Nice relaxing atmosphere. Great burgers! Excellent service!
Ammy Jorgenson
Very fresh inviting vibe! Cool place to hang out for both kids and adults.
John Kitsmiller
Very nice server. Loved they even have water outside for your pup - sure indicator of my kind of place. Zeke loved his burger too!
Jay and Stephanie
The key lime pie was amazing. Great service and dog friendly (outside)
Connie Kehrer
Had the prime rib with mashed potatoes and asparagus. Service was excellent: prompt and very friendly. However I was disappointed in the quality of the meat, which was not very tender and contained a lot of gristle. I noticed other reviews which rate the prime rib very highly, which makes me wonder if the quality of available meat has declined in the last few months. Because mine was just not very good. Also, although the atmosphere and ambience was pleasant, it was too warm with no AC. Not sure if they have AC or not, but if they don’t I would not eat here in the middle of the summer.
Bill Duffey
Always a fun spot
Jamie Chilberg
I had the “Maine Lobster Roll” and I was disappointed. I’ve had excellent lobster rolls before, in Spokane (Makiel’s, High Tide/Zona Blanca), and a similar item for a similar price is what I was expecting. Lobster rolls should be rich, but what I got tasted like carbs. Too much, too crusty bread. And the filling I can’t believe is more than 20% actual lobster. I don’t know what else was in there, it’s a mystery. Imagine a chicken salad sandwich without the chicken. It was something like that. To be fair, what I got was a way bigger portion than what I was expecting. But I only ate less than half of it, and picked the visible lobster pieces out of what was left. It just wasn’t very good, especially for the price ($29). They’d do well to make it much smaller so they don’t have to cheap out on the essential ingredient.
The service wasn’t awful but it wasn’t particularly good either. To be fair, they were pretty busy for a Tuesday night. I left a tip anyway.
I’m not angry, just disappointed.
Glen Bates
I went back to baxters yesterday 6/7/25 to get the prime rib and this time it wasn't even prime rib. Both my girlfriend and l were and are totaly bumed and fully disapointed. I should of took a picture of it. We wont go back.
I got the prime rib The prime rib was absolutely delicious I will definitely go back, it was worth every penny. Yummy 💯
Kent Hooper
Most excellent burger. Great service. The kitchen missed on a couple things...our salad that was on our plate withe burger was almost hot..? Very warm. We're pickle people..had to ask for the pickle...like I said...kitchen screw up...Brie was great.
Rudy Rudebaugh
Great atmosphere, food is top shelf and music made for a enjoyable evening.
Baxters is the worst restaurant experience I have ever had bar none. I called in early like 4 to 5 hours early to find out what I needed to do as I work nights in Sandpoint but live way south so I called in told them what I was wanting and what should I do, the guy was short with me but told me to call in at least a half hour early. OK I told him I lived 40 minutes away so I would call before I left (this was for a steak salad) I called 1 hour before I had to be at work the Man was extra rude to me, I never told him I had talked to him earlier it doesn’t matter you shouldn’t treat prospective customers the way he did. He was so rude I said never mind I would NEVER ORDER from this place after that experience
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Liz
Cute setting in downtown Sandpoint, the food is very Rich and beautifully portioned but small plates and larger prices. We had a couple drinks to visit but with outside seating refills on drinks was pretty slow. However servers were very friendly.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Linnea Ryckman
Good food good service great desserts
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brian Christiansen
Great little place with fantastic service and comfort food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ian Morris
Off peak visit. Sept 29. Quiet. Pleasant staff. Lost the order. Finally received the order after an hour and a half waiting. They offered a bowl of soup to keep us going. We were hungry by 8:30pm!
Meatloaf - boring. Better meatloaf in the frozen section of the supermarket.
Steak good. Huckleberry sauce - nearly tasteless.
Mash potatoes - Nice and hot!
They didn't comp a thing. Just charged us for everything (except the soup).
Nice relaxing atmosphere. Great burgers! Excellent service!
Very fresh inviting vibe! Cool place to hang out for both kids and adults.
Very nice server. Loved they even have water outside for your pup - sure indicator of my kind of place. Zeke loved his burger too!
The key lime pie was amazing. Great service and dog friendly (outside)
Had the prime rib with mashed potatoes and asparagus. Service was excellent: prompt and very friendly. However I was disappointed in the quality of the meat, which was not very tender and contained a lot of gristle. I noticed other reviews which rate the prime rib very highly, which makes me wonder if the quality of available meat has declined in the last few months. Because mine was just not very good. Also, although the atmosphere and ambience was pleasant, it was too warm with no AC. Not sure if they have AC or not, but if they don’t I would not eat here in the middle of the summer.
Always a fun spot
I had the “Maine Lobster Roll” and I was disappointed. I’ve had excellent lobster rolls before, in Spokane (Makiel’s, High Tide/Zona Blanca), and a similar item for a similar price is what I was expecting. Lobster rolls should be rich, but what I got tasted like carbs. Too much, too crusty bread. And the filling I can’t believe is more than 20% actual lobster. I don’t know what else was in there, it’s a mystery. Imagine a chicken salad sandwich without the chicken. It was something like that. To be fair, what I got was a way bigger portion than what I was expecting. But I only ate less than half of it, and picked the visible lobster pieces out of what was left. It just wasn’t very good, especially for the price ($29). They’d do well to make it much smaller so they don’t have to cheap out on the essential ingredient.
The service wasn’t awful but it wasn’t particularly good either. To be fair, they were pretty busy for a Tuesday night. I left a tip anyway.
I’m not angry, just disappointed.
I went back to baxters yesterday 6/7/25 to get the prime rib and this time it wasn't even prime rib. Both my girlfriend and l were and are totaly bumed and fully disapointed. I should of took a picture of it. We wont go back.
I got the prime rib
The prime rib was absolutely delicious
I will definitely go back, it was worth every penny.
Yummy
💯
Most excellent burger. Great service. The kitchen missed on a couple things...our salad that was on our plate withe burger was almost hot..? Very warm. We're pickle people..had to ask for the pickle...like I said...kitchen screw up...Brie was great.
Great atmosphere, food is top shelf and music made for a enjoyable evening.
Restaurantji Recommends
Baxters is the worst restaurant experience I have ever had bar none. I called in early like 4 to 5 hours early to find out what I needed to do as I work nights in Sandpoint but live way south so I called in told them what I was wanting and what should I do, the guy was short with me but told me to call in at least a half hour early. OK I told him I lived 40 minutes away so I would call before I left (this was for a steak salad) I called 1 hour before I had to be at work the Man was extra rude to me, I never told him I had talked to him earlier it doesn’t matter you shouldn’t treat prospective customers the way he did. He was so rude I said never mind I would NEVER ORDER from this place after that experience
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Cute setting in downtown Sandpoint, the food is very Rich and beautifully portioned but small plates and larger prices. We had a couple drinks to visit but with outside seating refills on drinks was pretty slow. However servers were very friendly.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Good food good service great desserts
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great little place with fantastic service and comfort food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Off peak visit. Sept 29. Quiet. Pleasant staff. Lost the order. Finally received the order after an hour and a half waiting. They offered a bowl of soup to keep us going. We were hungry by 8:30pm!
Meatloaf - boring. Better meatloaf in the frozen section of the supermarket.
Steak good. Huckleberry sauce - nearly tasteless.
Mash potatoes - Nice and hot!
They didn't comp a thing. Just charged us for everything (except the soup).
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
Loading...