Papa Kelsey's | Pizza & Subs

379 S Idaho St, Wendell
(208) 536-2505

Recent Reviews

Brian Moore

Very fast service for the lunch rush

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rachael Douglas

My husband called and placed an order around 6 pm, he asked for a hawaiian pizza sub & a light onion french dip (he had to ask for light onions 4 times!).. we brought it home. My husband has a regular pizza sub no pineapple whatsoever. My French dip is covered & I mean covered in onions. My husband's fry sauce is broken and spilled in his fries.. oh and half were burnt. For not a single person eating in there at the time of order... cmon.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Shawn Parks

Good lunch

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Whitney Hankel

Overcharged, food was terrible, 2 pizzas were made completely wrong! I get server bad migraines eating anything tomato based. Specifically requested 2 of them to be made with ranch base instead of pizza sauce. Drove in a bad snow storm to get them and came back home to 2 being made wrong and the 1 pizza for the kids tasted like it had rotten cheese!! All I asked for was a refund of all my money!! Especially being over charged!! Deal was 2 medium 2 topping pizzas for $20.99! I got charged $61.24 for 4 medium pizzas!! If it were The Gines or the Sears that still owned the restaurant they would have done me right!! NEVER AGAIN WILL I EVER RECOMMEND THIS PLACE NOR WILL I EVER EAT HERE AGAIN!!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Christal Bowman

This place is a joke! 2 pizzas were made completely wrong and they tasted terrible! The girls working had terrible customer service! And even after my daughter talked to the owner and he said he would do full refund on Monday he turned around on Monday and refused to do it!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jacquelyn Crocker

The pizza is way over priced and it’s really terrible. Bland, weird textured cheese and just not good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 3

Dsn Stonekilla

Absolutely amazing service, very clean. They employee is super nice and helpful

Bird Fleck

The food is SO GOOD! You need to go here! I've had the subs before and they blow my mind.I had a breakfast burrito and it was perfection! My friend got the breakfast pizza and it looked really good too! She said it was. It was super cold there but the food warmed us up.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alonzo Ayón

Food was not fresh. Friendly staff, but the corners of the bread for the subs were so hard and soggy in the middle. Super overpriced for something below average! Sorry, not sorry :(

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Karlena Sears

Called at 8:24 pm to order pizza they answered and said sorry we closed an hour early. Not a way to operate a business if your hours are posted with out subject to change. Won’t be in business for long if this is how you operate.

Desiree Thompson

Pizza was not edible tasted as if it had been spritzed with capsaicin. I ordered a Supreme add

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Dean Moreno

The ladies there were wonderful and the service was amazing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Triple Meat Supreme Sub

Lois Spitz

If I could give 0 stars to the Jerome location I would. Definitely don't recommend delivery from this location (Jerome location) due to using doordash. I ordered some subs for my family and never got them. Ordered them at about 7:30pm. We never received our order. No call nothing. Ended up with our ordered getting canceled through a text and then they closed the location for the night. The last the could do is call and refund our money. But nope they just canceled and closed. Delivery shouldn't be an option unless your order is guaranteed to be delivered.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Maria P.

Came for dinner after a day at the hot springs. We ordered a large Hawaiian pizza and asked if we could substitute pepperoni for the Canadian bacon. We were charged for an additional topping (pepperoni) and then they eliminated the Canadian bacon for free. I wish they would have told me about the extra charge because I may have not made it. The large pizzas were $2 off but we didn't get that discount...so remember to ask before paying. The pizza was just Ok. Everything is out of a can or box...nothing original. Cheap ingredients made for just a barely Ok pizza. The salad was head lettuce with 2 chopped pepperonis and a sprinkle of olives and cheese. Again, not worth the price. The gal ringing us up didn't know how to add a combo meal or how to give up the advertised discount. She never looked at us, made friendly eye contact, nor greeted us warmly....she looked like a deer in the headlights. I understand just starting out, but much more training is needed. Overall we had a very poor experience, and poor food for $26. We will never be back.

Ariana M.

Every time I go in there it's bad service. The kids working are always laughing and joking around in the back. My order is always missing half the ingredients it's a joke is anyone in charge here?

Load More

Papa Kelsey's | Pizza & Subs

379 S Idaho St, Wendell, ID 83355
(208) 536-2505