Had myself a slice of cheese pizza, a breaded steak sandwich and a cannoli and it was all very delicious! This area needed a place with slices hot and ready to go that isn't a gas station and I couldn't be happier with the quality of this place! Will be my go to heading to work for a slice! A week later I got a 16" pizza half cheese half sausage and it was cooked to perfection. A lot of other places I have to ask for well done but Legends knows how to do it without even asking! The mozzarella sticks and breaded mushrooms were also excellent. Highly recommend and will be coming back frequently!
scott lange
I have eaten there twice and was very pleased with the quality of food and the size of the portions. The first time I had the pizza OMG great taste and and great ingredients. Today I had legends pasta alla vodka it was amazing again great taste and ingredients and huge portions. If there was ten stars I would have given them ten stars. They are a welcome pizza/restaurant in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tassie Tagarelli
I stopped by Legands yesterday for a slice. I had heard great things about this place on social media. Pleasantly....all were true ?. Great food, friendly staff and a great owner.I ordered a medium cheese, since the slices end at 4:00pm & I was there about 4:30pm. I also ordered a chicken parm sandwich to go and a side of meatballs to enjoy while waiting for the pizza.The owner & his daughter Natalie were sitting at the counter & said hello. We struck up a conversation and I enjoyed hearing their story about how/why they started a pizza place.I really enjoyed the meatballs & red sauce...so much so that I ate my chicken parm sandwich at the counter as well. While chatting with Natalie.The pizza was thin, crispy & perfectly baked well done, as I ordered.Food was great, friendly staff & will definitely be back. Natalie mentioned her Mom makes the lasagna ??. Can't wait to try it!!They are still in the process of completing the interior. When completed they will have slots, a bar & later hours. Really appreciate the later hours - as a night owl.....it will be great to get a quality, fresh made pizza after 10pm ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anthony Galatte
This place is FANTASTIC!The owners are gems, employees are sweethearts, atmosphere and vibe are on point - Oh, and the food is PHENOMENAL!We have been in the area now for almost 3 years and since the pandemic ended, we try to, for the most part, hit a different pizza spot every time we order out for it.My wife kept hearing about this place and we finally picked up some Za and Ribs on Sunday and my whole family is in love!This is going to be our go to spot 75 percent of the time, the other 25 percent will go to being adventurous, or if we are out of town lol…. Not kidding tho!Looking forward to buying some of their merchandise too.We will be seeing them again very soon for our next date night.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lanie K.
Stopped in last weekend. Food and service was excellent. Family owned. Staff was very friendly! Did not realize they just opened about a month ago. My husband and I had fried pickles, the Italian sausage burger, and a small pizza with Italian beef and green peppers. Everything was excellent. The Italian sausage burger was something so different and so tasty. Italian beef was best I've ever had on a pizza. Pizza sauce and crust was perfect. We will definitely be back. I'm craving it already!
Jeffrey Hurd
I knew right away when they made their dressings for the salad I was very happy with the ranch dressing. Salad is simple and delicious. The setting is simple and very clean. The staff is friendly and treated me like they knew me.Pizza just arrive and it smells wonderful and guess what they cut in squares. I love square cuts. Wonderful flavor. Crust is perfect slight crunch and I don’t have to fight with it Recommend you check it out
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rino Miulli
Finally, a place in Carol Stream where you can sit down with your family and enjoy very fresh and homemade recipes.We were pleasantly surprised by the customer service and the amazing food. We ordered several items on the menu and the pizza was delicious. You can tell they use very high-quality ingredients and a lot of love. We will be back very soon.
Clint F
Update April 2024: Ordered again via online with delivery. Pizza was promised for delivery in 60-65 minutes and was at my door exactly when promised. Ordered a sausage pizza again to compare to last time and also got a tiramisu. The pizza arrived warm (not hot) with golden color cheese and a cracker thin crust. Crust was improved, light and buttery. This time the sausage pieces were larger (with great flavor) and cheese was good (I do like that the cheese is not greasy at all). Tiramisu was very tasty. Overall, I am going to update to 4/5 stars.-------------This is a new pizza place that just opened early March 2024. Placed order via phone. Was a little surprised they didn't ask for a name. Ordered a large cheese and sausage. Pizza was promised to be ready in 25-30 min, and when I arrived just before the 30 min mark I was greeted and they asked what my order was (since they didn't take my name I am guessing why they asked what I ordered). Pizza was brought to me immediately and I was on my way.The pizza business in this area is very competitive so you really need to set yourself apart. The crust was average, didn't have the salty crunch of a tavern style pizza and really didn't taste like it was freshly made. The sauce was mild, without much distinction. The cheese blend was odd and produced a lot of grease which soaked into the crust. It had a decent flavor but I usually prefer more mozzarella over other cheeses. What disappointed me the most was the sausage. The sausage pieces were small and didn't produce much flavor compared to what else you can find in the area.Overall this first experience was average but I think there is some potential here. Their prices are very reasonable. I am going to give this place another try in a few weeks when they have some more pies under their belt and update my review.
Food: 4
Service: 5
Dave Pawelek
Finally a local place that appreciates the art of making a loaded Bloody Mary! We spend a lot of our summer weekends in Wi. where the Bloody’s are known for along with old fashions too. Tried both of them and Legends has nailed the old fashion and bloody too. Very friendly servers and there’s something to be said when the owner Michelle is part of the serving team too. Mark the husband / owner took a few minutes to check-in and asked for feedback. When was the last time an owner came to your table to ask what they can do better? Well done on the customer experience! Not only was the food, service, and incredibly fair price something that is rare these days the pride this husband and wife team bring to the table can be felt the moment you walk in and are greeted. Looking forward to coming back again and again! Dave and Nancy!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeff V.
great owners,,great food,,tried quite a few things on the menu,and its all very good,service is great and friendly.A+ rating all around from my wife and i.
Great pizza I have lived in Carol Stream over 5 years and never had such great pizza in all the 5 years bought it 2 times within a weeks period . I'm grateful for this pizza place . Great customer service. Excellent all around. Definitely will be dining in as well . My name is Dawn
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Kevin Conroy
Finally, good pizza in Carol
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lauren Green
Our family of four ordered a large pizza tonight and absolutely loved it! We loved the flavor and the quality. We will definitely order again! Very very yummy!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amanda Brown
First time trying had an issue with my bank card Staff was very friendly Cheese and sauce cover entire pizza Highly recommend will be
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
pablo velazquez
The customer service is amazing! And the food was delicious! I will definitely be
Had myself a slice of cheese pizza, a breaded steak sandwich and a cannoli and it was all very delicious! This area needed a place with slices hot and ready to go that isn't a gas station and I couldn't be happier with the quality of this place! Will be my go to heading to work for a slice! A week later I got a 16" pizza half cheese half sausage and it was cooked to perfection. A lot of other places I have to ask for well done but Legends knows how to do it without even asking! The mozzarella sticks and breaded mushrooms were also excellent. Highly recommend and will be coming back frequently!
I have eaten there twice and was very pleased with the quality of food and the size of the portions. The first time I had the pizza OMG great taste and and great ingredients. Today I had legends pasta alla vodka it was amazing again great taste and ingredients and huge portions. If there was ten stars I would have given them ten stars. They are a welcome pizza/restaurant in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I stopped by Legands yesterday for a slice. I had heard great things about this place on social media. Pleasantly....all were true ?. Great food, friendly staff and a great owner.I ordered a medium cheese, since the slices end at 4:00pm & I was there about 4:30pm. I also ordered a chicken parm sandwich to go and a side of meatballs to enjoy while waiting for the pizza.The owner & his daughter Natalie were sitting at the counter & said hello. We struck up a conversation and I enjoyed hearing their story about how/why they started a pizza place.I really enjoyed the meatballs & red sauce...so much so that I ate my chicken parm sandwich at the counter as well. While chatting with Natalie.The pizza was thin, crispy & perfectly baked well done, as I ordered.Food was great, friendly staff & will definitely be back. Natalie mentioned her Mom makes the lasagna ??. Can't wait to try it!!They are still in the process of completing the interior. When completed they will have slots, a bar & later hours. Really appreciate the later hours - as a night owl.....it will be great to get a quality, fresh made pizza after 10pm ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is FANTASTIC!The owners are gems, employees are sweethearts, atmosphere and vibe are on point - Oh, and the food is PHENOMENAL!We have been in the area now for almost 3 years and since the pandemic ended, we try to, for the most part, hit a different pizza spot every time we order out for it.My wife kept hearing about this place and we finally picked up some Za and Ribs on Sunday and my whole family is in love!This is going to be our go to spot 75 percent of the time, the other 25 percent will go to being adventurous, or if we are out of town lol…. Not kidding tho!Looking forward to buying some of their merchandise too.We will be seeing them again very soon for our next date night.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped in last weekend. Food and service was excellent. Family owned. Staff was very friendly! Did not realize they just opened about a month ago. My husband and I had fried pickles, the Italian sausage burger, and a small pizza with Italian beef and green peppers. Everything was excellent. The Italian sausage burger was something so different and so tasty. Italian beef was best I've ever had on a pizza. Pizza sauce and crust was perfect. We will definitely be back. I'm craving it already!
I knew right away when they made their dressings for the salad I was very happy with the ranch dressing. Salad is simple and delicious. The setting is simple and very clean. The staff is friendly and treated me like they knew me.Pizza just arrive and it smells wonderful and guess what they cut in squares. I love square cuts. Wonderful flavor. Crust is perfect slight crunch and I don’t have to fight with it Recommend you check it out
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Finally, a place in Carol Stream where you can sit down with your family and enjoy very fresh and homemade recipes.We were pleasantly surprised by the customer service and the amazing food. We ordered several items on the menu and the pizza was delicious. You can tell they use very high-quality ingredients and a lot of love. We will be back very soon.
Update April 2024: Ordered again via online with delivery. Pizza was promised for delivery in 60-65 minutes and was at my door exactly when promised. Ordered a sausage pizza again to compare to last time and also got a tiramisu. The pizza arrived warm (not hot) with golden color cheese and a cracker thin crust. Crust was improved, light and buttery. This time the sausage pieces were larger (with great flavor) and cheese was good (I do like that the cheese is not greasy at all). Tiramisu was very tasty. Overall, I am going to update to 4/5 stars.-------------This is a new pizza place that just opened early March 2024. Placed order via phone. Was a little surprised they didn't ask for a name. Ordered a large cheese and sausage. Pizza was promised to be ready in 25-30 min, and when I arrived just before the 30 min mark I was greeted and they asked what my order was (since they didn't take my name I am guessing why they asked what I ordered). Pizza was brought to me immediately and I was on my way.The pizza business in this area is very competitive so you really need to set yourself apart. The crust was average, didn't have the salty crunch of a tavern style pizza and really didn't taste like it was freshly made. The sauce was mild, without much distinction. The cheese blend was odd and produced a lot of grease which soaked into the crust. It had a decent flavor but I usually prefer more mozzarella over other cheeses. What disappointed me the most was the sausage. The sausage pieces were small and didn't produce much flavor compared to what else you can find in the area.Overall this first experience was average but I think there is some potential here. Their prices are very reasonable. I am going to give this place another try in a few weeks when they have some more pies under their belt and update my review.
Food: 4
Service: 5
Finally a local place that appreciates the art of making a loaded Bloody Mary! We spend a lot of our summer weekends in Wi. where the Bloody’s are known for along with old fashions too. Tried both of them and Legends has nailed the old fashion and bloody too. Very friendly servers and there’s something to be said when the owner Michelle is part of the serving team too. Mark the husband / owner took a few minutes to check-in and asked for feedback. When was the last time an owner came to your table to ask what they can do better? Well done on the customer experience! Not only was the food, service, and incredibly fair price something that is rare these days the pride this husband and wife team bring to the table can be felt the moment you walk in and are greeted. Looking forward to coming back again and again! Dave and Nancy!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
great owners,,great food,,tried quite a few things on the menu,and its all very good,service is great and friendly.A+ rating all around from my wife and i.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great pizza I have lived in Carol Stream over 5 years and never had such great pizza in all the 5 years bought it 2 times within a weeks period . I'm grateful for this pizza place . Great customer service. Excellent all around. Definitely will be dining in as well . My name is Dawn
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Finally, good pizza in Carol
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our family of four ordered a large pizza tonight and absolutely loved it! We loved the flavor and the quality. We will definitely order again! Very very yummy!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time trying had an issue with my bank card Staff was very friendly Cheese and sauce cover entire pizza Highly recommend will be
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The customer service is amazing! And the food was delicious! I will definitely be
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Tiramisu