Stella's Ice Cream - Eagle

Perfect in every way!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Salted Caramel

Overall stars. Stella's Ice Cream in Eagle, located at 2826 S Eagle Rd, is a premium, handcrafted ice cream parlor that consistently delivers on quality and customer experience. It is easily a top contender for the best ice cream in the Treasure Valley.

Product Quality & Texture:
The defining feature of Stella's is the dense, rich texture of their product. This is not soft-serve; it's a high-fat, ultra-creamy ice cream that holds its shape and flavor well. The base flavors—Vanilla and Chocolate—are notably high quality.

Flavor Recommendations & Variety:
Stella's excels at flavor innovation and variety. They maintain a solid selection of core favorites and rotating specials.

Must-Try Dairy: The Salted Caramel is highly recommended; it strikes a perfect balance between sweet, buttery caramel and sea salt, preventing it from being cloyingly sweet. The Rocky Road is another solid choice, featuring large, quality mix-ins of almonds and marshmallows.

Best Vegan Options: Stella's is a standout for dietary needs. Their dairy-free line, made with coconut milk, is extensive and high-quality, often including flavors like Chocolate Oreo and Strawberry. This is a crucial detail for consumers with lactose intolerance or vegan diets.

Other Noteworthy Items: Beyond scoops, their menu includes popular items like milkshakes (starting around $9.00 for 12oz) and various party packs. They also offer Pupsicles ($2.50) for dogs, a nice touch for pet owners.

Atmosphere and Service:
The Eagle location is clean, bright, and modern, making it a good spot for a quick stop or a longer hang-out. It’s situated in a convenient plaza area. The staff consistently receives high praise across reviews for being friendly, patient, and efficient. They are known for allowing multiple samples and helping indecisive customers navigate the flavor board, which enhances the overall visit.

Pricing and Value:
Pricing is on the higher end, aligning with premium, handcrafted ice cream shops, but the quality justifies the cost. A Single Scoop is typically around $5.50, and a Double Scoop is approximately $8.75. Considering the rich product, generous scoops, and fast service, the value proposition remains high.

Logistics & Accessibility:
Located near other dining and entertainment options, the shop has good visibility. The hours are generally consistent (typically Noon to 10 PM or 11 PM, seven days a week). Note that during peak summer months, lines can form, but staff usually handle the flow efficiently.

In Summary:
For anyone in the Eagle area looking for genuinely high-quality, creamy ice cream with diverse options for various dietary needs, Stella's is the definitive local choice. Excellent product consistency and top-tier customer service make this a highly reliable 5-star destination.

Employee was condescending when telling me I had 0$ on my gift card.

I love Stella's ice cream... The service is always been very polite and welcoming..... Nowadays you really appreciate the good service

Staff were super nice and friendly. Clean environment.

Great location but unfortunately they never have good dairy free flavors or they only have two options. I try calling in advance to check the flavors but no one ever answers the phone. I wish this location would offer more dairy free flavors like the other locations.

DoorDash driver review. I'm sure the ice cream is wonderful but it it sucks my time waiting for the order to be completed. And then I spend 90 minutes delivering it it to a happy people neighborhood halfway between Boise and Cascade for $5. I'm an elite 35 year experienced college trained diesel mechanic that makes $40 per hour at my main job.

These girls are amazing, they not only took the time to acknowledge us during a busy rush but also got our order right and was super friendly. I will definitely be back and would highly recommend stopping in. The Dairy -Free mint chip with coconut milk was amazing 🍦

Went in, waited 15 minutes, everyone else was served, we continued to wait, no one spoke to us. Two girls walked past us several times, I asked if we could get a single kids ice cream cone, no response. We walked out without having anyone take our order and a sad little seven year old. We won’t be back.

The ice cream is good, but don’t order the mini size. We are used to that size being the complimentary taste size. Order the next size up and get a real serving

We love Stella’s Ice Cream!

This tiny spoonful cost me $3.45 a complete rip off and honestly laughable. Definitely will not be coming back. If a manager could reach out to me that would be great

Very nice and friendly staff

Amazing Ice Cream 🍦 and the workers are so friendly 🥰

Always delicious treat with the grandkids!