Stopped by for the first time today and was not disappointed. Owners were super friendly and accommodating (I must have asked 100 questions about their place😉). Pizza was fantastic!!! No short cuts taken here. Can’t wait to get back here.
Dylan Stevely
Horrible business hours and limited quantities available. We all understand it’s a good pizza but the availability is just horrible and a waste of time trying , if they can operate like a normal pizza place I will change my review
Mike Ketcherick
Excellent pizza, Regardless of what ya get, be sure to get a plain cheese pie, ya get a true taste of the base pizza. It's completely worthy of the great score they got from Dave Portnoy. Will definitely be back as long as I win the telephone sweepstakes getting a hold of them. Well worth the effort!!
Thanks!!
John Mangia
The pizza is delicious. I highly recommend.
Pete Schuessler
Great pizza and owners but they lost my business. I can make a complete dinner for how long it takes on the phone trying to get thru after they got a great review on a popular social media site. I just spent 40 mins calling nonstop to get a message they're sold out. No pizza is worth that amount of effort. I wish them the best, but time to find another pizza joint or make our own from delicious sourdough pizza dough made locally.
Jim Mutnik
High Quality Pizza with fresh ingredients. Owners are Super Friendly. Must try Spot.
Yalanda Bibbins
They don't open at 4pm never open on time. I don't think they really care but you lose customers like this.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Evon Johnson
I love it, flavor great and if u warm up a pizza after having it in ur fridge it still taste
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chris Harris
Veggie Stromboli
Food: 5
Travis Grillot
I don't usually leave reviews but unfortunately I couldn't not leave one for this place. I love pizza. Thick crust, thin crust, deep dish and everything in between. Usually pizza, like many awesome things in life, is good even when it's bad. Not so with Moonlight Pizza in Stone Mountain. I don't know if we just caught them on a bad day or if this is the way it always is, but it was so bad I don't care to find out. The cheese bread was like gritty cardboard. The pizza, soggy cardboard. It seemed like they took cheese product and tomato sauce and threw it together in a blender and then dumped that slurry on a puddle of poorly mixed water and flower and baked it for five minutes. We got wings too. They were at least edible, but I know 3 wing places within a block of this place that are better. The pizza and cheese bread though, me and my SO each ate one slice and threw rest away. I'm sad that pizza this bad exists.
Ordered a large meatlover taste ok. Glad we got another alternative to Lil Caesars in the hood. The ladies were sweethearts here, customer service was great. Only downside would be I didn't know they had pizza here thought it was a fish and wings spot, if you go by the signs.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Build Your Own Pizza
Sebastian Orrego-Jimenez
Ordered the chicken parm with bolognese (meat) sauce. Tell me why there was mushroom onions peppers all up in it when it didn’t say anything about that on the menu. The meat in the sauce had barley had any flavor to it. Chicken was gross, tasted like Tyson’s frozen chicken Patties but soggy. Will not be back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 5
Christopher Mejia
It was my first time eating here, the wings were nice and fresh and the flavor was so good. Pizza was also super
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
DC Coop
Ordered a large meatlover taste ok. Glad we got another alternative to Lil Caesars in the hood. The ladies were sweethearts here, customer service was great. Only downside would be I didn't know they had pizza here thought it was a fish and wings spot, if you go by the signs.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Build Your Own Pizza
Carolyn Blair
They barely answer the phone. I was told I can not order over the phone. The online menu doesn’t have all the options. This place isn’t a convenience. The food is good but the wait is not & the area isn’t a place I feel comfortable sitting and waiting especially when I want it to be grab & go. It is going down the drain already it was a good and convenient when you had the option of calling in even though it took many calls to get an answer
Stopped by for the first time today and was not disappointed. Owners were super friendly and accommodating (I must have asked 100 questions about their place😉). Pizza was fantastic!!! No short cuts taken here. Can’t wait to get back here.
Horrible business hours and limited quantities available. We all understand it’s a good pizza but the availability is just horrible and a waste of time trying , if they can operate like a normal pizza place I will change my review
Excellent pizza, Regardless of what ya get, be sure to get a plain cheese pie, ya get a true taste of the base pizza. It's completely worthy of the great score they got from Dave Portnoy. Will definitely be back as long as I win the telephone sweepstakes getting a hold of them. Well worth the effort!! Thanks!!
The pizza is delicious. I highly recommend.
Great pizza and owners but they lost my business. I can make a complete dinner for how long it takes on the phone trying to get thru after they got a great review on a popular social media site. I just spent 40 mins calling nonstop to get a message they're sold out. No pizza is worth that amount of effort. I wish them the best, but time to find another pizza joint or make our own from delicious sourdough pizza dough made locally.
High Quality Pizza with fresh ingredients. Owners are Super Friendly. Must try Spot.
They don't open at 4pm never open on time. I don't think they really care but you lose customers like this.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
I love it, flavor great and if u warm up a pizza after having it in ur fridge it still taste
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Veggie Stromboli
Food: 5
I don't usually leave reviews but unfortunately I couldn't not leave one for this place. I love pizza. Thick crust, thin crust, deep dish and everything in between. Usually pizza, like many awesome things in life, is good even when it's bad. Not so with Moonlight Pizza in Stone Mountain. I don't know if we just caught them on a bad day or if this is the way it always is, but it was so bad I don't care to find out. The cheese bread was like gritty cardboard. The pizza, soggy cardboard. It seemed like they took cheese product and tomato sauce and threw it together in a blender and then dumped that slurry on a puddle of poorly mixed water and flower and baked it for five minutes. We got wings too. They were at least edible, but I know 3 wing places within a block of this place that are better. The pizza and cheese bread though, me and my SO each ate one slice and threw rest away. I'm sad that pizza this bad exists.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Ordered a large meatlover taste ok. Glad we got another alternative to Lil Caesars in the hood. The ladies were sweethearts here, customer service was great. Only downside would be I didn't know they had pizza here thought it was a fish and wings spot, if you go by the signs.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Build Your Own Pizza
Ordered the chicken parm with bolognese (meat) sauce. Tell me why there was mushroom onions peppers all up in it when it didn’t say anything about that on the menu. The meat in the sauce had barley had any flavor to it. Chicken was gross, tasted like Tyson’s frozen chicken Patties but soggy. Will not be back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 5
It was my first time eating here, the wings were nice and fresh and the flavor was so good. Pizza was also super
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a large meatlover taste ok. Glad we got another alternative to Lil Caesars in the hood. The ladies were sweethearts here, customer service was great. Only downside would be I didn't know they had pizza here thought it was a fish and wings spot, if you go by the signs.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Build Your Own Pizza
They barely answer the phone. I was told I can not order over the phone. The online menu doesn’t have all the options. This place isn’t a convenience. The food is good but the wait is not & the area isn’t a place I feel comfortable sitting and waiting especially when I want it to be grab & go. It is going down the drain already it was a good and convenient when you had the option of calling in even though it took many calls to get an answer
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Wings, Build Your Own Pizza
Loading...