Papa Kelsey's of Hagerman

130 S State St, Hagerman
(208) 837-6680

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Dennis Burnaman

My turkey sandwich was sad. Looked like it had been stepped on. Hardly any meat, one tomato slice. The pizza was just not good. Taste like frozen pizza. I have actually had better pizza at chuck e cheese. The smell when you walk in should have been my clue it's awful 😞

Becky Johnstone

Great food! Very tasty.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sandwich

Patsy Pruitt

We went here for a family dinner while visiting Idaho. They were reasonably priced, great service, and the food was delicious. They also had ice cream for dessert.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Ricky C

The price is amazing and so is the food. Had Huckleberry ice cream, firehouse pizza, and a Hawaiian, and a hamburger. Everything is top notch and the staff were extremely friendly.

R C

The price is amazing and so is the food. Had Huckleberry ice cream, firehouse pizza, and a Hawaiian, and a hamburger. Everything is top notch and the staff were extremely friendly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tiffany Stoermer

We ordered an All Meat large pizza.... excited to try because it was our first time. It was doughy, bland and all you could taste was bacon. Very disappointed!!!! Won't try the pizza again but will give one more shot for sandwiches cause limited here......

Food: 1

Service: 2

Charlotte Faulkner

Delicious. Enough said!!!!

Ryan Brown

I love papa Kelsey's however the ice cream was a bit freezer burnt and I think that's because it's not served often. Great otherwise.

Tina Kuohwa Lee

The pastrami sandwich very good

We Griff

Good Gigantic hot sandwiches, add what veggies you want, very friendly staff.

Linda Amarante

Great place and food

Tyler Byman

Stopped by this evening on my way through. My cousin reccomended it a couple of times (his mom lives in town and he eats here when he's in the area). Highly reccomend it!

Zora Fansler

Great pizza and wonderful salads

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brooke Nielsen

We ate here while we were staying in Billingsley Creek. I have to have gluten free food and they had a great selection of gluten free food. Not to mention that the gluten pizza and breadsticks were ABSOLUTELY amazing!!! Thank you for having options like this even in a tiny town. We can’t wait to visit and eat there again!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brett D

Girls are great to deal with and the food tastes great! Reasonably priced too.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Italian Combo

Loading...