Best pizza place in town! You can’t go wrong here, exceptional quality and service. It’s underrated and usually never a wait even though there is no parking in the parking lot. Way better than Righteous Slice, I like it better than Mod!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: BBQ Chicken Bacon, Pizza
Heather Cameron
This is the hardest review I've ever written because of the two extremes in our experience. We ordered pizza and dessert for takeout. The pizza was amazing! Easily one of the best pizzas I've ever had. We did the build your own option (all the toppings you want for one price!) The brisket was especially yummy! Delicious and a good value.But the desserts were a different story... We had huckleberry cheesecake and a chocolate cake. They were both terrible. I don't think I've ever called a dessert terrible before. We actually threw the cheesecake away after one bite. It had zero huckleberry flavor and it just tasted really off...maybe rancid or sat in a fridge too long and picked up other flavors? The chocolate cake was so dry. The mounds of frosting on top made it edible, but not worth more than a few bites. And these desserts were not cheap. So disappointing.
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Rachael Mickelsen
I came here with my husband and two kids. It’s the cutest restaurant. You walk in and right away you see cheesecakes and ice cream. ? They have a ton of home decor items displayed all throughout the restaurant, and the layout is super adorable. We went on a Wednesday night at around 6 PM. There were a couple workers there, and they were able to make and bake our food swiftly. We ordered a build-your-own pizza and a bbq chicken pizza. The pizza was fantastic! The flavors really came through, and the crust was crispy. ?? My husband also ordered their root beer float. It was huge! We loved our visit there, and we will be back again soon.
Alix G.
I was anything but impressed. Our waitress seemed like she was not trained very well. My food not only looked absolutely unappetizing but was soggy and gross to say the least. Pizza should not be like that. I would have chosen Little Ceasers over this. Will not be going here again.
Beth Johnson
My husband and I were looking forward to trying this place. I have to say, we were disappointed. First off, the customer service was very mediocre. We didn’t know where to order for a minute and not one person greeted us or helped us out. We waited quite a while for our food considering that there was hardly anyone there. The food was also very mediocre. I did like the rosemary crust. My husband on the other hand, hated the texture of the cheese so much, he spit it out. Also, it was extremely overpriced! When we got to the register, I was shocked: $24.00 for two 8 inch pizzas and 2 sodas. We could have gone to Righteous Slice for the same price for full sized delicious pizzas.
Ethan
Great pizza, the best in Rexburg by far. Service is slow usually but it’s all worth the wait.
Katie Robinson
Straight up so good! If you don’t eat here you might as well just not live. If I had the money I’d buy this place, and then never eat anything but their pizza. HIGHLY ENJOYED.
Carie Benson
It's soooooo good! I tried the bacon and macaroni and cheese pizza, just to try this seemingly strange combination out, but ended up loving it. It's now my favorite pizza type ever!
Jodie Orme
Always SO SLOW! Not sure why I keep coming back thinking it will be better this time. The food is good but plan to spend at least 45 minutes waiting for them to ask you want to order…even if you are only 2nd in line. This has been my experience at least 4 times. They have got to figure something out…I will not be back.
Jaeger Jane
Straight up so good! If you don’t eat here you might as well just not live. If I had the money I’d buy this place, and then never eat anything but their pizza. HIGHLY ENJOYED.
Great pizza! Great service! Throw on all the meats and cheeses and you’ll have a taste of Heaven!
Kalan Spencer
Absolutely amazing. I got the pizza with every meat topping on it and it was beautiful. HIGHLY RECOMMEND
Chris Obay
I ONLY give it 5 stars for the girl working by herself in the front and the quality of the food! NOT for the management!! When she says please don't tip that the employees don't get the tips that the owner takes it!! Wow ?
David
The food is great. The service is terrible. Every time I’ve gone, the employees are slow, clueless about customer service and how the restaurant works. Someone please train these poor kids how customer service works.
Jasmine A.
My friend and I went and had a horrible experience. Her pizza was undercooked so we asked for it to be put back in the oven. Then my pizza came and it was all burnt and not edible. I asked for it to be made again and it came out the same way. Customer service was super slow and there was only one worker. We waited in line for 20 mins when we were the only ones there.
Best pizza place in town! You can’t go wrong here, exceptional quality and service. It’s underrated and usually never a wait even though there is no parking in the parking lot. Way better than Righteous Slice, I like it better than Mod!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: BBQ Chicken Bacon, Pizza
This is the hardest review I've ever written because of the two extremes in our experience. We ordered pizza and dessert for takeout. The pizza was amazing! Easily one of the best pizzas I've ever had. We did the build your own option (all the toppings you want for one price!) The brisket was especially yummy! Delicious and a good value.But the desserts were a different story... We had huckleberry cheesecake and a chocolate cake. They were both terrible. I don't think I've ever called a dessert terrible before. We actually threw the cheesecake away after one bite. It had zero huckleberry flavor and it just tasted really off...maybe rancid or sat in a fridge too long and picked up other flavors? The chocolate cake was so dry. The mounds of frosting on top made it edible, but not worth more than a few bites. And these desserts were not cheap. So disappointing.
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizza
I came here with my husband and two kids. It’s the cutest restaurant. You walk in and right away you see cheesecakes and ice cream. ? They have a ton of home decor items displayed all throughout the restaurant, and the layout is super adorable. We went on a Wednesday night at around 6 PM. There were a couple workers there, and they were able to make and bake our food swiftly. We ordered a build-your-own pizza and a bbq chicken pizza. The pizza was fantastic! The flavors really came through, and the crust was crispy. ?? My husband also ordered their root beer float. It was huge! We loved our visit there, and we will be back again soon.
I was anything but impressed. Our waitress seemed like she was not trained very well. My food not only looked absolutely unappetizing but was soggy and gross to say the least. Pizza should not be like that. I would have chosen Little Ceasers over this. Will not be going here again.
My husband and I were looking forward to trying this place. I have to say, we were disappointed. First off, the customer service was very mediocre. We didn’t know where to order for a minute and not one person greeted us or helped us out. We waited quite a while for our food considering that there was hardly anyone there. The food was also very mediocre. I did like the rosemary crust. My husband on the other hand, hated the texture of the cheese so much, he spit it out. Also, it was extremely overpriced! When we got to the register, I was shocked: $24.00 for two 8 inch pizzas and 2 sodas. We could have gone to Righteous Slice for the same price for full sized delicious pizzas.
Great pizza, the best in Rexburg by far. Service is slow usually but it’s all worth the wait.
Straight up so good! If you don’t eat here you might as well just not live. If I had the money I’d buy this place, and then never eat anything but their pizza. HIGHLY ENJOYED.
It's soooooo good! I tried the bacon and macaroni and cheese pizza, just to try this seemingly strange combination out, but ended up loving it. It's now my favorite pizza type ever!
Always SO SLOW! Not sure why I keep coming back thinking it will be better this time. The food is good but plan to spend at least 45 minutes waiting for them to ask you want to order…even if you are only 2nd in line. This has been my experience at least 4 times. They have got to figure something out…I will not be back.
Straight up so good! If you don’t eat here you might as well just not live. If I had the money I’d buy this place, and then never eat anything but their pizza. HIGHLY ENJOYED.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great pizza! Great service! Throw on all the meats and cheeses and you’ll have a taste of Heaven!
Absolutely amazing. I got the pizza with every meat topping on it and it was beautiful. HIGHLY RECOMMEND
I ONLY give it 5 stars for the girl working by herself in the front and the quality of the food! NOT for the management!! When she says please don't tip that the employees don't get the tips that the owner takes it!! Wow ?
The food is great. The service is terrible. Every time I’ve gone, the employees are slow, clueless about customer service and how the restaurant works. Someone please train these poor kids how customer service works.
My friend and I went and had a horrible experience. Her pizza was undercooked so we asked for it to be put back in the oven. Then my pizza came and it was all burnt and not edible. I asked for it to be made again and it came out the same way. Customer service was super slow and there was only one worker. We waited in line for 20 mins when we were the only ones there.