Agape Coffeehouse
20 S 16th St, Payette
(208) 642-7233
Customers' Favorites
Chipotle Ranch Sirloin Steak Burrito
Grilled Turkey and Havarti Sandwich
Almond White Chocolate Scone
Breakfast Sandwich All Week
Spicy Steak Quesadilla
Biscuits and Gravy
Peaches and Cream
Mango Smoothie
White Lotus
Pour Over
Frozen
House Chai Frozen
House Chai blended
Big Train Chai Frozen
Creamy Big Train chai blended with your choice of milk and ice.
Cremosa Frozen
Hot Chocolate Frozen
Lemonade(Frozen)
Matcha Latte Frozen
Mocha Frozen
Cricket Mocha Frozen
Mexican Mocha Frozen
S'mores Mocha Frozen
Turtle Mocha Frozen
Velvet Mocha Frozen
White Alaska Frozen
Caramel Marble Frozen
Milky Way Mocha Frozen
Breve Frozen
Caramel Marble Frozen
Latte Frozen
Coffee
Breve
Rich, creamy, delicious. Comprised of our house Espresso and steamed Half and Half, this drink is a winner.
Milkyway
A popular choice! Crafted with our house espresso, white chocolate, chocolate, carmel, and steamed milk.
Turtle
An epic classic combination. The Turtle is made with our classic house crafted espresso, caramel, hazelnut, rich chocolate and silky steamed milk. A favorite among fellow Agape patrons!
White Alaska
The white chocolate version of the Mocha. This is creamy and dreamy. Made with our house espresso, steamed milk and white chocolate, an ever popular drink at our shop!
Mocha
Made up of our House roasted espresso, delicious rich gourmet chocolate and silky steamed milk, this drink is excellent! The chocolate and espresso make for a beautiful dark backdrop for our crisp white latte art, enjoy!
Mexican Mocha
The Mocha with an excellent twist, a dash of cayenne and cinnamon. Whether you enjoy a small amount of heat with your mocha or you wish to stop a heart attack this drink is for you!
Shot in the Dark
Our fresh brew of the day with shots of our house espresso. This drink is for serious coffee fanatic and caffiene seekers.
Latte
One of the flagship standards of the industry. The latte is a simple and very enjoyable beverage. Our house roasted espresso with steamed milk and a thin layer of silky, smooth, and delicious microfoam which serves as our canvas for beautiful latte art hand crafted with love!
Cappuccino
One of the most ordered coffee drinks in America. This exciting beverage is made using our house crafted espresso topped with a thick layer of silky foam. It can come either as a wet cappuccino(Even proportions of steamed milk and foam with espresso) or Dry(Higher proportion of silky foam to milk, with espresso)
Pour Over
Our freshly roasted coffee of the day ground fresh and then expertly brewed with the pour over method just for you. This method brings out more clarity and a better complexity in each cup.
Flat White
This delicious cup is an 8 oz latte. Commonly called a Flat White in Australia. This option allows you to experience our espresso as it melds beautifully with the milk, developing many of the subtle flavors found in the espresso. A favorite among baristas!
Filter Coffee
Our freshly roasted brew of the day brewed to perfection in our Fetco Coffee brewer!
Americano
Our special hand crafted espresso in hot water, this classic option showcases the natural flavors in our espresso. The shots pulled to extract as many natural sugars and oils from the beans that we can while avoiding the "bitters" and then they are preserved immediately in either hot water or ice. A very popular choice.
Shot of espresso
Smoothies
Banana
Berry Good
The Berry Good smoothie is made with real strawberries, blueberries, raspberries, and blackberries
BlackBerry
BlueBerry
Chocolate monkey
Crafted rich chocolate and real bananas
Honey Berry Hemp
Mango Smoothie
The Berry Good smoothie is made with real strawberries, blueberries, raspberries, and blackberries
Peach Mango
Peaches N' Cream
Made with real peaches and cream.
Strawberry
StrawBerry-Banana Smoothie
Delicous banana smoothie made with real banana
Hot Chocolate/Steamers
Gourmet Cocoa
Classic, comforting, rich and warming. A favorite among our young customers and those desiring chocolate without the coffee.
Velvet Dark Hot Chocolate
Wonderful rich dark cocoa! Great for chocolate lovers also works beautifully with espresso.
Mexican Hot Chocolate
Rich Cocoa with cayenne.
White Elephant
Steamed milk with silky white chocolate.
Kids Hot Cocoa
Delicous hot cocoa made at a lower temp. Comes in 8 oz
Steamer
Steamed milk with your choice of flavor
Tea and Wellness
House Chai
Our own house crafted Indian inspired Chai made with love right here in our kitchen.If you crave authentic chai, this is your drink!
Big Train Chai
A very popular choice for lovers of sweet chai. Some have requested us to rename this drink to Choo Choo Chai, what do you think?
Dirty Chai
Big Train chai with our house espresso. Sweet spices, creamy foam and just a hint of rich espresso.
Fresh Brewed Tea
A wide assortment of delicious teas
Golden Milk
An extremely flavorful combination of ginger, tumeric, honey, spices and coconut milk.
Traditional Matcha
Finely ground organic japanese tea whisked with the tradtional method in hot water
Matcha Latte
Organic Japanese matcha tea steamed with milk-- a delicious treat!
London Fog
A fantastic treat for tea drinkers. Earl grey tea and lavender with a layer of thick, silky foam.(Hot) or Iced earl grey with lavender infused with creamy half and half(Iced)
Loose Leaf Tea
Our loose leaf tea's are sourced from Certified organic farms and are fairtrade certified. They boast a wide array of certificates that are too many to list
Tea for Two
Baked Goods And Snacks
Gummies
Fruit Leather
Pouches
Coffee Blossom Honey Sticks
Oatmeal Cup
Cranberry Orange Scone
Snickerdoodle
Blueberry Lemon Zest Scones GF
bread pudding
Bottled Beverages
Kirkland Water
Bottled water
Red Bull
Red Bull
Martinelli's Apple Juice
Brew Dr. Kombucha Lemon Grove
Brew Dr. Kombucha Superberry
Honest Kids Organic Juice Pink Lemonade
Honest Kids Organic Juice Fruit Punch
Sanpellegrino
Jones Soda
Good to Grow
Guayaki Yerba Mate Enlighten mint
smart water
Poppi Soda
Simply Gum
Peppermint Natural Chewing gum
Refreshing and subtly sweet, our Peppermint chewing gum is simply delicious. We've been told that it's an on-the-go essential, perfect to grab before a meeting, after lunch, or whenever you need a little kick.
Details
• Made in United States
• Ingredients: Organic Raw Cane Sugar, Natural Chicle Base (chicle, candelilla wax, citric acid), Natural Peppermint Oil, Organic Vegetable Glycerin, Organic Rice Flour
Pumpkin Spice Natural Chewing Gum
It's PUMPKIN SPICE SEASON! Don't miss out on this seasonal flavor. It'll only be around for a little while. Made with Pumpkin, Nutmeg, and Clove, our new Pumpkin Spice flavor tastes just like your favorite latte and pumpkin pie.
Pumpkin Spice is THE Fall flavor for all your Fall activities like after school sports, to pumpkin picking, to coffee shop chats!
Made in United States
• Ingredients: Organic Raw Cane Sugar, Natural Chicle Base (chicle, candelilla wax, citric acid), Nutmeg Oil, Clove Oil, Pumpkin Oil, Cayenne Pepper, Organic Vegetable Glycerin, Organic Rice Flour
Spearmint Natural Chewing Gum
Refreshing and subtly sweet, our natural Spearmint chewing gum is simply delicious. Each pack of gum is made in New York with the finest ingredients sourced from around the world. They never use anything artificial - no aspartame or synthetic plastics.
Made in United States
• Ingredients: Organic Raw Cane Sugar, Natural Chicle Base (chicle, candelilla wax, citric acid), Natural Spearmint Oil, Organic Vegetable Glycerin, Organic Rice Flour
Peppermint Natural Chewing Gum Sugar Free
Made with xylitol, our new Sugar-Free Peppermint gum has the same refreshing, minty flavor as our original, but without the sugar. Xylitol has the same great taste as sugar but with almost half the calories and a lower glycemic index. Studies have shown that xylitol boosts dental health and helps prevent cavities.
Made in United States
• Ingredients: Plant-based Xylitol, Natural Chicle Base (chicle tree sap, candelilla wax, citric acid), Peppermint Oil, Organic Vegetable Glycerin, Gum Arabic, Organic Rice Flour
Simply Mints Awaken(Caffeine)
Awaken mints, made with Peppermint and Matcha, contains 360 mg of Caffeine in each tin, which is the equivalent of 4 cups of coffee. It's the perfect mint for enjoying throughout the day, whenever you need a little boost.
Made in Canada
• Ingredients: Cane Sugar, Peppermint Oil, Matcha Powder, Natural Caffeine, Calcium Stearate
Simply Mints Ginger
Not all mints are, well, mint. The perfect pick-me-up after coffee or dinner, our ginger mints are refreshing with just the right amount of zing. Made with only four ingredients, they won't leave you with a sugary aftertaste, either.
Made in Canada
• Ingredients: Cane Sugar, Ground Ginger Root, Ginger Extract, Calcium Stearate
Simply Mints Meyer Lemon
Simply Mints Peppermint
Breakfast
Chipotle Ranch Sirloin Steak Burrito
Epic combination of Housemade Chipotle ranch, Philly style Sirloin Steak, Farm Egg, Potato and Sharp white Cheddar cheese. Crisped to perfection on our Panini press
Biscuits and gravy
Breakfast Sandwich
Our house made sourdough smothered in our zesty garlic truffle aioli, melted havarti cheese, bacon and farm fresh egg!
Lunch
Biscuit
Tomato Bisque
Freshly roasted beans
Columbian 1lb
Haitian Blue 1lb
Haitian Blue Mountain Baptiste
Mellow, smooth and creamy body. Roasted almonds, buttery mouthfeel. Low acidity with a sweet, smooth finish. Astonishing balance.
Guatemala Ayarza Onyx 1 Lb
Organic Sumatra 1lb
Sumatra
Big exotic flavors from this wild Indonesian coffee! Spicy notes of Red Rooibos tea, earth and dried date. A subtle floral overtone mixes with deep, dark chocolate ganache. A favorite amongst coffee lovers.
Monsooned Malabar 1lb
Monsoon Malabar
Harvested during monsoon season, this single origin coffee has a strong forefront note of pipe tobacco, a touch of soft bergamot and a dry, dark chocolate finish.
Decaf 1lb
Agape 5 Bean Espresso 1lb
Agape Signature Espresso
A rich and complex six bean blend with a nutty aroma, notes of smooth dark chocolate, and a delicate jasmine finish.
Espresso 1/2lb
Decaf 8oz
1\2 monsooned malbar
Sourdough Boule
Sourdough Boule
Asiago Parmasan Romano
Jalepeno Cheddar
Photos
+54 photos
+53 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
This coffeehouse is our favorite spot for either a breakfast and coffee or lunch. The pastries are superb and of the finest quality. We consider Agape Coffeehouse to be on par with high-end coffeehouses we've visited all over the world.
July 2025
A great craft coffeeshop with good coffee and an immaculate atmosphere. The Paulsons have done a great job with it. We especially love hanging out at their Artisan Markets on the weekends. Not to mention there is a fenced-in playset for kids so parents of young kids can relax.
They roast their own beans and do a good job. Their coffee is definitely on the darker side. It works well with their espresso drinks. They also have creative tea options which we’ve...
They roast their own beans and do a good job. Their coffee is definitely on the darker side. It works well with their espresso drinks. They also have creative tea options which we’ve...
June 2025
I work from home and coming here daily for the last week or so, it's a great little place that has delicious coffee. I am on a White Alaska kick and highly recommend it with their biscuits and gravy!
January 2025
You May Also Like
Burger King - 305 S 16th St
![]()
Burgers, Fast Food
Erika's Kitchen - 1630 3rd Ave S
![]()
American
Subway - 455 S 16th St
![]()
Sandwich Shop, Fast Food