Casey's

39131 N Sheridan Rd, Beach Park
(224) 348-3410

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Brady Christians

They can't even cook a pizza right.

Jarome

I am a dedicated food reviewer with a blog that has over 11.7K followers. I have been a frequent customer at this Casey’s since it opened, visiting daily during the overnight shift after work. It’s unacceptable that I’ve observed your cashier sleeping on shift multiple times, sometimes requiring another employee—either a young man or a woman from the kitchen—to step in. This situation compromises customer service and security. Given the opportunity, someone with ill intentions could easily exploit this vulnerability, yet the staff continues to sleep during my visits 3-5 times per week. I am not trying to target any individual, such as the man with the beard at the front, but I am concerned about safety. I will be returning, and I expect this issue to be addressed promptly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 2

kenneth mcintosh

Honestly swing through here almost every day, whether on the way to or from work. I love the food, and the people are always so nice to me! Tay is definitely my favorite and always extremely helpful!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Jaida Durham

Very clean & very good customer service . I was serviced by Ariona and she was amazing!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brian Wheeler

Bought pizza twice and was very good and fresh. However the service is ok at best. The fuel pumps processes debit cards pretty slowly and sometimes I have to insert my card in twice because it freezes. The atmosphere is great. Outside and inside is clean.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza and Sausage Pizza

Rafaela Perez Arroyo

PIZZA GAVE ME DIARRHEA !!!!!! HAD TO GO TO THE

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Edgar Arroyo

DO NOT GO HERE IF YOUR LIFE DEPENDS ON IT!! GO SOMEWHERE ELSE. my husband ran out of gas and they said they couldn’t take cash right now. And their pizza gave me diarrhea. Disgusting people with no answers. Don’t go here!!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Pan Verde

I’m going to tell you something pizza lady let her cook. I love this place I never had a bad experience. get your self some gas and a pizza save your self time, also brother in the kitchen doing a great job doing midnight orders keep up the good work hermano

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Melvin Powell

Nice gas station, good fountain drinks

Service: 5

steffy09ish

This location has very unreliable hours of operation & at times very unpleasant staff. Employees are always closing this store in the middle of the night at random. (No they are not just closing briefly for a bathroom break, we have sat in the parking lot for long periods waiting on multiple occasions and nobody ever opened the door) & the times we have been able to shop inside, Staff treats us like we are an inconvenience to them. We dealt with it for so long because we LOVE Casey’s, but this location is HORRIBLE!!! You should not be pulling up nervously wondering which irritated employee is working that shift or if the door will open… Lately we have just been giving our business to the 7/11 up the road instead of stopping to pull on a locked door... it’s such a shame!

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Alexander Oronia

This is the worst Casey’s I’ve been thought I’ve too over 50 stores in 4 different states this is a horrible store

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Deja Brown

What's the point of having a card reader that offers cash back if you don't want to give customers cash back???? Update the card readers so you won't have any more confusion

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 2

Jordan Ruble

This is a horrible store, on two separate occasions I have payed for gas and went to pump it and the pump not work correctly twice and both times all the money from the transaction was taken but I received no gas. I understand how the system works, however this is unacceptable to continuously happen. I know this corporation will do absolutely nothing about it so I figured I'd leave a warning for others.

Dan Flores

Stopped this morning to fuel up. They were maybe 3 pumps that were open the rest had the yellow bags on them indicating they were out. It's happened before. No real pizza but mostly slices that have been there all day garbage over flowing by the pumps they they have baffoons running the place or the owner is one. Such high hopes for this place when they were building ot gas station nearby with food that they advertised but it's turning into a ghetto garbage over flowing sore!!!

efore. No real pizza

Rebecca

They never have pizza and are frequently closed for no apparent reason.

Loading...