Fatty Magoo's Bar & Eatery

We had a build your own pasta, a sandwich and the fried ravioli. The food was really good. Only down side I’d say was that the ranch on the starter salads was a little too watery, but the taste overall was good. Appetizer didn’t come until after the meal had been brought out and we’d started eating, so we really didn’t want it by the time it came. Service was a little disappointing, it took us over 2 hours to get in and out which seems long for a fast casual place. Server literally would put something on the table and run away without talking to us, so it was just kind of an odd experience service-wise. We would come again for the food, but are cautious to do so because of the service.

Nothing special. Had the fish fry, very small pieces, but it was ok. Place could have been cleaner, floor could have been swept. Server had to correct our check three times. Charged us for 3 items that were included (fries and salad) with dinner. Salad was never brought, when asked to take it off the bill, she asked if I wanted it to go....no.

Parking lot makes it look like it's closed, but it's open. Went in. Got beers with a co-worker and food. My Stella draft wasn't good, switched to Corona in bottle. That was good. Half price burger, it was also ok. Nothing great, but not horrible. Co-worker had pizza and that was good. Overall, my bill wasn't high. Bathroom faucet is janky, it's partially broken. If they could give the parking lot some tlc, and others. Might be better. I wouldn't recommend.

Gyros were a disgrace to Greece, hot wing were ok .. haven’t tried the pizza yet but so far the best thing they had to offer was the Italian beef egg rolls

Great food and great service. So good! Our waitress Samantha was very attentive and timed everything perfectly for our to go addition. Highly recommended

Great food, good atmosphere. Best Vodka Sauce I've had in a long time!!! Do yourself a favor and swing in for a bite and a pint.

If you enjoy a good dive bar, then Fatty Magoo's is for you! We had a thin crust pizza and chicken strips. The chicken strips were a little overdone. The pizza was good. They put a generous amount of cheese on top so if you're the type that picks toppings off, you will have a harder time seeing what you want to pick off. Good service. Good food. Probably won't be back.

Went on Sunday. Really good food, nice cold beer. Good spot!

Food was delicious, had tequila wings with limes. Excellent will get again. Also had our go to, Salerno special pizza cooked to perfection.

Great vibe. Decent pizza.Was only turned off when asking the female manager to remove dollar on the wall with offensive language on it. Initially she gave me a hard time downplaying the whole thing. But after further discussion, she kindly respected my request to take it down and let me replace it with something more respectable. In the future I hope no one allows this level of ignorance to be displayed on their wall so carelessly. But if they chose to, just be aware thats all. Fingers crossed they dont take my $5 down. Peace and love always.

Enjoyed my visit. Ashley rocks!!! Margie rocks!!! Sam rocks!!!Good Atmosphere. Good Food.Definitely recommend for good energy, food and drinks.

Friendly locals, great friendly helpful staff!

Haven't been there in years. Won't go back. Especially with my women. The management was okay with some crazy guy yelling at everyone very threatening statements. Because the staff was cool with it we just left vs calling the police.

wow Rude service. I came in because of reviews. I called in asking if family friendly, they said yes, I had 2 kids. came in at 5:30 didn't get pizza until 6:40!!!! they were only maybe 3 - 4 tables in all of people. not crowded. I wish they advised it would be a long time. my daughter asked for a chili that was nasty, and we returned immediately and was still charged due it. questioned manager and she refused to compensate chili. I have never ever been so disrespected by a so called manager that wished to debate me in front of other customers. I wish the owner sees my review.

Poor service, only offered appetizers on the menu. Waited half hour and watched 2 ‘servers’ flirt with 1 guy at the bar, do shots with him. When we said we were leaving then food was suddenly ready. Took it to go, we’d had enough.