Critters Outdoor Pizza

170 S Cherokee Rd, Social Circle
(678) 465-9625

Recent Reviews

Vinny Himes

The staff are kind and attentive, the crust is the best I've ever had. All the toppings and ingredients are fresh and delicious!Still amazing! This is our family's Friday night go to spot!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Domonique Campbell

What a cute little place with amazing customer service and just all around friendly vibes. Since I moved to Georgia from Jersey I’ve been looking for a place that has some decent thin crust pizza and I surely found it. I can’t rate what the “sit down restaurant” experience would’ve been because I only just walked in and ordered to go but in that brief interaction I had with the young lady that greeted me I felt really welcomed (I only regret not remembering her name). Pizza wise I literally couldn’t even take a picture of the whole thing because when I saw it I didn’t wanna wait to taste and before I knew it half was gone ?. Overall great brief and friendly experience I will definitely be going back ??

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: 20 in Pepperoni Pizza

Kevin Kelley

My visits here didn’t start off well because every time we ordered a pizza it was burnt, but lately they’ve done much better with their food preparation. Critter’s is definitely a lot better than my original impression and I think any pizza lover should give them a try,

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Kharaan Woods

Pizza is great!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jessica Nunez

Pizza is absolutely amazing. Best pizza in the area including Covington. Closest thing you will get to New York pizza around here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chris A

Best pizza in Morgan or Walton hands down

Bryce Laxson

Can't rate the food as I wasn't even able to place an order! Called twice just for it to ring once and be hung up on! Idk how people expect to run a business like this when you can't even be bothered to pick up the phone!

Service: 1

Aimee Maner

Best pizza place in Georgia! Great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

nate smith

The only problem we had with the pasta bowls where , 1 : they didn't have them before. Pizza great , bread sticks are awesome . Possums sauce is to die for .

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sauce, Cheese Bread, Cheese Pizza, 10 Trash Panda, Awesome Possum, Garlic, 20 in Pepperoni Pizza, 10 White Boy, 10 Smokey Says

Jennifer M.

Six stars! Seriously. We were so lucky to find this pizza joint in quaint Social Circle Ga, only seven minutes from I-20. Despite the name, there is indoor seating, although not quite as appealing as the outdoor area. Service was quick at 7:30pm with few customers but plenty of takeout orders. We thoroughly enjoyed the homemade gluten free brick oven crust (with quite crisp edges). The 10" was more like 12". We chose "veg out" and "white boy" and both were deliciously garlicky with amazingly fresh ingredients. The pizza was even more decadent with possum sauce - even more garlic with possibly sour cream - really delicious!

Ryan Anglin

Best pizza around! Nothing in Athens compares. The pizza crust is charred to perfection. Oven baked is the only way to go. Great atmosphere with a great server.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mullinax Mechanical

We love this pizza! It's always great!

Csaba Kis-Iván

Online order was super easy, when I went to pick up my order the staff was very friendly and kind. The pizza was very good! Thank you!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nikki Perry

Staff was fantastic, service was great, food was too greasy. Not my kind of pizza. I wouldn't eat here again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Jake Parker

My wife and I and 2 other couples decided to try Critters out this past Friday evening. I started following their Instagram and was intrigued by their message of high quality local sourced ingredients, and have been looking for a local pizza place near our home. However after our experience, I must say the hype did not live up to the reality for us. The first thing we noticed was that the health score was an 81. Although this isn’t the worst score, it’s also not the best. BUT if the pizza and service was on point that easily can be overlooked. Next concern for us was that it took over an hour to receive 2 cheese breads and 6 small pizzas. Again, easy to overlook if the pizza and service were good since it’s a Friday night and it’s busy. However once we did receive our pizzas it was not at the quality I’ve seen on their social media. 3 out of the 6 pizzas were an under-done sloppy mess. The toppings were hurriedly thrown on top with whole slices missing toppings. It appeared that they were being rushed out of the ovens and the quality suffered. We had to send back a whole pizza because of how under-done it was. The prices were also a little steep but again, easily overlooked for a quality pie. All of that to say, I believe this place has great potential and I would love for it to succeed. In my humble opinion, I think the efficiency in the kitchen needs to improve to get food out quicker but also make sure each pizza maintains a consistent quality. I don’t mind waiting for great pizza but it also shouldn’t take over an hour for thin crust pizzas. I hope the improvements are made because Critters has an amazing local pizza joint vibe. Consistency and efficiency is key.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Cheese Bread

Load More