Such great food and the server was as sweet as pie.. I would recommend to anyone visiting Maui
Thomas Soptick
Great burgers, shakes, and service. Cute 50s decor. Highly recommend!
Carter Pulsipher
Went there just to get ice cream and very friendly staff gave us multiple samples. Ice cream was really good and the coconut is a must. A good place to go and cool looking retro diner!
Leilani Angel Vasquez
For starters, server came to us not without introducing himself. I was with my friends and after we placed our orders, he snatched the menus off our hands in a rude way. After our meal, we were paying for our meals and my friends were doing Apple Pay and card. When it came to the tips option, our server was looking on our screen on how much tip we were going to put, is that how servers supposed to do their job? Also one of my friends were confused on where to tap her card and apologized to our server, and the server responded to her “sorry for what” in a rude way. Me and my friends were also outside and our server opened the restaurant door in an aggressive way and approached me and slammed the bill saying my amount was wrong. Of course I apologized and gave him the correct amount and said to keep the change. Our server then fake laughed and walked away shaking his head.
What the server looked like: - long curly hair, shoulder length - has a mustache & beard - has an accent, looks Latin? - skinny
Rick DeLisi
I ordered the fish mahi burger / sandwich. They said it was a mahi filet more like a fish stick in the middle of a bun … taste was horrible worse then it looked. Would not recommend my daughter said the hot dog was burnt and nasty didn’t finish it. Sad effort from the chef.
C Clair
Went there roaches on the floor crawling on my feet. The burgers taste like they're old or gamey. Two people working. Do the island a favor and shut that place down
Brooke
The place is very cute but the staff are a bit impatient. Food was good, fries are for sure of one the best items to get. Milkshakes are good too!
Connie McLean
We come here every year for their Patty Melt. I’m a Patty Melt snob and these are the best! Gauda was a wonderful server!
Angelica Dail
I’ve come to Peggy Sue’s quite a few times over the years. My first impression after not being there in a while was this place looks really rundown. Although, the servers are always polite and welcoming.
However, there’s a miscommunication between them and their cooks. I have a specific allergy that I make very clear to them every time I go. Quite a few times I have gotten my food back with the seasoning that I requested not be put on my food due to the fact that it makes me ill.
Furthermore, their sign in their door doesn’t match the price at the register which I find a bait and switch. I requested my onions to be grilled, but they tried to charge me $2 more dollars for that.
The server gave me the wrong drink, but luckily caught it in time. She didn’t check my food to make sure my allergy was taken care of. Lastly, the quality of the food just wasn’t great. My burger was soggy, my tomatoes were overly ripe, and my fries overly seasoned with garlic. I didn’t even finish my meal.
Great restaurant, like in the 60s. Food great. Service very friendly. We really liked it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tony Schöne
The food was delicious, the colleague at the service was probably a bit confused that day, but no problem, I got my drink after asking and we both got cutlery. ;)
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Michał Klecz
Everything is fine and dandy, but the owners should think about better air extraction from the kitchen. After eating on site, the clothes can be washed with an additional amount of scented liquid.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
CM McPhail
Great burgers and awesome milkshakes, the guys working their are friendly; the atmosphere is retro, (love it), overall a great time, definitely worth checking out
Parking: Easy to get to from our hotel in Kihei, good location
Kid-friendliness: Families with children came in while we dining and got ice cream cones, others were enjoying the burger and fries
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burger&Fries, Burger
Christine C
Patty melt and sweet potato fries were delicious. Definitely stop in for a bite.
Such great food and the server was as sweet as pie.. I would recommend to anyone visiting
Maui
Great burgers, shakes, and service. Cute 50s decor. Highly recommend!
Went there just to get ice cream and very friendly staff gave us multiple samples. Ice cream was really good and the coconut is a must. A good place to go and cool looking retro diner!
For starters, server came to us not without introducing himself. I was with my friends and after we placed our orders, he snatched the menus off our hands in a rude way. After our meal, we were paying for our meals and my friends were doing Apple Pay and card. When it came to the tips option, our server was looking on our screen on how much tip we were going to put, is that how servers supposed to do their job? Also one of my friends were confused on where to tap her card and apologized to our server, and the server responded to her “sorry for what” in a rude way. Me and my friends were also outside and our server opened the restaurant door in an aggressive way and approached me and slammed the bill saying my amount was wrong. Of course I apologized and gave him the correct amount and said to keep the change. Our server then fake laughed and walked away shaking his head.
What the server looked like:
- long curly hair, shoulder length
- has a mustache & beard
- has an accent, looks Latin?
- skinny
I ordered the fish mahi burger / sandwich. They said it was a mahi filet more like a fish stick in the middle of a bun … taste was horrible worse then it looked. Would not recommend my daughter said the hot dog was burnt and nasty didn’t finish it. Sad effort from the chef.
Went there roaches on the floor crawling on my feet. The burgers taste like they're old or gamey. Two people working. Do the island a favor and shut that place down
The place is very cute but the staff are a bit impatient. Food was good, fries are for sure of one the best items to get. Milkshakes are good too!
We come here every year for their Patty Melt. I’m a Patty Melt snob and these are the best! Gauda was a wonderful server!
I’ve come to Peggy Sue’s quite a few times over the years. My first impression after not being there in a while was this place looks really rundown. Although, the servers are always polite and welcoming.
However, there’s a miscommunication between them and their cooks. I have a specific allergy that I make very clear to them every time I go. Quite a few times I have gotten my food back with the seasoning that I requested not be put on my food due to the fact that it makes me ill.
Furthermore, their sign in their door doesn’t match the price at the register which I find a bait and switch. I requested my onions to be grilled, but they tried to charge me $2 more dollars for that.
The server gave me the wrong drink, but luckily caught it in time. She didn’t check my food to make sure my allergy was taken care of. Lastly, the quality of the food just wasn’t great. My burger was soggy, my tomatoes were overly ripe, and my fries overly seasoned with garlic. I didn’t even finish my meal.
Real and good burger ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Great restaurant, like in the 60s. Food great.
Service very friendly.
We really liked it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food was delicious, the colleague at the service was probably a bit confused that day, but no problem, I got my drink after asking and we both got cutlery. ;)
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Everything is fine and dandy, but the owners should think about better air extraction from the kitchen. After eating on site, the clothes can be washed with an additional amount of scented liquid.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great burgers and awesome milkshakes, the guys working their are friendly; the atmosphere is retro, (love it), overall a great time, definitely worth checking out
Parking: Easy to get to from our hotel in Kihei, good location
Kid-friendliness: Families with children came in while we dining and got ice cream cones, others were enjoying the burger and fries
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burger&Fries, Burger
Patty melt and sweet potato fries were delicious. Definitely stop in for a bite.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Loading...