Lindy's Restaurant

27843 US-95, Athol
(208) 683-3400

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Emy P

The food was the best overall (out of all of the park options!) but just very slow even if not at full capacity.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Gingham Salad

Jaswinder Singh (Google Official Guide)

Overall good food & good selection, I would say above average compare to some others nearby.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Half Rack of Ribs, Garlic Fries, Oriental Chicken Salad

Mark Mullin

One of the worst dining experiences of my life. We walked in and it wasn’t busy. We were promptly seated and about 5 mins later, our waiter came over to greet us. He took our drink order, 2 coffees, 3 sodas. About 10 mins later our drinks arrived and the coffees were stone cold. Not warm but cold as if the coffee had been sitting on the counter, overnight. Another 10 mins goes by and we flag our waiter down and let him know the coffee is cold and could we please have hot replacements. He took our food order and said he’d go get new coffee. Our food order was simple. Penne chicken Alfredo without the parmesan cheese. St. Louis burger with a side of mayo. An Asian salad that had advertised, romaine and cabbage Asian mix with an extra plate for a toddler to pick at.

20 mins go by. Coffees finally arrive. They’re hot. Great! Then, the server comes by and lets us know they’re out of provolone cheese. I let him know cheddar will be fine.

The meals arrive. 55 mins from when we walked in. The penne chicken Alfredo is covered in parm.
There’s no side of mayo for the St Louis burger. There is no extra plate and the Asian salad has nearly rotten mandarin oranges, brown iceberg lettuce and the slimiest dressing you’ll ever see.

No offers of refills unless asked, subpar food and terrible service.

Avoid at all costs.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 1

Brittany Gallaway

It seems as if the service here is a common issue reading the other reviews. We started off on the wrong foot when we came in and were told it was a 5-10 minute wait, we put our name on the list and went and sat with our kids in the waiting area near the host stand. Near 20 minutes passed so o went up to talk to the hostess and see where we were on the list, our name had been removed and we were totally forgotten about, even though we were waiting 10 feet away. They were able to seat us and then we had a long wait for someone to come to our table. Finally, a friendly server named Chelsea came by. She apologized and said there was some confusion on which tables each server had. I will go on to say that it seemed like the place was in shambles that day and many issues were happening left and right. I wanted though to acknowledge the friendly service Chelsea gave us even though she was having a terrible terrible day (she even told us she was) She could have been rude and given us bad service but she was very sweet the entire visit and doing her best given the circumstances. As for the food quality, it wasn't great but I also wasn't expecting it to be. I was very very happy with the cocktails though, they were great.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Emilie Pelletier

The food was the best overall (out of all of the park options!) but just very slow even if not at full capacity.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Gingham Salad

Ben VanDonge

One of the only places to eat in the park where you can get some vegetables. Nice sit-down atmosphere. Food was above average and appropriately priced.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Maddy Woods

I chose Lindy’s as a way to escape on my Silverwood trip. My server was rude and dismissive the whole meal and seemed to treat the whole experience as a dollar sign.

She took our order and seemed annoyed that we weren’t ready to order immediately. Our drinks took forever to come to the table and our server didn’t bring out our food or our drinks to us. I didn’t even see our server again until it was time to pay our bill and then she was very rude and seemed to almost demand a tip.

I understand that Silverwood employs a lot of children, but this child felt out of place in a “nice” restaurant like this one.

Food was good but service was terrible. I felt ignored and it ruined my day.

I will not be returning if you continue to employ rude children like our server.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 1

Taylor Choyce

When we walked in and it was dead. I asked the hostess how busy it was and she said not at all. I then asked how busy the kitchen was because I've read a ton of reviews about how slow the service and kitchen is. Predictably, because there were only 4 tables occupied, she said the kitchen is not busy at all. We were seated. As someone who spent many years as a server, I know that industry standard for a table greet is within 2 minutes of being seated. I told my daughters that if we aren't greeted within 5 minutes that we were leaving. Keep in mind, the restaurant was dead. 4 minutes later we got up and left, having not been greeted by anyone.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Besh N

All I can say is we have been going to Lindy's for years (2012). This was my biggest disappointment ever. My burger was so charred and flavorless, also not even close to 1/3 lbs at all. My daughter also always gets the spaghetti and meatballs. She got half a bowl and 2 small meatballs. Sorry but we will never go again for such small portions with high prices.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Besnik Nela

All I can say is we have been going to Lindy's for years (2012). This was my biggest disappointment ever. My burger was so charred and flavorless, also not even close to 1/3 lbs at all. My daughter also always gets the spaghetti and meatballs. She got half a bowl and 2 small meatballs. Sorry but we will never go again for such small portions with high prices.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Tom Sturzen

The homemade mac and cheese and home made penne pasta was soooo good! Prices good for sit down restaurant! Went both days burger and chicken also good but pasta for the win!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Mac and Cheese

Lorilei Sue

Waiter was friendly and attentive. Food was absolutely delicious and the price was very impressive. I paid more previously to eat at the Boulder Beach food stands, except the atmosphere was far better then at Boulder Beach. I will eat here from now on when I go to silverwood.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Todd Reed

Top expensive for what food was received and the quality.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Jon Straley

Amazing food and great prices!! Our waitress Audrey was so kind and accommodating! Will be back soon.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheeseburger, Spaghetti

Robert F

Food quality seemed decent, prices weren’t bad at all for a theme park, but we had flies that kept bothering us. The server just said it was out of her control and offered to close a side door. That did not help at all. We complained again because it was landing on our food and drinks. We asked for a manager finally. She tried to get a fly off the wall but it kept flying around the table. She was also fairly dismissive but offered to move us to another table. We agreed to move closer to the back but a fly still found their way back there. Again food not bad but service was terrible and with constant fly attacks the ambiance was horrendous. So much potential, didn’t mind waiting over an hour honestly but with fly infested food and poor service would never go back. Now I see these reviews and wish I had read them before trying this restaurant.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Loading...