Just what we needed after a road trip Pizza was good, vibes were good Had a good cashier didn’t catch her name but had black hair
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
Abi B
This Pizza Pie Cafe seems like it is struggling to keep up with their many customers. It is a college town after all, so that is not surprising. The selection is varied, the food is tasty (especially the pasta sauces), and the workers are friendly. And the decorations are cool. And they do take pizza requests, but you need to get them in as soon as you arrive to reap the benefits.
Here is what would have made our visit better:
1. Get rid of the booth seating!!! Honestly, for a buffet restaurant, booth seating is ridiculous. People constantly have to make everyone on their side of the table get up so they can revisit the buffets. Then when they come back, everyone has to move again. How can anyone sit down and eat in peace with having to move...and move... and move out of the way.
2. Fix the broken automatic hand towels in the women's bathroom. It is more sanitary to wash and completely dry hands. And in a buffet setting, ensuring your customers have clean hands is very important.
3. Make combo pizza a regular option.
4. Have the bus boys clear away plates more often, especially with larger groups. Our table was never cleared and we had a group of 12, so the plates really stacked up on our tables.
5. Install better, brighter lighting.
6. Fix your fly problem.
That might sound like a lot a cons. I do recommend this for a pizza buffet. The ingredient lists are pretty clean, too. Like they use real cream in their sauces, ect.
If the owner would take the time to install some upgrades, and the workers would stay on top of things like working hand towels and cleaning tables faster (or maybe they just need more workers hired to deal effectively with their workload), then a three star restaurant could become a five star restaurant.
Average pizza. Better than pizza hut or domino's but still mid grade pizza IMO.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pizza and Salad
Brekken Pope
Very good food. The employees are great at what they do. The tables are always clean and the service at the front is amazingly fast. I drink Mountain Dew often, and every time I come here it is more of an orange color. I highly recommend coming here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chris
Obnoxious screamo/metal and even some sexually explicit music played loudly throughout the restaurant on 10/05 around 6 PM.
Some of the songs were remixes and Tik Tok edits, so it was clearly a very inventional curated custom playlist.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 2
Travis N Lindsay Palmer
There are several pizza choices in buffet. Salad is great. Breadsticks were a fave. My kids loved the dessert pizzas. Great location in Rexburg. Prices are responsible. Not the best pizza I've had but still yummy. We've gone several times. Eat in a booth or tall tables with barstools.
Kid-friendliness: Kids love this place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizzas, Salad Bar, Pizza and Salad
Elle Critch
Food is good. Service is also good but the line was really long. Overall not bad but there is better pizza at other places. The pasta is pretty decent too, I just wish they would make sure it’s fully drained before being put on your plate!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Salad Bar, Pizza and Salad
umukundwa gisellephionah
The pasta was great, the pizzas were not cooked all the way, you could see and taste the dough
Crystal Nykreim
Pizza and Pasta were really good. Only down was they were out of parmesean, and the empty tables were a little messy. But overall really good and super affordable. Dessert Pizza was amazing.
Vegetarian options: Amazing Pasta and sauce selection, veggies Pizza was available, and great salad bar
Kid-friendliness: Lots to choose from
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Raspberry Desert Pizza, Pizzas, Salad Bar, Chicken Alfredo
The place was very busy but the staff was always helpful and pleasant. Best salad bar in town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad Bar
Maea Lefai
Cranked out the pizza, pizza was astute. Quite wonderful experience for me and the chums
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Oreo Dessert Pizza
Larry Jones
Good food, great service
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Raspberry Desert Pizza, Pizzas, Salad Bar
Eli Heindel
For buffet pizza, it's great. For regular pizza, it is edible dont expect greatness or anything above, "It's alright." You get what you pay for. And if you look at it that way, it's worth going.
We had a disappointing experience at Pizza Pie Cafe last week, which reached the attention of management. The problem had to do with the lack of pizza available while we were dining.
Ty explained why they were having problems on that particular evening and offered some buffet passes in an attempt to make things right. Kudos to him for making every effort to set things right and for reaching out. Things don’t always go as planned and Ty’s response was outstanding. Thank you!
Great food and service
Just what we needed after a road trip
Pizza was good, vibes were good
Had a good cashier didn’t catch her name but had black hair
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
This Pizza Pie Cafe seems like it is struggling to keep up with their many customers. It is a college town after all, so that is not surprising. The selection is varied, the food is tasty (especially the pasta sauces), and the workers are friendly. And the decorations are cool. And they do take pizza requests, but you need to get them in as soon as you arrive to reap the benefits.
Here is what would have made our visit better:
1. Get rid of the booth seating!!! Honestly, for a buffet restaurant, booth seating is ridiculous. People constantly have to make everyone on their side of the table get up so they can revisit the buffets. Then when they come back, everyone has to move again. How can anyone sit down and eat in peace with having to move...and move... and move out of the way.
2. Fix the broken automatic hand towels in the women's bathroom. It is more sanitary to wash and completely dry hands. And in a buffet setting, ensuring your customers have clean hands is very important.
3. Make combo pizza a regular option.
4. Have the bus boys clear away plates more often, especially with larger groups. Our table was never cleared and we had a group of 12, so the plates really stacked up on our tables.
5. Install better, brighter lighting.
6. Fix your fly problem.
That might sound like a lot a cons. I do recommend this for a pizza buffet. The ingredient lists are pretty clean, too. Like they use real cream in their sauces, ect.
If the owner would take the time to install some upgrades, and the workers would stay on top of things like working hand towels and cleaning tables faster (or maybe they just need more workers hired to deal effectively with their workload), then a three star restaurant could become a five star restaurant.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Apple, Oreo Dessert Pizza, Spud-O-Licious, Penne Carbonara
Average pizza. Better than pizza hut or domino's but still mid grade pizza IMO.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pizza and Salad
Very good food. The employees are great at what they do. The tables are always clean and the service at the front is amazingly fast. I drink Mountain Dew often, and every time I come here it is more of an orange color. I highly recommend coming here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Obnoxious screamo/metal and even some sexually explicit music played loudly throughout the restaurant on 10/05 around 6 PM.
Some of the songs were remixes and Tik Tok edits, so it was clearly a very inventional curated custom playlist.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 2
There are several pizza choices in buffet. Salad is great. Breadsticks were a fave. My kids loved the dessert pizzas. Great location in Rexburg. Prices are responsible. Not the best pizza I've had but still yummy. We've gone several times. Eat in a booth or tall tables with barstools.
Kid-friendliness: Kids love this place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizzas, Salad Bar, Pizza and Salad
Food is good. Service is also good but the line was really long. Overall not bad but there is better pizza at other places. The pasta is pretty decent too, I just wish they would make sure it’s fully drained before being put on your plate!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Salad Bar, Pizza and Salad
The pasta was great, the pizzas were not cooked all the way, you could see and taste the dough
Pizza and Pasta were really good. Only down was they were out of parmesean, and the empty tables were a little messy. But overall really good and super affordable. Dessert Pizza was amazing.
Vegetarian options: Amazing Pasta and sauce selection, veggies Pizza was available, and great salad bar
Kid-friendliness: Lots to choose from
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Raspberry Desert Pizza, Pizzas, Salad Bar, Chicken Alfredo
Restaurantji Recommends
The place was very busy but the staff was always helpful and pleasant.
Best salad bar in town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad Bar
Cranked out the pizza, pizza was astute. Quite wonderful experience for me and the chums
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Oreo Dessert Pizza
Good food, great service
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Raspberry Desert Pizza, Pizzas, Salad Bar
For buffet pizza, it's great. For regular pizza, it is edible dont expect greatness or anything above, "It's alright." You get what you pay for. And if you look at it that way, it's worth going.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cookie Monster, Oreo Dessert Pizza, Raspberry Desert Pizza, Pizzas, Penne Carbonara, Oreos Pizza, Chicken Alfredo Pizza, Salad Bar, Hawaiian Pizza Pepperoni Pizza Dessert Pizza, Pizza and Salad, The Hillbilly Pizza, Cheese Pizza, Cookie Dough Dessert Pizza, Chicken Ranch, Chicken Alfredo, Garlic Knots
We had a disappointing experience at Pizza Pie Cafe last week, which reached the attention of management. The problem had to do with the lack of pizza available while we were dining.
Ty explained why they were having problems on that particular evening and offered some buffet passes in an attempt to make things right. Kudos to him for making every effort to set things right and for reaching out. Things don’t always go as planned and Ty’s response was outstanding. Thank you!
Service: 5
Loading...