Yellowstone Playhouse at Island Park

The food was excellent. Very chuckwaggony. The venue is pretty good too with nice atmosphere. But, be warned, as others have pointed out - the play itself is really, really stupid. We saw Idaho Jones. It is extremely amateurish and lacks humor. And no, it is not that I subjectively don't like the type of humor, it is simply not funny at all. I was there with a large group, and we all agreed. So did everyone I talked to. And it is not dumb in a funny way either. It is completely devoid of humor. Enjoy the food and group dinner, but keep expectations for the show extremely low. Rated 5 stars because the food was just that good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

The best place ever!!! Please take your family or dates here! Absolutely amazing! Food was great but the play was outstanding!! So much fun and we laughed so hard!! Will be coming back every year for sure!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

My only regret is we went at the close of the season. Now we have to wait until they open again next year.
It's a beautiful and easy drive from Rexburg. Very family friendly place. The food was phenomenal. The staff and cast were all amazing. I have zero complaints or even suggestions, honestly. We can't wait until our family visits us so we can take them there!

Vegetarian options: You don't have to have meat, they offer a meal without it.

Kid-friendliness: Theu offer kids meals. They also have a "cry room" where you can hear the show but then your kids can't disturb others watching the show. It's perfect if you have a kid that just can't get through the show. (We've all been there, we get it. Don't let your kid be an excuse not to go! It's awesome!)
Personally, the live show is very entertaining and so busy, kids would love it.

Wheelchair accessibility: There are ramps and reserved places to sit for better accessibility.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This place almost felt almost fairytale esk, first of all I went here with my family to see idaho Jones II. And let me tell you, as a musical kid it was one of the funniest ones I've seem, everyone seemed extremely kind and respectful. The show was just amazing in everyday, ESPECIALLY THE SINGING!! When I tell you that some of those people have more talent than modern day music artist I mean it. The food was pretty good, I got a Mac and cheese and a roll (it sounded good) but all the food looked delicious and my family said it was amazing, the interactive atmosphere is so fun making you feel welcome. I could gush on and on about this place but you'll just have to go for yourself. One more thing, this is not about the performance, but I felt at times the audience was acting inappropriately towards jokes, for example there was a hilarious joke where the mc was saying complements about random people and trump and biden showed up and it stumped him, but what was a little inappropriate in my opinion was the crowd booing at only one of the presidential candidates, I know there is nothing this amazing staff can do about that, just a heads up in case you are planning on going the audience is very strong minded on certain topics.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Our family goes to the Yellowstone Playhouse every year and have yet to be disappointed! Great atmosphere, food and entertainment

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We are staying at the RV park across the street with some friends, one couple who's having their 25th anniversary. We saw the parking lot full every night and decided to look into it. Our friends decided a dinner theater was a nice treat for their anniversary so the rest of us joined in. I was looking forward to it because I like that sort of thing and we don't really have places like this back home. Given all the cars in the lot each night my expectations were high but my wife's were a bit more muted because, after all, how much of a dinner and a show can you really get for $45. Well, we both walked away with it having exceeded our expectations for not only the quality of the play but the quantity and quality of the food. A very friendly and efficient staff kept things moving along and our group and, judging from audience reaction throughout, the rest of the house had a very enjoyable evening with a lot of good food and laughter.

Terrific show and meal

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brother Durrant brings a special spirit that rivals general conference. Dinner was epic and the jokes were on point!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dinner was delicious and plentiful. The play was upbeat, and the MC was very energetic. Parts of the play were "belly-laugh" funny.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Our family has made this an annual tradition. We enjoy the comedy/twists to classic stories.
Food is great! Wonderful prices.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Every show we have been to has been amazing! Best Prime rib in 500 miles or more! The crew is top-notch. I wish we would go more than once a summer. I highly recommend attending a show and having dinner. You won't regret it!!

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes! I was on crutches the last show, and it was easy. Wheelchair accessible for sure. You may just give them a heads up when you buy your tickets

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Excellent prime rib, wonderful staff, funny show with talented actors. Only down side was the seating is tight. Great date night!

Kid-friendliness: Kids would love the play!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We do a dinner and show here every year. Always so much fun and we laugh a ton.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We didn’t do the dinner, but we did two shows. They were excellent! Good wholesome fun. Also appreciate Donna helping us move our tickets around due to a family complication. The cast/staff do an excellent job and work their tails off! If you’re in the area, definitely come out. It’s a fun time!

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

If there were something higher than 5 stars I would give that to them! We have never been to a funnier show. They are the best and I always laugh until it hurts! Idaho Jones 2 was the absolute best. It is a must see! And the food A +

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5