Italian Cowboy Cafe

502 3rd Ave, Sheldon
(712) 631-4222

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jamie Van Roekel

Excellent in all ways!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joyce Fedders

I have never had a bad meal or sweet treat from here since I started going there. The meatloaf is awesome,as are the potatoes served with it. The flatbreads are out of this world and I usually take half home. The caramel cinnamon rolls are heavenly and melt in your mouth. Have also gotten their smoked ribs and tasty and tender. Love the friendly staff and quiet atmosphere. Will keep supporting them. Try it, you will like it!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kim Bonestroo Van Tilburg

Food was mouth watering. Atmosphere can’t be beat. The owner is one of the sweetest personable people around . Would recommend to anyone go check this place out.

Dan Rollison

Great service.

Jan Schilling

Ate dinner on 2-5-2022. No menu only buffet. Food was luke warm and not much to choose from. Not good at all.

Blanca Boom-Struyk

Is therapy was amazing. Went out to eat there 1st time in a long time and all was it so good.

sxyfkr77

Thought we would give breakfast a try since we tried supper back when they first opened. Sadly food was worse then the first visit, which wasn't very good either. Atmosphere felt very cluttered and hard to relax yet we were the only ones there. We didn't think the general store blended well with the restaurant setting.

Adrianne Aulenbach

Thought we would give breakfast a try since we tried supper back when they first opened. Sadly food was worse then the first visit, which wasn't very good either. Atmosphere felt very cluttered and hard to relax yet we were the only ones there. We didn't think the general store blended well with the restaurant setting.

scott shiner

The place was odd to say the very least. The decor itself is that of a bar. Lots of taxidermy and lots of skulls and horns. It also has a little garage sale in the back with not so garage sale prices. The menu, again odd. Don't know what to make of a menu that had egg salad, tuna salad, bologna sandwich, peanut butter and jelly or a BLT. I guess just not what I wanted for lunch. I wanted to try the daily special as it was lasagna day but when the waitress couldn't explain what the gravy is they put on it, I was out. They also make fresh pies for sale. What kind? Who knows. The menu doesn't tell you.

Nora Miller

The buffet is amazing!

Kristen Kleinwolterink

Great food and friendly service!!

Chuck Smidstra

Excellent experience!

Aaron Boone

Food was good

Shawn Todd

It a very nice place to eat

Karla Schnepf-Hanna

Alfredo pasta was great. Large portion. Had a side salad and bread. Plan on taking some home. Nice and quiet when we were in there. Great staff !

Loading...