The cashier was nice, but the atmosphere was gloomy, like a hospital. We ordered 2 spaghetti, 1 alfredo, and a salad bar and garlic bread. Our food cost about 60 dollars.The salad bar was really good but everything else was terrible. The bread sticks were gross, and the garlic bread was topped with garlic and oil, and wasn't good at all. The spaghetti sauce looked like it came out of a can or was frozen, it was chunky and didn't taste good. The 16 dollar alfredo with shrimp was oily and had too much garlic in it. It had cheap popcorn shrimp in it. Food was so bad and expensive that I couldn't even force myself to eat it because I started to feel sick. There are plenty of other places that you can go to get better food for the same price.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 4
Lanny “goose1127” Denton
We have went here for years and really enjoy their food they got good prices and good food it's worth the drive
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Google Google
Closed at random times, unreliable business.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
G RAThbun
Like everything else in life nowadays the food quality is just not quite what it used to be but still good. Service was real good clean and quiet place to have a lunch
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Tara Smith
The food was great! Nice salad bar, great pizza! The service was good too! As far as the seating, it's kind of dark and needs some sprucing up. I would definitely order from them again, only as a takeout or delivery next time.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Staker “yolobomber” Holt
Been going since it was Maxie’s.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
LC
First time eating here. The pizza and salad bar was excellent, the service was excellent as well. However; they had their son there who was eating a cucumber slice from the tongs. Putting it right into his mouth and back into the cucumber bowl.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Canadian Bacon Pizza, One-Trip Salad Bar
Guylia James
We had the salad bar, it was fresh and delicious! Such a variety of items ie. Sweet pickles, beets, cucumbers, cottage cheese etc
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Katrina Gottschalch
Found this little place while passing through on a road trip. My niece and I got the chicken parmigiana and the lasagna, both were ordered to go.
Starting with the good things: 1. the lady at the counter taking orders was very nice 2. the quaint decore was endearing and felt like stepping back to a simpler time 3. portions sizes were large 4. prices would have been fair if the food was better quality, each entre was about $16 and came with garlic bread and a garden salad.
Now for the bad: 1. The chicken parmigiana was made with frozen pre-packages chicken patties, like what you would get in a banquet tv dinner. They had a very spongy texture 2. The lasagna wasn't made with any discernable layers, it was just a pile of cut up lasagna noodles with sauce, cheese, and ground sausage all mixed up. It tasted ok though 3. The garlic bread was very dry and bland 4. The salad was lack luster, just pre-made bagged iceberg lettuce with a couple veggies thrown on 5. We didn't get any utensils to eat our food with.
The restaurant smelled good and the pizza looked really great. Maybe if we had gotten the pizza we would have had a better experience. I would suggest steering clear of the pasta dishes here.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
Adam Pearson
Locally owned and operated with great pizza. Ive only had their puzza so cannot comment on the rest of their offerings. Fresh, good salad bar with a macaroni salad on it thats delicious. Very nice staff. Can't go wrong at Monterey Jack's.
I order take out pizza about every two weeks. Two times the pizzas were so undercooked that I threw them out. Last time was March 24, 2025. I ordered 2 pizzas, both were undercooked. The crust was so raw I threw them out. Also the one was supposed to be to be a vegetarian and I didn’t even recognize what they gave me. I arrived on time and had to wait 25 minutes. Salad bar needed to be restocked, most items were empty. Total waste of time and money.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Esteban Son
Damn good pizza. Will be ordering again soon.
Holly McClain Tucker
Their pizza and lasagna is AMAZING!
If you loved Maxie’s, you’ll love eating here!
Norma O. Juarez Mendoza
BEST PIZZA! Recommend there Idiots Delight
Christine Friel
Over the last 10 months we have found hair in our food on 5 separate occasions.
Then this happened..... on Thanksgiving eve I ordered a chicken club sandwich with seashore fries and a side of onion rings. About two hours later I was having a stomach ache but by midnight I was extremely 🤢. it felt like getting jabbed with a knife or such..... then the vomiting started. I texted Slice and told them what was up..... long story short... everyone was here for Thanksgiving dinner and I missed 90 percent of it. I wasn't completely well until this last Sunday.
I tried to get it settled with Slice as the mediator.
Ain't working......
OM Goodness.. Their offer is they will give me 20 per cent off my next order....... REALLY 😄🤣 LIKE I WOULD EVER ORDER FROM THEM AGAIN. Not after hair and then poisoning me.
Next time you order for delivery... check out the inside of that bag they bring it in. Oh what don't I recommend you about them..I ...recommended
NEVER GO THERE..........EVER.
The cashier was nice, but the atmosphere was gloomy, like a hospital. We ordered 2 spaghetti, 1 alfredo, and a salad bar and garlic bread. Our food cost about 60 dollars.The salad bar was really good but everything else was terrible. The bread sticks were gross, and the garlic bread was topped with garlic and oil, and wasn't good at all. The spaghetti sauce looked like it came out of a can or was frozen, it was chunky and didn't taste good. The 16 dollar alfredo with shrimp was oily and had too much garlic in it. It had cheap popcorn shrimp in it. Food was so bad and expensive that I couldn't even force myself to eat it because I started to feel sick. There are plenty of other places that you can go to get better food for the same price.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 4
We have went here for years and really enjoy their food they got good prices and good food it's worth the drive
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Closed at random times, unreliable business.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Like everything else in life nowadays the food quality is just not quite what it used to be but still good. Service was real good clean and quiet place to have a lunch
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
The food was great! Nice salad bar, great pizza! The service was good too! As far as the seating, it's kind of dark and needs some sprucing up. I would definitely order from them again, only as a takeout or delivery next time.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Been going since it was Maxie’s.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time eating here. The pizza and salad bar was excellent, the service was excellent as well.
However; they had their son there who was eating a cucumber slice from the tongs. Putting it right into his mouth and back into the cucumber bowl.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Canadian Bacon Pizza, One-Trip Salad Bar
We had the salad bar, it was fresh and delicious! Such a variety of items ie. Sweet pickles, beets, cucumbers, cottage cheese etc
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Found this little place while passing through on a road trip. My niece and I got the chicken parmigiana and the lasagna, both were ordered to go.
Starting with the good things: 1. the lady at the counter taking orders was very nice 2. the quaint decore was endearing and felt like stepping back to a simpler time 3. portions sizes were large 4. prices would have been fair if the food was better quality, each entre was about $16 and came with garlic bread and a garden salad.
Now for the bad: 1. The chicken parmigiana was made with frozen pre-packages chicken patties, like what you would get in a banquet tv dinner. They had a very spongy texture 2. The lasagna wasn't made with any discernable layers, it was just a pile of cut up lasagna noodles with sauce, cheese, and ground sausage all mixed up. It tasted ok though 3. The garlic bread was very dry and bland 4. The salad was lack luster, just pre-made bagged iceberg lettuce with a couple veggies thrown on 5. We didn't get any utensils to eat our food with.
The restaurant smelled good and the pizza looked really great. Maybe if we had gotten the pizza we would have had a better experience. I would suggest steering clear of the pasta dishes here.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
Locally owned and operated with great pizza. Ive only had their puzza so cannot comment on the rest of their offerings. Fresh, good salad bar with a macaroni salad on it thats delicious. Very nice staff. Can't go wrong at Monterey Jack's.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I order take out pizza about every two weeks. Two times the pizzas were so undercooked that I threw them out. Last time was March 24, 2025. I ordered 2 pizzas, both were undercooked. The crust was so raw I threw them out. Also the one was supposed to be to be a vegetarian and I didn’t even recognize what they gave me. I arrived on time and had to wait 25 minutes. Salad bar needed to be restocked, most items were empty. Total waste of time and money.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Damn good pizza. Will be ordering again soon.
Their pizza and lasagna is AMAZING! If you loved Maxie’s, you’ll love eating here!
BEST PIZZA! Recommend there Idiots Delight
Over the last 10 months we have found hair in our food on 5 separate occasions. Then this happened..... on Thanksgiving eve I ordered a chicken club sandwich with seashore fries and a side of onion rings. About two hours later I was having a stomach ache but by midnight I was extremely 🤢. it felt like getting jabbed with a knife or such..... then the vomiting started. I texted Slice and told them what was up..... long story short... everyone was here for Thanksgiving dinner and I missed 90 percent of it. I wasn't completely well until this last Sunday. I tried to get it settled with Slice as the mediator. Ain't working...... OM Goodness.. Their offer is they will give me 20 per cent off my next order....... REALLY 😄🤣 LIKE I WOULD EVER ORDER FROM THEM AGAIN. Not after hair and then poisoning me. Next time you order for delivery... check out the inside of that bag they bring it in. Oh what don't I recommend you about them..I ...recommended NEVER GO THERE..........EVER.
Loading...