Extreme Pizza Caldwell

Name: Extreme Pizza Caldwell
Address: 111 S 7th Ave, Caldwell, Idaho, 83605, US
Telephone: (208) 402-5722
Price range: $
Rating: 4.4

$ • Pizza, Chicken Wings, Salad

Hours:
111 S 7th Ave, Caldwell
(208) 402-5722

Menu Order Online

About Extreme Pizza Caldwell

Extreme Pizza Caldwell is a charming pizza cafe with friendly staff and cute pizza names. The crust is soft and chewy with a crisp bottom, and the toppings are balanced nicely. Customers praise the pizza as the best in town, offering real sauce, fresh ingredients, and a crispy crust that stands out compared to other local options. The 8" Kickin' Chicken and Flying High Thai Chicken salad are recommended, with fresh and large salads on the side. Many find the prices very reasonable, with pizzas costing around $8, making it a great value for quality food. The atmosphere is family-friendly and welcoming, with staff always courteous and helpful, even assisting with wheelchair accessibility despite the door being a bit tight. Customers often recommend ordering ahead during busy dinner times and appreciate the hospitality and delicious food that makes the trip worthwhile. Although you might need to go next door for a beer, the excellent pizza makes it worth the trip. Recent reviews highlight the delicious thin, crunchy crust and good toppings on Hawaiian slices, and customers say it’s their favorite pizza place, worth the drive from Meridian. Despite some difficulty calling in orders due to short staffing, service remains friendly and the pizza is consistently amazing, with popular options like Yard Sale and The Shredder. One customer also raves about the Caesar dressing made in-house, calling it the best salad dressing they’ve ever had and wishing it was sold separately.