Hall of Fame Pizza & Wings

The food was absolutely delicious. Best pizza burger I have ever had. Also strongly suggest trying the garlic parmesan fries. Kids loved the pizza, all around amazing. Great place will definitely go back.

The pizza is always good!

How the hell is this place still in business? It’s a takeout joint that somehow can’t handle people ordering food. That’s like going to a dentist who’s scared of teeth. You’ve got two people working—two!—and you’re six orders deep already, but hey, let’s keep taking more orders. Because who needs logic when you’ve got blind optimism, right?

I waited over an hour and a half for a freakin’ pizza. A pizza! Not a crown roast. Not a wedding cake. Dough, sauce, cheese—how hard is it?! Management, let me ask you something: you do understand basic math, right? Like if two people can make four pizzas an hour, maybe don’t accept eleven more orders unless you’re training a raccoon to help out in the back?

If counting is that hard, take off your shoes and start using your toes. Or better yet, just stop pretending you run a restaurant and open a museum of disappointment. You’re halfway there already.

The boneless wings are fire and the sweet women at the counters service was just as on point.

Best wings 🫰

I just picked up a pepperoni pizza and I would have done better to stop at HyVee and picked up a Jack’s frozen pizza. No wonder they are ready in 10 minutes. Casey’s is way better!! This was a waste of money.

Thai Pie flatbread is the best! We have never been disappointed with any of the food from Hall of Fame in Eldridge.

I ordered this pizza from Eldridge, I cannot tell you how wonderful this pizza turned out to be. I was vegetarian years ago and prefer that type of pizza. I lived in Chicago for quite a while and have never found a pizza, vegetarian that was this amazing!!! Order now, it is perfect!!!

Food: 5

Passing through and ordered pizza and boneless wings. Food was delicious and reasonably priced. Service was friendly and fast.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Taco, 12 Wings

The pizza never have enough sauce on the crust. The pepperoni is burnt, and it’s cold and greasy. The manager is very rude and argumentative.

Great place, food and staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Buffalo Wings, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, 12 Wings

I ordered a large. Garlic chicken bacon ranch. This was the worst driest pizza I've ever had from Hall of Fame. I choked it down.I will not order it again. It must have been a fluke. I love there pizza

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 5

We ordered HoF for the first time last night. I had The Wizard and garlic bread. I was impressed by the quality and taste of everything. The staff member that assisted me was polite and friendly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great food. Very impressed. Reasonable prices and good service. Will absolutely be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5