A favorite of ours. Chef Steve always has superb food! Terrific service and very attentive and down home friendly.
Suzanne
It was an outstanding evening. We chose to eat outside and the service was excellent. Our food was enjoyed by alll.
Dwight
We had a wonderful experience at Ragazza Di Bufalo. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with just the right mix of rustic Idaho charm and upscale Italian style. Service was attentive and friendly without ever feeling rushed. The food was the highlight—authentic flavors with creative touches. We especially enjoyed the bison lasagna and the clam chowder, both of which were outstanding. Portions were generous, and everything felt fresh and thoughtfully prepared. The wine list also paired nicely with the menu. It's not the least expensive option in town, but the quality and overall dining experience make it well worth it. A real gem in Donnelly and a place we'll definitely return to.
Amy
Amazing as always! The chicken parm is the best! Our waitress surprised us with a glass of prosecco for our anniversary! Service and food never disappoint! Can't wait to come back!
Hailey
We were first time diners and were also celebrating our anniversary. The day after dining we are still talking about how amazing our food was! Everything we had was exceptional, one can certainly taste the freshness of the homemade pasta and sauces!! The service team was so welcoming and provided excellent personalized service. We can't wait to go back!
Deborah
Party of 4, with reservations so we did not have to wait for a seat. The food was most excellent all the way around. It does take awhile to receive it, so make an evening of it! The only negative was the noise factor. It was a full house on a Friday night and the noise made it difficult to even have a nice conversation. The hostess and our server were excellent! We can't wait to come back to try another dish but maybe on a middle of the week night when it's quieter!
Yvonne
Very friendly & welcoming. Our Server patiently answered all of our questions about the wine and food. Everything thing was outstanding, fresh and delicious. Highly recommend you try it.
Mark
Outstanding service & food, we now rank Ragazza Di Bufalo as the best restaurant in McCall - Donnelly.
Kris
Our party of 5 were there to celebrate a birthday, which was acknowledged as soon as we checked in. Our server, Grace was friendly & very good about checking on us during the meal. The menu had so many tempting options, we were all torn between dishes and Grace was very knowledgeable about them all. The menu also has wine suggestions which makes pairing very easy & our request for a sample was quickly provided. The meal was excellent from the homemade rosemary focaccia, to the chicken parm, the shrimp scampi with homemade pasta, the fish and their lasagna covered in a mushroom cream sauce was definitely one of the highlights of our trip. The salted Carmel gelato for the birthday girl was also very tasty. We highly recommend making reservations to dine here when visiting the McCall area. It was an excellent experience for a reasonable price.
Karen
As we pass through Donnelly, ID every summer we make sure to make this a priority stop! We HIGHLY RECOMMEND this restaurant. From being greeted at the front door all the way to the end of our meal the customer service is outstanding. Thank you Grace for being such a conscientious server and taking great care of us. Every one of us enjoyed our meal choices to the fullest. If the server asks if you would like the bread you must say yes !!! Oh my goodness, such freshness and a wonderful start to the meal. We will be back!
Of any place to eat in the nation, I'd choose Ragazza again to celebrate my birthday for dinner. Hands down the best food around! Excellent service too!
Gary
We were up staying in Tamarack for a couple days, we spent most time in McCall and our first day had a great lunch at Bistro 45 in McCall and learned there were a couple connected restaurants in Donnelly - Ragazza Di Bufalo (and wine bar next door)- we stopped by on our way back one night and didn't realize how popular it was - and fairly small (make reservations) but the hostess was so great and fit us in - we shared their most popular dish, the lasagne - very unique but VERY Good! The salad was great also. So good in fact we made reservations for the next night and had the Chicken Parm - a unique combo of red and white sauce - again great! Everyone there was very nice. And we requested DJ as our server both nights - she's Minnesota Nice! We'll be back! Make reservations!
Charlie
Food was delicious, as usual. Received a very thoughtful surprise from the chef. Always enjoy this taste of Italy. Plan ahead to make your reservation, it's worth it.
Beverly
Ragazza has a great menu and everything is delicious. Our group enjoyed their lobster linguini, veal marsala, lobster & shrimp ravioli and spaghetti and meatballs. Good Caesar salad as well. We were too full to try the huckleberry canola that was served at the next table. Looked great. Hostess and server were great. Efficient and friendly.
Cathleen
Amazing service and wonderful good home cooked food with a lot of options. They even have gluten free pasta. The artichoke appetizer is to die for!
A favorite of ours. Chef Steve always has superb food! Terrific service and very attentive and down home friendly.
It was an outstanding evening. We chose to eat outside and the service was excellent. Our food was enjoyed by alll.
We had a wonderful experience at Ragazza Di Bufalo. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with just the right mix of rustic Idaho charm and upscale Italian style. Service was attentive and friendly without ever feeling rushed. The food was the highlight—authentic flavors with creative touches. We especially enjoyed the bison lasagna and the clam chowder, both of which were outstanding. Portions were generous, and everything felt fresh and thoughtfully prepared. The wine list also paired nicely with the menu. It's not the least expensive option in town, but the quality and overall dining experience make it well worth it. A real gem in Donnelly and a place we'll definitely return to.
Amazing as always! The chicken parm is the best! Our waitress surprised us with a glass of prosecco for our anniversary! Service and food never disappoint! Can't wait to come back!
We were first time diners and were also celebrating our anniversary. The day after dining we are still talking about how amazing our food was! Everything we had was exceptional, one can certainly taste the freshness of the homemade pasta and sauces!! The service team was so welcoming and provided excellent personalized service. We can't wait to go back!
Party of 4, with reservations so we did not have to wait for a seat. The food was most excellent all the way around. It does take awhile to receive it, so make an evening of it! The only negative was the noise factor. It was a full house on a Friday night and the noise made it difficult to even have a nice conversation. The hostess and our server were excellent! We can't wait to come back to try another dish but maybe on a middle of the week night when it's quieter!
Very friendly & welcoming. Our Server patiently answered all of our questions about the wine and food. Everything thing was outstanding, fresh and delicious. Highly recommend you try it.
Outstanding service & food, we now rank Ragazza Di Bufalo as the best restaurant in McCall - Donnelly.
Our party of 5 were there to celebrate a birthday, which was acknowledged as soon as we checked in. Our server, Grace was friendly & very good about checking on us during the meal. The menu had so many tempting options, we were all torn between dishes and Grace was very knowledgeable about them all. The menu also has wine suggestions which makes pairing very easy & our request for a sample was quickly provided. The meal was excellent from the homemade rosemary focaccia, to the chicken parm, the shrimp scampi with homemade pasta, the fish and their lasagna covered in a mushroom cream sauce was definitely one of the highlights of our trip. The salted Carmel gelato for the birthday girl was also very tasty. We highly recommend making reservations to dine here when visiting the McCall area. It was an excellent experience for a reasonable price.
As we pass through Donnelly, ID every summer we make sure to make this a priority stop! We HIGHLY RECOMMEND this restaurant. From being greeted at the front door all the way to the end of our meal the customer service is outstanding. Thank you Grace for being such a conscientious server and taking great care of us. Every one of us enjoyed our meal choices to the fullest. If the server asks if you would like the bread you must say yes !!! Oh my goodness, such freshness and a wonderful start to the meal. We will be back!
Restaurantji Recommends
Of any place to eat in the nation, I'd choose Ragazza again to celebrate my birthday for dinner. Hands down the best food around! Excellent service too!
We were up staying in Tamarack for a couple days, we spent most time in McCall and our first day had a great lunch at Bistro 45 in McCall and learned there were a couple connected restaurants in Donnelly - Ragazza Di Bufalo (and wine bar next door)- we stopped by on our way back one night and didn't realize how popular it was - and fairly small (make reservations) but the hostess was so great and fit us in - we shared their most popular dish, the lasagne - very unique but VERY Good! The salad was great also. So good in fact we made reservations for the next night and had the Chicken Parm - a unique combo of red and white sauce - again great! Everyone there was very nice. And we requested DJ as our server both nights - she's Minnesota Nice! We'll be back! Make reservations!
Food was delicious, as usual. Received a very thoughtful surprise from the chef. Always enjoy this taste of Italy. Plan ahead to make your reservation, it's worth it.
Ragazza has a great menu and everything is delicious. Our group enjoyed their lobster linguini, veal marsala, lobster & shrimp ravioli and spaghetti and meatballs. Good Caesar salad as well. We were too full to try the huckleberry canola that was served at the next table. Looked great. Hostess and server were great. Efficient and friendly.
Amazing service and wonderful good home cooked food with a lot of options. They even have gluten free pasta. The artichoke appetizer is to die for!
Loading...