Olde Western Pizza Co.

13351 Old Western Ave, Blue Island
(708) 388-8900

Recent Reviews

Holly Lee

My son and I have been searching for a new pizza place and I think we have found it! The service, food and follow up were AMAZING! We ordered a pizza Friday night (I forgot to take a pic) and went back the next day for sandwiches! Yummy!Thank you!

Mark S.

I live 4 blocks outside of Blue Island. You do not serve Blue Island and the surrounding area. You don't deliver to my house. Your loss. Maybe try automobiles. They run on gasoline and delivery drivers usually own their own. I'm ordering pizza from farther away and I tip pretty good.

R.J. Hall

The pizza is very good. The prices are rather high but overall it's a cool restaurant. It'll have to be a every once in a while stop due to the prices. The boneless chicken tenders/wings are underwhelming in size and quantity. I would recommend sticking with the pizza.

Mona Le’on

This pizza is really good ! First time here and the lady Jessica I think her name is was so sweet very happy nice lady I will be back for more food

Bob F.

Decided to go here with a group of 12 the Wednesday after Christmas. All of us old Blue Islanders. We were interested to try this "new" pizza. We were pleasantly surprised with our choice! Ordered some apps, onion rings, mozzarella sticks, and cheesy garlic bread. All respectable! But the hit of the evening was the pizza! We sampled both the thin crust and the original hand tossed. Cheese and sausage as well as sweet veggie. Very tasty and enjoyable. Our server was great and the owner very accommodating! Could not have asked for a better experience. Highly recommend! Will return again.

Tim He

The thin crust is absolutely amazing and cooked to perfection. Some of the freshest tasting ingredients I’ve ever had! Great staff and welcoming atmosphere!

Daniel D.

The pizza was very good! The bartender was very nice and helped us decide what to order, we will definitely be back.

Jorge Aviles

Best Pizza in Blue Island!!! I recently placed a big order and everyone was so helpful, Great Pasta!!! Delicious Hot Wings!!Des, thank you for making my party a success.

Ram Cast

If i could give more stars, i would !!! Thanks for coming to Blue Island! They replaced a shuttered staple in Blue Island and brought life to the building. Their pizza is among the best in the area, I’ve been eating beggars my whole life and it is a tough choice between the 2. Their pizzas are thin crust, their toppings are plentiful and seasoning will very well satisfy your tastebuds, and is always fresh. The owner and employees are also a pleasure to work with, very friendly and courteous and respectful. Pricing is in-line with the competition, if not cheaper. I wish to eat their pizza for many years to come! Keep up the good work guys and thanks for being in our community!!!

Melissa DeForte-Villarreal

The staff is incredibly friendly and the thin crust pizza is really good! Also, try the sausage or pepperoni balls as an appetizer - they are amazing! Really happy to have this place in Blue Island and we'll be back for sure!!

L W.

A nice surprise not much from the outside but quaint on the inside. Relatively clean, pizza is good.

Rochelle Thomas

Came here tonight because I read the Google reviews under the new owner (Justin) that were really good. Just so you know it's a cute, clean, friendly restaurant. The pizza is tavern style with very fresh ingredients. I definitely recommend you try this neighborhood restaurant. Pucture is of my pizza (sorry its half eaten) and the amazing Sausage balls. I hope this place stays around for a long time.

Lindsay Jackson

Enjoyed the pizza. Wish it had more sausage on it for the price point. Sauce was good...makes me want to try a grinder with that marinara. Very friendly staff. They offer slices. Great place to eat while you do laundry! Would consider getting a larger thin crust on pizza night.

Hilford Gardon

thin crust giardiniera pizza was amazing and still good reheated.XL pizza came with pizza balls and dipped in marinara sauce they were little hand held deep dish pizzas. 5/7 will be back every time we're in town.i was too busy eating to take pics.

Juan Diaz

If you’re bar hopping or just around olde western, come check these guys out!! Fantastic homemade pizza made with natural ingredients & lots of love!! Great customer service ever!! This is my new spot for a fact now ?

Load More