Absolutely love Shy Simon’s Pizza! 🍕 The pizzas are delicious—perfectly baked with fresh ingredients and bold flavors in every bite. The service is always friendly and efficient, making you feel welcome from the moment you walk in. The dining room is clean and cozy, great for a casual night out, and the outdoor patio is absolutely beautiful—perfect for enjoying your meal on a nice day. Highly recommend if you’re looking for quality pizza and a great dining experience! 👏🔥
Luke Balmer
get the pastrami sandwich.
Carl Spackler
Clean, efficient and good. The little lady at the counter was very sweet and inviting. Definitely worth a visit.
Joseph Araiza
OMG! I drive past this little town 4 times a year. A friend mentioned it was a must stop, and we did. Amazing! Food, service and atmosphere. It is very close to the main highway. If you get the urge for a delicious pizza and you are close to Council, Shy Simons Pizza is a must!
Ben B
This 5 star review is from my 9 yr old son who really likes this place and so did I. He liked the soda selection (pineapple cream soda mixed with starry lemon lime). The pizza had very light and crisp crust with fresh toppings. The pastrami sandwich was cooked perfectly. Comfortable seats too :-) He says best pizza in the 🌍 10/10 on his rating scale.
Song River
Very good gluten free pizza, probably the best I've ever had. It tasted like pizza crust! The pesto is the one I ordered. Everything tasted fresh as in made to order. The pesto though does need a boost of garlic, lemon and salt. That would bring it up to five stars . Wonderful caring staff. I'd say best pizza in Idaho!
Judy D.
Pizza is great, staff is friendly. Nice new patio for dining.
Raymond Ortiz
Loved it amazing pizza and amazing people
Teresa Olson
Pretty decent pizza. Price not bad. Crust could be better but it's ok.
Nathan Miller
While working the Limepoint fire stopped in here and had a great pizza. Ready in 12 minutes, good cheese and sauce. Plenty of meat on the meatlovers.
Great hometown feeling, the sausage, garlic, jalapeño pizza was so good!!! Our server was the sweetest most helpful person!! I will always eat there!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Daniel Hunt
Delicious pizza! If you’re going through Council it’s a must stop.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers Pizza
Tony
In my humble opinion, this is the best handmade pizza anywhere. Every time we head north and go through Council we stop at Shy Simon's.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: blt on Rye Toast, Turkey Club Wrap, Lumberjack, Meat Lovers Pizza
Justin Norton
Very rude customer service.. my order was forgotten about and brought to me cold..would never return or recommend to anyone... they have won awards by being the only pizza place In town..I'm sure the local receive better service
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
d lawton
The pizza is the best pizza I’ve had in the area and the service can’t be beat! The price is great as well!
Absolutely love Shy Simon’s Pizza! 🍕 The pizzas are delicious—perfectly baked with fresh ingredients and bold flavors in every bite. The service is always friendly and efficient, making you feel welcome from the moment you walk in. The dining room is clean and cozy, great for a casual night out, and the outdoor patio is absolutely beautiful—perfect for enjoying your meal on a nice day. Highly recommend if you’re looking for quality pizza and a great dining experience! 👏🔥
get the pastrami sandwich.
Clean, efficient and good. The little lady at the counter was very sweet and inviting. Definitely worth a visit.
OMG! I drive past this little town 4 times a year. A friend mentioned it was a must stop, and we did. Amazing! Food, service and atmosphere. It is very close to the main highway. If you get the urge for a delicious pizza and you are close to Council, Shy Simons Pizza is a must!
This 5 star review is from my 9 yr old son who really likes this place and so did I. He liked the soda selection (pineapple cream soda mixed with starry lemon lime). The pizza had very light and crisp crust with fresh toppings. The pastrami sandwich was cooked perfectly. Comfortable seats too :-) He says best pizza in the 🌍 10/10 on his rating scale.
Very good gluten free pizza, probably the best I've ever had. It tasted like pizza crust! The pesto is the one I ordered. Everything tasted fresh as in made to order. The pesto though does need a boost of garlic, lemon and salt. That would bring it up to five stars .
Wonderful caring staff. I'd say best pizza in Idaho!
Pizza is great, staff is friendly. Nice new patio for dining.
Loved it amazing pizza and amazing people
Pretty decent pizza. Price not bad. Crust could be better but it's ok.
While working the Limepoint fire stopped in here and had a great pizza. Ready in 12 minutes, good cheese and sauce. Plenty of meat on the meatlovers.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great hometown feeling, the sausage, garlic, jalapeño pizza was so good!!! Our server was the sweetest most helpful person!! I will always eat there!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious pizza! If you’re going through Council it’s a must stop.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers Pizza
In my humble opinion, this is the best handmade pizza anywhere. Every time we head north and go through Council we stop at Shy Simon's.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: blt on Rye Toast, Turkey Club Wrap, Lumberjack, Meat Lovers Pizza
Very rude customer service.. my order was forgotten about and brought to me cold..would never return or recommend to anyone... they have won awards by being the only pizza place In town..I'm sure the local receive better service
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
The pizza is the best pizza I’ve had in the area and the service can’t be beat! The price is great as well!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lumberjack, Garlic Chicken Pizza
Loading...