McEntyre's Bakery

1184 Concord Rd SE UNIT 1, Smyrna
(770) 434-3115

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Paul

Fantastic ! Try their barbecue!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Judi McIntyre

Great people and great products!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Trina Schwalje

Best cakes and petite fours. A family holiday tradition. My adult son asks for and reminds every Christmas.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Yellow Layer Cake with Chocolate Fudge Icing, Carrot Cake, German Chocolate Cake, Old Fashioned Caramel Cake, Chicken Salad

Lauren Allen

Delicious…… just be mindful of sanitary practices like not talking over customers food items and not face touching when serving food items.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Allyson Teasley

I've ordered a few cakes from this bakery and they all were so good! I'm a yellow cake w/buttercream icing type of girl, so that's usually my go-to. Easy to order and great customer service. I'm so glad my coworker put me on to them. I haven't had a good cake like theirs in years.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

Lisa Witt

We had the eclairs, strawberry cake, white cake, carrot cake and apple donut. Everything was delicious and the staff was really considerate and helpful. We ate on a small patio outside. It was very nice.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Carrot Cake, Doughnut

MS.A

Great customer service when I went to pick up my cake.

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bakery

Southwest Franklinton

Good as gold! Super staff with absolutely amazing customer service . This is a terrific bakery ✅

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Doughnut

Claude E

The best donut but its has a lemon flavor so I don’t consider it plain

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Travis Schulz

Great local bakery. Kids love coming here for the kid meals. Great price on sandwiches

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Noreen McGinty

Never disappointed

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bakery, German Chocolate Cake, Birthday Cake

Kathy Omaits

In business since 1947!!!! You don’t survive that long without being solidly great. Good excellent bakery goods and sandwiches too. Local businesses are my jam!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Demetria Andreadis

TLDR: Paid $50 for a custom cake that didn't follow instructions

I called this bakery asking if they did burn cakes. The woman who picked up said they did, and we went into details about the burn cakes they've made, but then I learned they close annually the first 2 weeks of July. July 10 is my boss' birthday, so I was bummed. I later talked with my coworkers and we decided to surprise our boss 2 weeks early, wanting the burn cake.

I went in last Saturday and was told they actually don't do burn cakes. You'd have to provide the burn photo. That wasn't mentioned on the first phone call, implied they did a few of them because they are becoming popular. The young man in front of me that Saturday spoke honestly saying that they only did one, the customer provided the burn photo, and it didn't turn out well.

But he was excited to help me make this cake within their limits and spent about 15 minutes with me going over their cake options in their cake catalog. I asked if they had photos of previous cakes and he said the photos were from the 1980s, but a customer next to me swore they made fabulous cakes.

My boss and his wife love going to Orlando Studios during Halloween, and they loved Harry Potter. Our boss is Slytherin house. We wanted a burn cake to make his cake magical. That's okay, we compromised with a cake that would reflect his happiness at the park.

I wanted the carrot cake to represent them at the park and his Harry Potter house. I told the young man I didn't want characters like Harry on the cake. He said they have drawn the train and castle before and they could draw those along the side of my 2 layered cake.

I told him explicitly: I wanted their photo on the top with piped icing around the edge and **nothing else**, and I did *NOT* want those clear sprinkles on top because it looked like freezer ice shards. I told him green snakes, the train, the castle, and any other Harry Potter imagery the baker wanted to draw was fine.

He offered air brushed mermaid scales on the cake side to look like snake scales, as a background for the drawings. That was an awesome suggestion and I was excited to see that! He helped me greatly with verbally designing the cake.

I told him I wanted to edit their photo before I submitted it to him. He said as long as I emailed them before Tuesday (them being closed Sunday and Monday) that would be fine. I did ask if he needed to write these ideas down and he assured me he had it between his 2 notes.

Awesome, this cake sounds like it will be amazing! $50 worthy.

Tuesday comes and I call to confirm they have my emailed photo. The woman who picked up said they didn't receive it (the email was correct, I triple checked). I sent it again, same email address, and over an hour later she calls me to confirm they have it now. But now she can't find my order? I told her the man I spoke with had 2 sets of notes and when she asked I told her the cake was due tomorrow at 11am. She puts me on hold for 2 rounds, then comes back saying she found the notes and the cake will be ready tomorrow by 11am.

The next day I picked up the cake before my shift and the photos attached are what I was given. I did not ask for 2 chunky fondant "snakes". In fact I never mentioned wanting fondant. And there are those freezer frost sprinkles on top that I explicitly said I did not want.

For $50 this was a huge disappointment.

The cake tasted good.

I would recommend going in to buy pre-made baked goods to support local business.

I recommend NOT custom ordering from this bakery since they failed in following any directions and were misleading on what they offer vs what they actually do. Big break in trust with a first time customer.

Back to big chain bakeries for c

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 1

Cool Breeze

Love this place! I've been getting birthday cakes here for over thirty years and it's the only place I really want birthday cake from. Also got my wedding cakes made here and they were outstanding! Everything I've had from here is excellent and I've tried most desserts and some regular lunch items. The cake is super sweet but even if you can't finish a piece you'll keep going back for another until it's gone. The cupcakes are like mini versions of the cake and wonderful. I can't say enough great things about this place but highly recommend it to anyone seeking the best cakes and other delightful desserts!

Parking: Limited parking spaces but not usually busy enough to be an issue, at least when I go.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Red Velvet Cake, Carrot Cake, German Chocolate Cake, Birthday Cake, Cheese Straws

Kelly Hayes

Our go to for birthdays and special occasions. Everything from the cakes to sugar cookies, cheese straws and other baked goods are delicious. Love supporting local! I love carrot cake and theirs is phenomenal.

Loading...