The Cookie Place

24 W 1st S, Rexburg
(208) 970-6543

Recent Reviews

Dale Kissell

Omg! The sugar cookies are

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Natalie B.

This place's cookies are delicious! They have really good flavors, but unfortunately the cookies are kind of small and overpriced.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chip, Assorted Cookies

Noah Sharp

This place is better than crumbl easily. All of their cookies are delicious. Especially love their snickerdoodle one. I'm giving up four stars though due to the

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Annie C.

Much better than crumble! They had a great variety available and staff is so kind. We ordered a couple dozen for a gathering and they were quick to serve us

River Osborn

These cookies are ridiculously delicious, and I'm not really even a cookie/sweets person. They're a tad pricey but for a special occasion (like a Tuesday) they're totally worth it. The sugar cookie frosting is heaven.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 5

Anonymous Tips

"Better than Crumble Cookies."The staff member was very courteous, easily explaining the offered menu options well, and getting us on our way very quickly! Cookies are absurdly expensive though, profit margins are evidently through the roof, but this is to no surprise as this is how their in-town competitor is set up as well.Pictured is just one of their cookies, for a reference of size and for what you are getting.Worth the visit, but insanely expensive cookies all around.

kaylee gray

For as much as they where three of our cookies where still doughy that’s outrages 14 Dolores for undercooked cookies not worth it

Ali Kilpatrick

The Cookie Place is the best! Not only are their cookies the best in the area the customer service is fantastic. I have contacted Val for 3 years in a row to support local military members and she never hesitates. I love businesses that support our troops!

Robin F.

The cookie place serve up hugh individual portion size cookies is why their prices r a little higher I believe. The service was great. if you approach them & u explain u have a allergy concern for certain ingredient in a certain type of cookie. They will tell you if it's 1 of your do not eat.

Adrianna B.

Best cookie spot in town by far! And I love supporting a local business:) Cookies are delish and huge.

Erika B.

Absolutely love this place! I recently moved away from Idaho to a state with so many different cookie shops, and none of them even come close to The Cookie Place. For any special occasion, or even just because, I order these cookies and have them shipped to me. The owners are incredible and always ship them so quickly. The cookies are AMAZING - by far the best cookies I've ever had. I can't say enough good things about this place! So happy I get to enjoy them even from a different state.

Miguel Coelho

Great stuff!The cookies were D E L I C I O U S! The box looks very well made and the cookies are so good?

Liam

Very big and delicious! Me and my wife are loving it.

Kevin J. Baxter

BETTER THAN CRUMBL!!!! Very professional, high quality cookies. My favorite flavor is the s’mores cookie made with the actual ingredients for s’mores! If you can afford one cookie try it!

Reese Stoddard

I absolutely recommend the cookie place! Their cookies are amazing and the people themselves are awesome. Great service and great cookies.

Load More