Cole's Cakery

137 Love Ave, Tifton
(229) 396-5565

Recent Reviews

Laura Coates

We were visiting from out of town and one of my kids with a gluten and dairy allergy had a birthday and we wanted some cupcakes to celebrate! They were very responsive and made sure to accommodate our allergies! Cupcakes were delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jennifer Ford

Oh. My. Goodness! I just experienced these lovely morsels of deliciousness, today! It's my birthday and my thoughtful boss, and his wife, graciously purchased a mixed dozen for myself and a few of my coworkers to enjoy. Man, these cupcakes were the bomb dot com ! I will be coming to purchase more!

jeresa ellison

I had a last minute cake emergency for my sister's gender reveal and Mr. Jimmy saved the day. He made the cake with less than 24hr notice and it was beautiful and delicious. Also the cashier was such a sweet young lady. Thank you Mr.Jimmy and staff. This is for sure my new favorite cake place!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stacey Clanton

I am very disappointed. $135 for a birthday cake that turned out as well as i could have had done at publics. This is quality and size.

j b

Really good cupcakes. Excellent service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Grace Learned

A last minute 10 layer cake for my family ! Great people!My favorite new place in

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cupcakes, Chocolate Covered

Larry Cutsail (Larry)

The only thing my wife wanted for her birthday, was a German Chocolate cake from Cole's. Jimmy did a fantastic job on it, and the cake looked great! It tasted even better! The icing wasn't too sweet, like many we've tried, but was just right! He went above and beyond for us, coming in on Monday when they were closed and made it for her special occasion. I am forever grateful, and they have earned a customer for life.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Judy Pate

The chocolate 12 layer cake is awesome. The best chocolate cake I have ever

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Billy Frank

They did a terrific job..Price was good and the cake was a hit..

joan-e stinson

I'VE NEVER TRIED THIS PLACE! Just putting that first I was just hoping to reach the the owners and let them know their brownie pictures on door dash make me not want to order they aught to look a little more moist then what they look like now!

Miguel

Great place to pick up some lunch or some cupcakes! I absolutely love stopping by for a chicken salad here! And their selection of cupcakes is really good too I always get a few to share!

Jose Perez

It was very pleasant and positive. Staff were very cheerful and nice. All of the cakes were delicious. We bought about 9 different kinds.

Turkesa Mclean

Gave 3 because of the service and the food. I'm new in town and I really don't expect much, but if I appear to be visiting, and this is just me, I would think that no matter what color you're skin is or what size you are you would render great service. Word of mouth is your best advertisement. I felt a little unwelcomed and I don't think I'll be back nor will I doordash again from them

Angelica York

Getting my wedding cake from them. The tasting was great, the cakes were all amazing!

Brittman Matkowsky

I came to town for Christmas and my sister bought a Red Velvet and a Chocolate Chocolate Cake and they are both AWESOME! I'm biased toward the Chocolate Chocolate cake because growing up I always had that for my birthday. Well this Cake took me back to my childhood growing up and I've eaten more than my fare share of it. Now I'm going to have to work out extra hard to work off all the delicious cake I've devoured! Thanks Coles! ? ? ?

Load More