Got the pickle pie and the jalapeño popper pie last night. They were both 10/10! Food was ready at time promised, cooked perfectly. Staff was friendly upon pick up. Very pleased with our order. Will definitely go back! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Alberto Miceli
Always great pizza, polite staff and always a great experience. Best pizza by far in Kungland or St. Marys
John Fedor
I just stopped in today and got a Margherita pie. if we're scoring based off of a New Haven, CT scale it's a 7.8. off a FL/GA scale it's 8.8 all day. nobody in the southern states has come close. it's a very good pie but not quite ready to sit at the same table as the big boys from New Haven. good job guys keep it up!
Gavin Harper
Went there for lunch and on top of an excellent pizza, we had a wonderful chat with the employee there, Jamie. Not only did she do a wonderful job making our pizza, but she was very friendly and made good conversation!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chance Bruce
While this style of pizza is not my preferred choice, both my wife and children loved it! It is New Haven style pizza, with Foxon Park sodas to boot! I will be returning so my wife can continue to taste home from so far away.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Foxon Park Soda, Italian Bomb
Gabe Fitzgerald
I first tried Yankee Pie Apizza the day they opened the food truck around 2 years ago and it was amazing, some of the best pizza I had in the south at the time. Recently I noticed they had an actual restaurant so I stopped in to check out the me u and have some of that great pizza I remembered. I was very disappointed when I got home and opened the boxes. I got a mootz and buffalo chicken pie. Both burnt, crust as thin as a crepe and little cheese. I also ordered 6 boneless wings, which ended up being bone-in. Very little sauce on the wings but they tasted good. I'm not sure if it was due to someone else cooking tonight but overall I am very disappointed. I had been really looking forward to the great pizza I remembered from the food truck.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
leanne Olivier
My family and I tried this pizza for the first time a couple weeks ago and loved it! We ordered again tonight and were very disappointed. Three of the five pizza’s we ordered were quite undercooked and soggy on the bottom. I was disappointed because the food was so very good the first time we ordered. I do think that they are one of the better pizza places locally, but would prefer consistency in the quality. I would like to add that the caprese salad is very good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
john bridges
All in all, the pizza was not very good. Thin burnt crust with lukewarm toppings at tourist attraction prices. Small area on the inside leaves a lot to be desired. While the service was fine and the area was clean I just cant recommend it based on a limited thin crust only menu that was poorly cooked.
Kid-friendliness: It was kid friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 3
Ricky Sarau
Incredible undercarriage, zero flop. New Haven style just the way I like it. One bite everybody knows the rules. Amazing pizza. Surprised the parking lot was empty. Drive an hour to try it and will be coming back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mr NeCr0
Owner has a real jersey shore vibe about him and is far more interested in hamming it up with the locals than helping his employees or his customers. The worst times to visit are when he is there ironically.
Dude is running for city council too, so I expect his political career will be similar. All talk while someone else does his work for him.
Last week I went to the Saint Marys water park and a very friendly dark-skinned guy helped me. It was a bit of a delay with the pizza but good service. However, today I went again so I went to buy pizza. I ordered 2 pepperoni pizzas and 5 soft drinks. Minutes later I ordered 1 more pizza and I told him that there were 3 in total and he spoke to me in a bad way that he almost broke the payment machine and he says to me: “Did you order one?” and I told him that I ordered 2 more, 1 was 3 and I went to the pool to wait. When I returned they gave me only 1 pizza and I told him that there were 3 since I don’t speak much English. How can I try to explain it to him? He puts 2 pizzas in the oven. I go to where my family is and since we had to leave, I tell my family to go over and pick up the pizzas and they give me only one, so I tell him that another one is missing and what I understand is that I sit down while the other pizza is ready. After a while I see that they are cleaning and closing, so I ask him how long it will take for the pizza and he starts telling me that he is not going to give me more pizza, that I only paid for 2 and that I am in the US and that I have to speak English already there, I think that his lack of respect exceeded my limit and my patience, I told him to look for the manager and he said no, so I went and looked for the manager of the place, she made him give me my money back, since I told the manager that he has 3 options, give me the pizza, the money or call the police, the least important thing is the pizza or the money but the discrimination against Latinos, the bad time of my family, especially my children, the one who served me was a white man with tattoos, I hope they do something about respect with this man, the manager of Saint Marys and his workers are excellent people and incredible service, without a doubt I would recommend Saint Marys Aquatic 100% it is a very nice and pleasant place to spend with the family, but I would not recommend Yankee Pie Apizza
Elaine R
Great pizza reminded us of home!! Being from Connecticut we were excited to find this place while vacationing in St Marys Ga. We now live Florida and are always on the hunt for a good pizza joint. Yankee Pie Apizza did not disappoint great tasting thin crunchy crust with plenty of toppings the young lady who took care of us wasgreat
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Josh Proctor
I prefer the carryout option for this local Pizza Joint. Get it to go and walk down to the waterfront park for a dining experience that surpasses most. My preference is the Cristin's Special Pie, a unique flavor unlike anything you can find at the other pizza places.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Cristen's Special with Sausage
Mary Jane May
My husband is in hospice care and once a month Yankee Pia Apizza donates a dinner to a hospice patient and family. Tonight a volunteer delivered a salad two pizzas and 4 bottles of water. It was graciously accepted and so thankful. Please buy local. They are the best. Thank you so much!!
Wayne and Mary Jane May
My husband is in hospice care and once a month Yankee Pia Apizza donates a dinner to a hospice patient and family. Tonight a volunteer delivered a salad two pizzas and 4 bottles of water. It was graciously accepted and so thankful. Please buy local. They are the best. Thank you so much!!
Got the pickle pie and the jalapeño popper pie last night. They were both 10/10! Food was ready at time promised, cooked perfectly. Staff was friendly upon pick up. Very pleased with our order. Will definitely go back! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Always great pizza, polite staff and always a great experience. Best pizza by far in Kungland or St. Marys
I just stopped in today and got a Margherita pie. if we're scoring based off of a New Haven, CT scale it's a 7.8. off a FL/GA scale it's 8.8 all day. nobody in the southern states has come close. it's a very good pie but not quite ready to sit at the same table as the big boys from New Haven. good job guys keep it up!
Went there for lunch and on top of an excellent pizza, we had a wonderful chat with the employee there, Jamie. Not only did she do a wonderful job making our pizza, but she was very friendly and made good conversation!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
While this style of pizza is not my preferred choice, both my wife and children loved it! It is New Haven style pizza, with Foxon Park sodas to boot! I will be returning so my wife can continue to taste home from so far away.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Foxon Park Soda, Italian Bomb
I first tried Yankee Pie Apizza the day they opened the food truck around 2 years ago and it was amazing, some of the best pizza I had in the south at the time. Recently I noticed they had an actual restaurant so I stopped in to check out the me u and have some of that great pizza I remembered. I was very disappointed when I got home and opened the boxes. I got a mootz and buffalo chicken pie. Both burnt, crust as thin as a crepe and little cheese. I also ordered 6 boneless wings, which ended up being bone-in. Very little sauce on the wings but they tasted good. I'm not sure if it was due to someone else cooking tonight but overall I am very disappointed. I had been really looking forward to the great pizza I remembered from the food truck.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
My family and I tried this pizza for the first time a couple weeks ago and loved it! We ordered again tonight and were very disappointed. Three of the five pizza’s we ordered were quite undercooked and soggy on the bottom. I was disappointed because the food was so very good the first time we ordered. I do think that they are one of the better pizza places locally, but would prefer consistency in the quality. I would like to add that the caprese salad is very good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
All in all, the pizza was not very good. Thin burnt crust with lukewarm toppings at tourist attraction prices. Small area on the inside leaves a lot to be desired. While the service was fine and the area was clean I just cant recommend it based on a limited thin crust only menu that was poorly cooked.
Kid-friendliness: It was kid friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 3
Incredible undercarriage, zero flop. New Haven style just the way I like it. One bite everybody knows the rules. Amazing pizza. Surprised the parking lot was empty. Drive an hour to try it and will be coming back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Owner has a real jersey shore vibe about him and is far more interested in hamming it up with the locals than helping his employees or his customers. The worst times to visit are when he is there ironically.
Dude is running for city council too, so I expect his political career will be similar. All talk while someone else does his work for him.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Last week I went to the Saint Marys water park and a very friendly dark-skinned guy helped me. It was a bit of a delay with the pizza but good service. However, today I went again so I went to buy pizza. I ordered 2 pepperoni pizzas and 5 soft drinks. Minutes later I ordered 1 more pizza and I told him that there were 3 in total and he spoke to me in a bad way that he almost broke the payment machine and he says to me: “Did you order one?” and I told him that I ordered 2 more, 1 was 3 and I went to the pool to wait. When I returned they gave me only 1 pizza and I told him that there were 3 since I don’t speak much English. How can I try to explain it to him? He puts 2 pizzas in the oven. I go to where my family is and since we had to leave, I tell my family to go over and pick up the pizzas and they give me only one, so I tell him that another one is missing and what I understand is that I sit down while the other pizza is ready. After a while I see that they are cleaning and closing, so I ask him how long it will take for the pizza and he starts telling me that he is not going to give me more pizza, that I only paid for 2 and that I am in the US and that I have to speak English already there, I think that his lack of respect exceeded my limit and my patience, I told him to look for the manager and he said no, so I went and looked for the manager of the place, she made him give me my money back, since I told the manager that he has 3 options, give me the pizza, the money or call the police, the least important thing is the pizza or the money but the discrimination against Latinos, the bad time of my family, especially my children, the one who served me was a white man with tattoos, I hope they do something about respect with this man, the manager of Saint Marys and his workers are excellent people and incredible service, without a doubt I would recommend Saint Marys Aquatic 100% it is a very nice and pleasant place to spend with the family, but I would not recommend Yankee Pie Apizza
Great pizza reminded us of home!! Being from Connecticut we were excited to find this place while vacationing in St Marys Ga. We now live Florida and are always on the hunt for a good pizza joint. Yankee Pie Apizza did not disappoint great tasting thin crunchy crust with plenty of toppings the young lady who took care of us wasgreat
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I prefer the carryout option for this local Pizza Joint. Get it to go and walk down to the waterfront park for a dining experience that surpasses most. My preference is the Cristin's Special Pie, a unique flavor unlike anything you can find at the other pizza places.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Cristen's Special with Sausage
My husband is in hospice care and once a month Yankee Pia Apizza donates a dinner to a hospice patient and family. Tonight a volunteer delivered a salad two pizzas and 4 bottles of water. It was graciously accepted and so thankful. Please buy local. They are the best. Thank you so much!!
My husband is in hospice care and once a month Yankee Pia Apizza donates a dinner to a hospice patient and family. Tonight a volunteer delivered a salad two pizzas and 4 bottles of water. It was graciously accepted and so thankful. Please buy local. They are the best. Thank you so much!!
Loading...