Charming little pizza cafe with cute pizza names and friendly staff. The pizza was very good. Crust is soft and chewy with a crisp bottom. Just the way I like it. Toppings were balanced nicely. I've already decided what I'll try next, because...I'll definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tiffany Donoho
My kids and I stopped by because I was craving pizza and what a surprise! The pizza was excellent! The only downfall was having to go next door to grab a beer, but it was worth it! I'll be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Krystal
Great pizza and service! The owner is super friendly and the atmosphere is fun and welcoming, our whole family loved it! We’ll definitely be back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
jessica muse
The pizza was great and they were accommodating for my food allergies. The toppings were generous and the flavor was amazing ?Dietary restrictions: They have a great variety of toppings for any and all. If u let them know u have allergies they were so gracious to help accommodate them
Recommended dishes: Create Your Own Calzone
Nicole Gray
We love their pizza, but the online services will not let you order gluten free crust so we have to call each time.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
andrea anderson
Absolutely wonderful food and helpful staff we will definitely be going back again soon!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mari
I absolutely adore this place. My first memory of this was in December 2022, it was about 8pm and this kind woman, perhaps a worker, manager or owner came up to my family and I to give us free pizzas while we were watching others at the ice rink. Pizza was and is great! I love them and what they do for the community.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeffrey Frost
This place does not disappoint!!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jon boy
This place has very good pizza! It's extreme! If I lived closer to here, you probably would see me every day. The pizza was a solid 5/5, the salad was great, and their cheesy bread (spicy) was delicious. The atmosphere was cool and comfortable. The only thing about it is limited seating (smaller location), which I don't think it effects the review because that's something out of their hands. I'm just glad the food was exceptional. I'll definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jennifer Chu
My husband and I were out running errands and we needed to take a break for food. He chose pizza and we started looking up different places. He showed me this place and just looking at the menu my mouth started watering. He is picky when it comes to trying new things so instead of just a pepperoni I recommended the Everst...meat and cheese. Neither of us had been there before and parking is definitely tight down there in a dead end street but we were lucky. The people were nice but one who served the majority of the time just seemed sad. But I've been there done that. No hate towards her. He got a medium of the Everest and he enjoyed it. It actually lasted him a couple days, which is the beauty of pizza. I had a "indee"/personal size of Pandoras Box I believe. It was good but it seemed like the top was a little burnt (the basil and artichoke hearts were a little black. It was hard to find the sun dried tomatoes, which I was lòking forward to. I enjoy a well done crust/bottom. So it was like the top was well done but the bottom needed a little more time. It was fully cooked, it was just off a little. But I worked 5 years at a pizza place so maybe I'm picky too. I will say this. I also ordered an "entree sized" Ceaser salad with chicken. And eating that, I would've died happy. The Ceaser dressing is made in house by the chef and I made sure they let him know that he should bottle and sell it. I've been looking for a good ceaser dressing and this one had me amazed and asking for more. Also, the lettuce was not only clean but crisp and dry!! They put a good amount of croutons and freshly shaved cheese. And the chicken looked and tasted fresh and wasn't dry. Best salad ever. Loved how they kept the "toppings and dressing" of the salad in separate piles on top so I could eat and mix as I went and still take it home with it being edible hours later. Small place inside so if you're looking to dine in, wait until after the lunch rush and before the dinner rush. Definitely worth a try.
So yummy!! Friendly staff and environment. Just wish they were open a little later. Otherwise it rocked and we will definitely be back
Holden Blackmer
From the exceptional service from their staff to their absolutely delicious food, I cannot recommend this place enough!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Create Your Own Calzone, Vegan Options, Vegan Cheese, Sauce, Vegan, Bogus Basin Potato Pizza with Bacon and Ranch
Lee Smith
Upon arrival we were curtly told there would be a 45 minute to hour wait when the entire place was empty and the teenaged girl behind the counter had just set down her cellphone… clearly busy.The food was subpar, the seating area uncomfortable, the soda fountain was off on their syrup levels so everything was watered down.I won’t be back.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
TheJessep4320
Friendly outgoing positive staff with a great attitude. Food was fresh and delicious would highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Justin P.
Great customer service and great food! Would definitely recommend to anyone in the Caldwell area. Way better than Idaho pizza.
Charming little pizza cafe with cute pizza names and friendly staff. The pizza was very good. Crust is soft and chewy with a crisp bottom. Just the way I like it. Toppings were balanced nicely. I've already decided what I'll try next, because...I'll definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My kids and I stopped by because I was craving pizza and what a surprise! The pizza was excellent! The only downfall was having to go next door to grab a beer, but it was worth it! I'll be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza and service! The owner is super friendly and the atmosphere is fun and welcoming, our whole family loved it! We’ll definitely be back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza was great and they were accommodating for my food allergies. The toppings were generous and the flavor was amazing ?Dietary restrictions: They have a great variety of toppings for any and all. If u let them know u have allergies they were so gracious to help accommodate them
Recommended dishes: Create Your Own Calzone
We love their pizza, but the online services will not let you order gluten free crust so we have to call each time.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Absolutely wonderful food and helpful staff we will definitely be going back again soon!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I absolutely adore this place. My first memory of this was in December 2022, it was about 8pm and this kind woman, perhaps a worker, manager or owner came up to my family and I to give us free pizzas while we were watching others at the ice rink. Pizza was and is great! I love them and what they do for the community.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place does not disappoint!!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place has very good pizza! It's extreme! If I lived closer to here, you probably would see me every day. The pizza was a solid 5/5, the salad was great, and their cheesy bread (spicy) was delicious. The atmosphere was cool and comfortable. The only thing about it is limited seating (smaller location), which I don't think it effects the review because that's something out of their hands. I'm just glad the food was exceptional. I'll definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My husband and I were out running errands and we needed to take a break for food. He chose pizza and we started looking up different places. He showed me this place and just looking at the menu my mouth started watering. He is picky when it comes to trying new things so instead of just a pepperoni I recommended the Everst...meat and cheese. Neither of us had been there before and parking is definitely tight down there in a dead end street but we were lucky. The people were nice but one who served the majority of the time just seemed sad. But I've been there done that. No hate towards her. He got a medium of the Everest and he enjoyed it. It actually lasted him a couple days, which is the beauty of pizza. I had a "indee"/personal size of Pandoras Box I believe. It was good but it seemed like the top was a little burnt (the basil and artichoke hearts were a little black. It was hard to find the sun dried tomatoes, which I was lòking forward to. I enjoy a well done crust/bottom. So it was like the top was well done but the bottom needed a little more time. It was fully cooked, it was just off a little. But I worked 5 years at a pizza place so maybe I'm picky too. I will say this. I also ordered an "entree sized" Ceaser salad with chicken. And eating that, I would've died happy. The Ceaser dressing is made in house by the chef and I made sure they let him know that he should bottle and sell it. I've been looking for a good ceaser dressing and this one had me amazed and asking for more. Also, the lettuce was not only clean but crisp and dry!! They put a good amount of croutons and freshly shaved cheese. And the chicken looked and tasted fresh and wasn't dry. Best salad ever. Loved how they kept the "toppings and dressing" of the salad in separate piles on top so I could eat and mix as I went and still take it home with it being edible hours later. Small place inside so if you're looking to dine in, wait until after the lunch rush and before the dinner rush. Definitely worth a try.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad
Restaurantji Recommends
So yummy!! Friendly staff and environment. Just wish they were open a little later. Otherwise it rocked and we will definitely be back
From the exceptional service from their staff to their absolutely delicious food, I cannot recommend this place enough!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Create Your Own Calzone, Vegan Options, Vegan Cheese, Sauce, Vegan, Bogus Basin Potato Pizza with Bacon and Ranch
Upon arrival we were curtly told there would be a 45 minute to hour wait when the entire place was empty and the teenaged girl behind the counter had just set down her cellphone… clearly busy.The food was subpar, the seating area uncomfortable, the soda fountain was off on their syrup levels so everything was watered down.I won’t be back.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Friendly outgoing positive staff with a great attitude. Food was fresh and delicious would highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great customer service and great food! Would definitely recommend to anyone in the Caldwell area. Way better than Idaho pizza.