When you order to go, the online price is 30% cheaper than if you walk in and order it as a to go order. I was kind of surprised and nobody could explain it. The hostess simply said “I don’t know why” and the young manager who came out said he didn’t know either. Perhaps that is a question to ask. I also ordered two different sauces for my spaghetti (thinking they would come in little cups or something) and instead of putting them on separately they mixed two completely different sauces on top of the spaghetti, which sort of spoiled the spaghetti- I was not given any option. I had planned on a portion for lunch the next day... but sadly It was not a very good mix! This was the first time I had been there, and I was a bit disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 3
Shanelle Thompson
There are too many kids running around unsupervised, very loud, like a chucky
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Daniel Stolle
The pizza is very delicious, there are quite a few types of pizza and they have salad and pasta options on the side. There is plenty of seating and it is beautifully decorated. The quality of the pizza is not the best, but the buffet is not that expensive and you can eat a lot. The service was normal.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Keaton Ballard
Pizza Pie Cafe is a classic buffet joint that I’ve been going to for 15 years. The food is already good but the actual tastiness of the food all depends on your creativity. See below my tips for increasing the tastiness of the food!1. Get pasta with your favorite sauce (I like carbonara or alfredo)2. Scrape the toppings off of your pizza slices onto your pasta (chicken alfredo pizza for the alfredo pasta) (chicken bacon ranch pizza for the carbonara pasta)3. Enjoy your pasta that now contains grilled chicken, extra cheese, onions, and tomatoes.I’ve also known some people who use the same technique but put the pizza toppings onto their salads. This technique makes this place a really fun place to eat because it opens up lots of possibilities for your meal!You’re welcome!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizzas, Chicken Alfredo, Chicken Alfredo Pizza, Salad Bar
Adasynn Elison
A good place for large groups if you make a reservation. Make sure to try their oreo pizza for dessert!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Oreo Dessert Pizza, Pizzas, Spud-O-Licious, Chicken Alfredo, Garlic Knots, Chicken Alfredo Pizza, Oreo, Salad Bar, Pizza and Salad
Andrew Parker
Great place to have family, the food was good, not great, but good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizzas, Salad Bar
Nathan Pederson
It's a all you can eat pizza buffet. It's got a salad bar, pasta, and of course, pizza. By far the highlight is the desert
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Brent Lords
Great variety of pasta & sauce choices, salad bar options, pizza and dessert pizza. I love going there for the food. The service is lacking. Everything I go there and no one is at counter I will usually stand there for a couple minutes before anyone comes even though co-workers right on other side of wall see me and make eye contact. No one says hi or someone will be right with you. And the workers who clean used dishes off tables will clean some but walk right past me with some used for some reason. It's random as I see it happen with others also. Maybe some secret thing that only they know the sequence of who to clean off. It's not a full dirty dishes tub either.It's called customer service & cleanliness.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizzas, Oreos Pizza, Hillbilly, Garlic Knots, Chicken Alfredo Pizza, Large 14 Cheese Stix, Pizza and Salad
Vicki Wickham
Love the variety of pizzas they offer and I really enjoy the salad bar.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
Isaac Oliphant
It's a pizza buffet, so naturally they sacrifice quality for quantity; I like it though. While a little pricey to go over and over again, it's a great spot to go with some friends.
Not surprised of the reviews here on below average buffet pizza. Then I'm not surprised because the byu-idaho coeds have a burnt pallet
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 5
David Crasper
Was great not to slow with getting
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Isabelle Paul
I had an amazing dining experience at Pizza Pie Café! The ambiance was warm and inviting, and the staff was incredibly friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anonymous Tips
Pizza pie Cafe is through and through a pizza buffet. There are a ton of different pizza flavors to choose from. Gluten options will cost extra though for those who may need to consider that. Loads of other different menu options are also available, such as a really solid salad bar, and even various pasta options. As is customary to most restaurants that charge for drinks, they do it shamelessly, as $2.99 for a soft serve drink is kind of steep even for the area especially. The pizza itself though is better than Little Caesars, but falls short somewhere before Pizza Hut and other various chains in terms of flavor for some of the pizzas. Highly recommend finishing off with some of the dessert pizzas, they are a worth while experience by itself.I have personally been to this location several times, the customer service experience is either rock solid or has some room for improvement, overall though, this is a great option for a pizza buffet eatery in the Rexburg Area.Edit: Added realtime pictures from last visit.Parking: Plenty of parking even during peak hours of operation.
When you order to go, the online price is 30% cheaper than if you walk in and order it as a to go order. I was kind of surprised and nobody could explain it. The hostess simply said “I don’t know why” and the young manager who came out said he didn’t know either. Perhaps that is a question to ask. I also ordered two different sauces for my spaghetti (thinking they would come in little cups or something) and instead of putting them on separately they mixed two completely different sauces on top of the spaghetti, which sort of spoiled the spaghetti- I was not given any option. I had planned on a portion for lunch the next day... but sadly It was not a very good mix! This was the first time I had been there, and I was a bit disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 3
There are too many kids running around unsupervised, very loud, like a chucky
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
The pizza is very delicious, there are quite a few types of pizza and they have salad and pasta options on the side. There is plenty of seating and it is beautifully decorated. The quality of the pizza is not the best, but the buffet is not that expensive and you can eat a lot. The service was normal.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Pizza Pie Cafe is a classic buffet joint that I’ve been going to for 15 years. The food is already good but the actual tastiness of the food all depends on your creativity. See below my tips for increasing the tastiness of the food!1. Get pasta with your favorite sauce (I like carbonara or alfredo)2. Scrape the toppings off of your pizza slices onto your pasta (chicken alfredo pizza for the alfredo pasta) (chicken bacon ranch pizza for the carbonara pasta)3. Enjoy your pasta that now contains grilled chicken, extra cheese, onions, and tomatoes.I’ve also known some people who use the same technique but put the pizza toppings onto their salads. This technique makes this place a really fun place to eat because it opens up lots of possibilities for your meal!You’re welcome!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizzas, Chicken Alfredo, Chicken Alfredo Pizza, Salad Bar
A good place for large groups if you make a reservation. Make sure to try their oreo pizza for dessert!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Oreo Dessert Pizza, Pizzas, Spud-O-Licious, Chicken Alfredo, Garlic Knots, Chicken Alfredo Pizza, Oreo, Salad Bar, Pizza and Salad
Great place to have family, the food was good, not great, but good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizzas, Salad Bar
It's a all you can eat pizza buffet. It's got a salad bar, pasta, and of course, pizza. By far the highlight is the desert
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Great variety of pasta & sauce choices, salad bar options, pizza and dessert pizza. I love going there for the food. The service is lacking. Everything I go there and no one is at counter I will usually stand there for a couple minutes before anyone comes even though co-workers right on other side of wall see me and make eye contact. No one says hi or someone will be right with you. And the workers who clean used dishes off tables will clean some but walk right past me with some used for some reason. It's random as I see it happen with others also. Maybe some secret thing that only they know the sequence of who to clean off. It's not a full dirty dishes tub either.It's called customer service & cleanliness.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizzas, Oreos Pizza, Hillbilly, Garlic Knots, Chicken Alfredo Pizza, Large 14 Cheese Stix, Pizza and Salad
Love the variety of pizzas they offer and I really enjoy the salad bar.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
It's a pizza buffet, so naturally they sacrifice quality for quantity; I like it though. While a little pricey to go over and over again, it's a great spot to go with some friends.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
Restaurantji Recommends
Not surprised of the reviews here on below average buffet pizza. Then I'm not surprised because the byu-idaho coeds have a burnt pallet
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 5
Was great not to slow with getting
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
I had an amazing dining experience at Pizza Pie Café! The ambiance was warm and inviting, and the staff was incredibly friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza pie Cafe is through and through a pizza buffet. There are a ton of different pizza flavors to choose from. Gluten options will cost extra though for those who may need to consider that. Loads of other different menu options are also available, such as a really solid salad bar, and even various pasta options. As is customary to most restaurants that charge for drinks, they do it shamelessly, as $2.99 for a soft serve drink is kind of steep even for the area especially. The pizza itself though is better than Little Caesars, but falls short somewhere before Pizza Hut and other various chains in terms of flavor for some of the pizzas. Highly recommend finishing off with some of the dessert pizzas, they are a worth while experience by itself.I have personally been to this location several times, the customer service experience is either rock solid or has some room for improvement, overall though, this is a great option for a pizza buffet eatery in the Rexburg Area.Edit: Added realtime pictures from last visit.Parking: Plenty of parking even during peak hours of operation.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pizzas, Cookie Dough Dessert Pizza, Cookie Dough, Spud-O-Licious, Oreos Pizza, Chicken Alfredo
Salad was old. The staff also struggled to keep up with the demand for pizza. The staff was helpful and friendly! They are the reason I go.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas, Cookie Dough Dessert Pizza