My boys loved it! Great food. Fresh and delicious!
Rita Cooper
All i can say is all you can eat!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Korbin Funriss
My experience was shitty, we made a reservation only for them to not actually reserve it if they get a bit busy. The food is always pretty good but it's often loud and popular.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Oreo Pizza
Zack Killeen (Zack)
I’ve gone to pizza pie cafe almost my entire life the desert pizzas are the best the pizzas good and the soda hits different
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brenden Benjamin
Love all of the Pizza Pie locations!! Almost always the most delicious food!! Ate here recently and I think we caught it at a weird time because the pizzas all seemed dried out and the crusts were pretty hard. The pasta was amazing like always though! Always worth eating here!! Staff are always amazing!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Kraig Reid
Very good food and atmosphere
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Levi Vanmiddendorp
I love the pizza and the pasta here, but the whoever was running the pasta has a horrible attitude. When my little sister walked up there he rolled his eye. Like sorry she’s making you do your job. And slams the pasta lid and plate. worst attitude I’ve ever witnessed in a food industry.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Kiel Moser
Food is ok. Salad and dessert are the only good things. For some reason, the savory pizza has a sweet taste to it. Don't know if it's because of staff failure or the food itself, but it ruins the entire thing for me.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Noah Lloyd
This pizza pie Café location is so much better than the Rexburg location. My wife and I came late at night to enjoy some pizza buffet but this time the pizza was tasting absolutely delicious. More than it ever has in Rexburg. The pizza tasted pretty fresh, considering it was a buffet. A few things that tasted like they had been sitting out for a while for example, there were these Oreo knot looking things and they looked delicious but then when we tasted them, they tasted stale and like they had been sitting out for a long time.
The pizzas that I would say are definite must: The combo pizza, Hawaiian pizza, the firefighter And my wife enjoyed the potato pizza. We were sad not to see the barbecue chicken pizza there this time as it’s one of my favorites.
One of the pizzas that we did not like is the buffalo wing pizza. To me it tasted like they had put panda express orange chicken sauce on the pizza and it just tasted weird.
For the dessert pizzas they have many options. They have the Oreo pizza, cookie dough, raspberry pizza, apple pizza, and a peach cobbler pizza. This time they even had a special of the Month pizza which was the s’mores pizza. It was delicious. Best dessert, pizza that we’ve ever had at Pizza pie Café. Dare I say best dessert pizza I’ve ever had.
If you ever get tired of pizza, they also offer a salad bar buffet as well as a pasta buffet. We did try a few of the pasta sauces. The best one was the carbonara, followed by the roasted red pepper, marinara, and Alfredo. The Alfredo just tasted kind of plain and boring. The pasta bar also has many different types of pasta, such as angel hair, fettuccine, wagon wheel, etc..
The salad bar is also another great option. They have different kinds of salad mixes such as spring mix and an iceberg mix. They have many different toppings, such as pepperoni, bacon, peppers, ham, egg, tomato, etc. They also have different dressing such as Italian ranch thousand Island, cottage cheese, etc..
Overall, if you have never been to pizza pie café or I’ve never been to this location I highly recommend checking it out. One of the best times to go is during lunch as the price is 10.49 for adult adults. Dinner is 11.59. This restaurant does offer special pricing for seniors and military. If you also are thinking about hosting a birthday party here they do have a private room that is free.
Its okay! We visit at least once a year while visiting family because it has options for everyone. The vegetarians get salad, the meat eaters get meat pizzas and pasta sauces.
The only thing I don't appreciate is the immediate asking for a tip when you check in & pay. I'm all for tipping when I'm given service. Here, you order at the counter, get your own food & drinks and we bussed our own table. Not once did someone walk around picking up the empty, used dishes. We had to find the bin and take them ourselves. So why am I being asked for a tip?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Bethany Nelson
When you all don't want the same kind of pizza this is a place where everyone can walk away happy. They also have yummy pasta options and a nice salad bar area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Janet Curtis
Wonderful place to have a Birthday party 🎈. Thank you so much for all your help providing what we needed like picking up dishes we were finished with and getting the high chairs we needed. Thank you for all your help!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza and Salad, Pizza of the Month
melissadc76
This place is still reasonable in price and the food is pretty good buffet style eating. Parking is easy, kid-friendly. I mostly eat the salad bar and the kids like the pizza, pasta, drinks, and dessert. My only complaint is the lack of tables. Almost every time we go there, we have to sit at a dirty table and ask someone to clear and clean it for us.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Merlady Idaho
Pizza was cold. Like not even a little warm. You can tell it had been sitting there forever. It also had a slightly weird tastes to most of them. Employeees barely acknowledge you except for the lady cleaning for some reason.
My boys loved it! Great food. Fresh and delicious!
All i can say is all you can eat!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My experience was shitty, we made a reservation only for them to not actually reserve it if they get a bit busy. The food is always pretty good but it's often loud and popular.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Oreo Pizza
I’ve gone to pizza pie cafe almost my entire life the desert pizzas are the best the pizzas good and the soda hits different
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love all of the Pizza Pie locations!! Almost always the most delicious food!! Ate here recently and I think we caught it at a weird time because the pizzas all seemed dried out and the crusts were pretty hard. The pasta was amazing like always though! Always worth eating here!! Staff are always amazing!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Very good food and atmosphere
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
I love the pizza and the pasta here, but the whoever was running the pasta has a horrible attitude. When my little sister walked up there he rolled his eye. Like sorry she’s making you do your job. And slams the pasta lid and plate. worst attitude I’ve ever witnessed in a food industry.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Food is ok. Salad and dessert are the only good things. For some reason, the savory pizza has a sweet taste to it. Don't know if it's because of staff failure or the food itself, but it ruins the entire thing for me.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
This pizza pie Café location is so much better than the Rexburg location. My wife and I came late at night to enjoy some pizza buffet but this time the pizza was tasting absolutely delicious. More than it ever has in Rexburg. The pizza tasted pretty fresh, considering it was a buffet. A few things that tasted like they had been sitting out for a while for example, there were these Oreo knot looking things and they looked delicious but then when we tasted them, they tasted stale and like they had been sitting out for a long time.
The pizzas that I would say are definite must:
The combo pizza, Hawaiian pizza, the firefighter And my wife enjoyed the potato pizza. We were sad not to see the barbecue chicken pizza there this time as it’s one of my favorites.
One of the pizzas that we did not like is the buffalo wing pizza. To me it tasted like they had put panda express orange chicken sauce on the pizza and it just tasted weird.
For the dessert pizzas they have many options. They have the Oreo pizza, cookie dough, raspberry pizza, apple pizza, and a peach cobbler pizza. This time they even had a special of the Month pizza which was the s’mores pizza. It was delicious. Best dessert, pizza that we’ve ever had at Pizza pie Café. Dare I say best dessert pizza I’ve ever had.
If you ever get tired of pizza, they also offer a salad bar buffet as well as a pasta buffet. We did try a few of the pasta sauces. The best one was the carbonara, followed by the roasted red pepper, marinara, and Alfredo. The Alfredo just tasted kind of plain and boring. The pasta bar also has many different types of pasta, such as angel hair, fettuccine, wagon wheel, etc..
The salad bar is also another great option. They have different kinds of salad mixes such as spring mix and an iceberg mix. They have many different toppings, such as pepperoni, bacon, peppers, ham, egg, tomato, etc. They also have different dressing such as Italian ranch thousand Island, cottage cheese, etc..
Overall, if you have never been to pizza pie café or I’ve never been to this location I highly recommend checking it out. One of the best times to go is during lunch as the price is 10.49 for adult adults. Dinner is 11.59. This restaurant does offer special pricing for seniors and military. If you also are thinking about hosting a birthday party here they do have a private room that is free.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
They were nice
Restaurantji Recommends
Its okay! We visit at least once a year while visiting family because it has options for everyone. The vegetarians get salad, the meat eaters get meat pizzas and pasta sauces.
The only thing I don't appreciate is the immediate asking for a tip when you check in & pay. I'm all for tipping when I'm given service. Here, you order at the counter, get your own food & drinks and we bussed our own table. Not once did someone walk around picking up the empty, used dishes. We had to find the bin and take them ourselves. So why am I being asked for a tip?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
When you all don't want the same kind of pizza this is a place where everyone can walk away happy. They also have yummy pasta options and a nice salad bar area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wonderful place to have a Birthday party 🎈. Thank you so much for all your help providing what we needed like picking up dishes we were finished with and getting the high chairs we needed. Thank you for all your help!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza and Salad, Pizza of the Month
This place is still reasonable in price and the food is pretty good buffet style eating. Parking is easy, kid-friendly. I mostly eat the salad bar and the kids like the pizza, pasta, drinks, and dessert. My only complaint is the lack of tables. Almost every time we go there, we have to sit at a dirty table and ask someone to clear and clean it for us.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Pizza was cold. Like not even a little warm. You can tell it had been sitting there forever. It also had a slightly weird tastes to most of them. Employeees barely acknowledge you except for the lady cleaning for some reason.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Loading...