“Freaky fast” must acutely mean “we will think about making your food for at least 30 minutes and then tell you it’s on its way both times you call 15 minutes apart.” I have to wonder if the concept of eating on your lunch break is built into their business model. I started typing this 5 minutes after my last phone when I was told it would be 4 more minutes. Still no sign of my food!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Trypten Babcockc
Ordered the beach club sandwich that, mind you, the avocado is the best part of the sandwich. I have eaten this sandwich at several other Jimmy John’s locations and there is plenty of avocado spread on this sandwich. After I take a couple of bites of the sandwich I got at the Rexburg Jimmy John’s, I realize I can’t taste any avocado. Opened the sandwich and didn’t see any avocado either. I went back to the store and the employee had us open our sandwich and look between the cheese, where I found approximately 1/8th of a teaspoon of avocado spread. Could not even taste the avocado spread as I ate the remainder of the sandwich. Do better Rexburg Jimmy John’s, do better.
Food: 2
Service: 1
Jacquline Maggetti
Great experience at the Jimmy John’s in Rexburg! The restaurant was clean, and my family and I were greeted right away when we walked in. Our order was taken promptly, and everything came out exactly as we requested, fresh and correct.
While we didn’t ask for recommendations, we also weren’t offered any suggestions, so definitely ask about extras or add-ons that might not be obvious on the menu, they have some great ones!
The restrooms were clean, and the outdoor seating was a huge bonus. The trees surrounding the building add such a beautiful, colorful touch, and you get a great view of Rexburg Park while you eat.
Overall, a solid, satisfying visit. We’ll definitely be back next time we’re in town!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Kasydee Ranae Ricks
I just ordered a sandwich there and half of the things were not even on the sandwich. No cucumbers, no pickles that I asked for, and on top of that whatever knife they used to cut my sandwich in half was covered in mustard. It is not that hard to make a sandwich correctly! I've been an employee there before (a manager) and know how simple it is to read the ticket and make the sandwich correctly.
Food: 1
Service: 3
Valeria Perez
I’ve been eating at Jimmy John’s for years now. I have had a couple orders messed up in this location, but nothing tops this. Moldy bread on my sandwich. I was just offered a refund, and it’s in app money value, not my actual cash. I hope I don’t get sick. The people are very nice, but nice isn’t enough when mistakes like these happen.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
C.C.
First time trying this place and wasn't super impressed. The sandwich was lacking something.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Trinity Mason
some girl at window hit on my boyfriend with ME IN THE CAR. that’s embarrassing for her.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Brad Smith
Jimmy John's, "Freaking Fast!" Not this one. Freakin' slow.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
Katie Arciga
I love the sandwiches from here! They are always quick and delicious.
Madilyn Benson
We ordered our food and the drinks were only filled half way with NO ice (all 6 drinks), then we opened our sandwiches and they had no lettuce after we ordered lettuce and were very poorly put together and was missing other toppings. There was a very small portion of turkey and all I tasted was bread. It was like they just threw everything together and called it good. VERY disappointed
The food was ok, it definitely isn't as fresh and amazing as they were the 1st few years.
Kid-friendliness: I always take my kids and grandkids!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Avocado Spread
Kelle Erickson
I placed my order 40 min before my lunch break. 30 min later still no lunch so I called. Was told they were swamped and it should be another 10 min. Finally found my order and sent it with a delivery service. Took another 10 min. Basically my order took approximately 1 hour to get to me and they didn’t send my drink. I love the food but the amount of time for delivery is extremely disappointing. This has happened to me several times with longer wait times. Probably need to find another sandwich shop
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Lesa Jackson
Placed an order to be delivered at noon - didn't show up til after 1PM. When you have a specific time for people to eat for a meeting and Jimmy John's says "sorry, they're swamped and short staffed" whose issue is that - VERY POOR MANAGEMENT - in my opinion!! NOT freaky fast. Their delivery service is sub-par at best.
Food: 4
Service: 1
Eli Heindel
Not a fan. The food made me feel sick after a few bites and I couldn't finish it. Which for me is rare I can eat pretty much anything. However the staff was incredibly kind and the interior was very clean.
“Freaky fast” must acutely mean “we will think about making your food for at least 30 minutes and then tell you it’s on its way both times you call 15 minutes apart.” I have to wonder if the concept of eating on your lunch break is built into their business model.
I started typing this 5 minutes after my last phone when I was told it would be 4 more minutes. Still no sign of my food!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Ordered the beach club sandwich that, mind you, the avocado is the best part of the sandwich. I have eaten this sandwich at several other Jimmy John’s locations and there is plenty of avocado spread on this sandwich. After I take a couple of bites of the sandwich I got at the Rexburg Jimmy John’s, I realize I can’t taste any avocado. Opened the sandwich and didn’t see any avocado either. I went back to the store and the employee had us open our sandwich and look between the cheese, where I found approximately 1/8th of a teaspoon of avocado spread. Could not even taste the avocado spread as I ate the remainder of the sandwich. Do better Rexburg Jimmy John’s, do better.
Food: 2
Service: 1
Great experience at the Jimmy John’s in Rexburg! The restaurant was clean, and my family and I were greeted right away when we walked in. Our order was taken promptly, and everything came out exactly as we requested, fresh and correct.
While we didn’t ask for recommendations, we also weren’t offered any suggestions, so definitely ask about extras or add-ons that might not be obvious on the menu, they have some great ones!
The restrooms were clean, and the outdoor seating was a huge bonus. The trees surrounding the building add such a beautiful, colorful touch, and you get a great view of Rexburg Park while you eat.
Overall, a solid, satisfying visit. We’ll definitely be back next time we’re in town!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
I just ordered a sandwich there and half of the things were not even on the sandwich. No cucumbers, no pickles that I asked for, and on top of that whatever knife they used to cut my sandwich in half was covered in mustard. It is not that hard to make a sandwich correctly! I've been an employee there before (a manager) and know how simple it is to read the ticket and make the sandwich correctly.
Food: 1
Service: 3
I’ve been eating at Jimmy John’s for years now. I have had a couple orders messed up in this location, but nothing tops this. Moldy bread on my sandwich.
I was just offered a refund, and it’s in app money value, not my actual cash.
I hope I don’t get sick.
The people are very nice, but nice isn’t enough when mistakes like these happen.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
First time trying this place and wasn't super impressed. The sandwich was lacking something.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
some girl at window hit on my boyfriend with ME IN THE CAR. that’s embarrassing for her.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jimmy John's, "Freaking Fast!" Not this one. Freakin' slow.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
I love the sandwiches from here! They are always quick and delicious.
We ordered our food and the drinks were only filled half way with NO ice (all 6 drinks), then we opened our sandwiches and they had no lettuce after we ordered lettuce and were very poorly put together and was missing other toppings. There was a very small portion of turkey and all I tasted was bread. It was like they just threw everything together and called it good. VERY disappointed
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Good, but they always mess up our orders.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 3
The food was ok, it definitely isn't as fresh and amazing as they were the 1st few years.
Kid-friendliness: I always take my kids and grandkids!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Avocado Spread
I placed my order 40 min before my lunch break. 30 min later still no lunch so I called. Was told they were swamped and it should be another 10 min. Finally found my order and sent it with a delivery service. Took another 10 min. Basically my order took approximately 1 hour to get to me and they didn’t send my drink. I love the food but the amount of time for delivery is extremely disappointing. This has happened to me several times with longer wait times. Probably need to find another sandwich shop
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Placed an order to be delivered at noon - didn't show up til after 1PM. When you have a specific time for people to eat for a meeting and Jimmy John's says "sorry, they're swamped and short staffed" whose issue is that - VERY POOR MANAGEMENT - in my opinion!! NOT freaky fast. Their delivery service is sub-par at best.
Food: 4
Service: 1
Not a fan. The food made me feel sick after a few bites and I couldn't finish it. Which for me is rare I can eat pretty much anything. However the staff was incredibly kind and the interior was very clean.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Loading...