Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Sandy Springs GA

Everything was great until we were handed the pie. The apple pie was pretty good, but the rest were raw. They were awful. Our family couldn’t even eat them. We only ate the apple one. They usually have samples to try out the back they made today, but they didn’t I guess because I want you to pay before you taste The awfulness It used to be great, but now it’s under new owners awful

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Apple Pie

There were a lot of pies to choose from. I tried the Pecan and Caramel Turtle, the pecan was my favorite. The worker was super nice and was happy to show me the seasonal flavors. I like the different size options and I really love the crust that was used. There was a coffee area but it's far too small to consider sitting down.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best key lime pie I've ever had, other than in the Florida Keys.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Key Lime Pie

So delicious! I bought a key lime pie, and a couple small peach pies that had a crumble topping.. and they were so good.. I would highly recommend..

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Key Lime Pie

Pie crust was not flaky enough.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

I don’t even eat pie like that, nor do I go looking for pie anywhere, but I can count on two hands how many times I’ve had pie from here in the past month. If I had a grandmother that made the best pie on Earth, I’d forgo her’s to get some from here

Delicious pecan & peanut butter pie!! Amazing customer service!! Stayed open past close because we wanted pie so badly at 9:05 pm. Haha!

The apple pie here is great!

Best pies 🥧 !!
Kimmie is so sweet & funny 😄
Place is clean & it smells so good !!
Employee is very nice !

Great pies

My husband and I came here on a whim and WOW! they had a gluten free option for me, a very welcome surprise. Not only were the pies delicious, but the owner Kimmie and her one employee were so incredible kind and attentive. We felt so well taken care of and welcomed. We will be back any time we are in the area and would 10/10 recommend!

We were in town for my wife’s doctor appointment and wanted a sweet treat before leaving Sandy Springs to head south. I looked up spots nearby and found the name “Buttermilk Sky Pie” very interesting and thought to check them out. With no expectations we walked in to be greeted by the jovial owner, Kimmee, who welcomed us immediately with a friendly shout from the back, as she hurried to leave the kitchen and assist us at the counter. She told us all about the different options and upon hearing me mention my wife was gluten-free and would not be eating, told us she had several flavors available for her! We also got to chat a bit about family, her origins in Korea and then the US, and immediately knew we would be back again next month. Her kind and warm spirit alone, made us want to support this local business-owner! And once we arrived home to try the pies we were blown away. Hands-down, one of THE BEST pecan pies I have ever eaten in my life. And my wife’s gluten-free key lime, was so good she forgot it wasn’t a regular pie. Kimmee’s staff was also super professional and welcoming, adding to the overall positive vibes and experience. 10/10 recommend enjoying some pie on a random evening when you’re in the area!!

I recently visited Buttermilk Sky Pie, and it was a delightful experience! I purchased their 4-inch pies, which are a great option if you're looking for something smaller than their regular-sized pies. I tried Granny's Apple, Key Lime, and the Spiced Apple Butter flavors, and I must say, each one was packed with flavor. The shop offers even more flavors to explore, and they kindly provide pie samples so you can find your favorite before committing. The customer service was fantastic - friendly and attentive staff made the experience even better. One thing to note is that the pies are very sweet. While delicious, I personally couldn't finish an entire 4-inch pie in one sitting. They're definitely worth sharing with a friend or saving for later. Overall, Buttermilk Sky Pie is a must-visit. I'm already looking forward to trying their other flavors!

Be safe and enjoy!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Key Lime Pie, Apple Pie

Took the kids to Activate, a gaming place across the street, so we stopped by and got a bunch of 4" pies. A touch pricey, but oh so good! Will definitely return anytime we are in the area.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This place is a dream and a curse for pre-diabetics like myself.

The key lime pie has the perfect custard because of its texture and fresh taste. I prefer lattice apple pies, but this place has me sold with the brown sugar crumble. The pecan pie 🥧 😋 filling was perfect. Overall, they secure a lovely balance of salt and sweet in all of their pies, so the fillings and crust marry well.

Dietary restrictions: They have gluten-free options, fyi.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Key Lime Pie, Apple Pie, Buttermilk Sky Pie, Pecan Mini Pie