Mystic Cafe
1303 Main St, Lewiston
(208) 743-1811
Customers' Favorites
The Mystic Turkey Melt
Chicken Fried Steak
Fish Street Tacos
Garbage Potatoes
Cuban Sandwich
Eggs Benedict
Mystic Burger
Cinnamon Roll
French Fries
Polenta Fries
Menu
Photos
+59 photos
+58 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
We visited Mystic Cafe on our anniversary weekend getaway after reading good reviews and finding our other top choices were closed for 4th of July weekend. We were disappointed. The ambiance is fantastic - we loved it. But it is very fast food and not meant for lingering over dinner. Our reservation was for 6:30 and we were out the door by 7:00. I ordered the chicken tortellono and it was buried in a thick, cheesy cream sauce - I literally picked the chicken and tortelloni pieces...
Absolutely 5 Stars for service, food presentations, taste, and cleanliness. High class and comfortable restaurant. Very enjoyable experience! We had a large college graduation group, and every one of us was awed by the servers, cook, food, drinks. and wonderful time at Mystic Cafe!!!
Oh my gosh, totally in love with this place! We came for lunch and had tacos and a blt and oh my it was delicious! It was cool to learn about the history of what the restaurant used to be, we loved the decor, I wish we were still in town to catch some live music, but there is always next time. Loved it so much we are going back for breakfast before we leave town.
You May Also Like
Eagles Lounge - 1310 Main St
![]()
Cocktail Bar, Lounges
Tacos Cecy - 1350 Main St
![]()
Mexican, Food Stands, Vegetarian
Koi Japanese Steakhouse & Sushi - 1407 Main St
![]()
Japanese, Sushi Bar