Nicky's The Real McCoy

2400 S Cicero Ave, Cicero
(708) 222-8500

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Italian Beef Sandwich Combo
Grilled Chicken Combo
Gyros Sandwich Combo
BBQ Chicken Dinner
Steak Sandwich
Gyros Dinner
Gyro Dinner
Big Baby
Hot Dog
Sauce

Menu

Greek/Mex/BBQ CHICKEN RIB-TIPS GYRO Dinners and Sandwiches

Gyros Dinner
Served with extra meat,greek salad,fries and 2 pieces of greek pita bread.
Greek Chicken Dinner ( half-chicken)
Generous, charbroiled half-chicken topped with our signature lemon sauce. Served with greek salad, fries and toasted garlic bread.
BBQ Ribs Tips Dinner Char-broiled
Seasoned rib tips, Char-broiled to perfection and smothered with our BBQ sauce. Served with fries, cole slaw, baked beans and toasted garlic bread.
Pollo Abobado Asado Al carbon
Half chicken ( 4 pieces of chicken) Rice,beans,onions, fries,chillies-jalapeno,6 tortillas and salsa.
BBQ Chicken Dinner (half-chicken)
Generous, charbroiled half-chicken topped with our signature BBQ sauce.served with fries,Cole slaw,baked beans and toasted garlic bread
Gyros Sandwich
Savoury layers of top quality beef and lamb perfectly seasoned with zesty spices.served in a toasted pita with fresh sliced onions, tomatos and cucumber sauce.
Chicken On Pita
chicken breast served on pita with mayo ,lettuce,tomato and raw onions.
Gyros Cucumber Sauce
Our traditional, creamy cucumber sauce with garlic amnd lemon juice that really brings out the flavor of our gyros sandwich.
Extra Feta Cheese
Extra Pita Bread
Authentic greek pita bread with fluffy texture, exceptional taste and crafted quality.

Char Broiled Favorites
Greek Chicken Dinner ( half-chicken)
Generous, charbroiled half-chicken topped with our garlicky, luscious lemon sauce. Served with fries, greek salad, rice, and toasted garlic bread.
BBQ Ribs Tips Dinner Char-broiled
Seasoned rib tips, Char-broiled to perfection and smothered with our BBQ sauce. Served with fries, cole slaw, baked beans and toasted garlic bread.
BBQ Ribs Tips Dinner( Char-broiled )
Seasoned rib tips, Char-broiled to perfection and smothered with our BBQ sauce. Served with fries, cole slaw, baked beans and toasted garlic bread.
BBQ Chicken Dinner (half-chicken)
Generous, charbroiled half-chicken topped with our signature BBQ sauce.served with fries,Cole slaw,baked beans and toasted garlic bread
Pollo Abobado Asado Al carbon
Half chicken ( 4 pieces of chicken) Rice,beans,onions, fries,chillies-jalapeno,6 tortillas and salsa.
BBQ Chicken Dinner (half-chicken)
Generous, charbroiled half-chicken topped with our signature BBQ sauce.served with fries,Cole slaw,baked beans and toasted garlic bread
Pollo Abobado Asado Al carbon
Half chicken ( 4 pieces of chicken) Rice,beans,onions, fries,chillies-jalapeno,6 tortillas and salsa.
Chicken Sandwich
Flame-broiled, chicken breast served on a sesame seed bun with leuttce, raw onions tomatos and mayonnaise.
Chicken On Pita
chicken breast served on pita with mayo ,lettuce,tomato and raw onions.
Chicken On Pita
chicken breast served on pita with mayo ,lettuce,tomato and raw onions.
Whole Chicken
Only chicken (8 pieces ) 2 breasts, 2 thighs, 2legs, 2 wings.-
BBQ Rib Sandwich
Served with grilled onions,pickels and bbq sauce on garlic bread
BBQ Chicken Sandwich
Flame-broiled, chicken breast tossed in our signature BBQ sauce and served on a sesame seed bun with lettuce raw onion and mayo

Italian Sandwiches
Italian Beef Sandwich Served always dipped/juicy on a French bread (cheese and peppers EXTRA ) (dry upon request)
Served always dipped/juicy on a French bread (cheese and peppers EXTRA ) (dry upon request)
Two Pizza Puffs
One Pizza Puff
Italian Beef and Sausage Combination Sandwich Served always dipped/juicy on a French bread (cheese and peppers EXTRA ) (dry upon request)
Served always dipped/juicy on a French bread (cheese and peppers EXTRA ) (dry upon request)
Italian Sausage (Mild) Sandwich Served always dipped/juicy on a French bread (cheese and peppers EXTRA ) (dry upon request)
Served always dipped/juicy on a French bread (cheese and peppers EXTRA ) (dry upon request)
Gravy Bread Sandwich Served always dipped/juicy on a French bread (cheese and peppers EXTRA ) (dry upon request)
Served always dipped/juicy on a French bread (cheese and peppers EXTRA ) (dry upon request)

From Our Grilll
Big Baby 1/4lb.Double Cheese Burger
Two fresh, pure beef patties served on a toasted, sesame seed bun with american cheese, ketchup, mustard, pickles and topped with our special grilled onions. No fries included.
Two Big Babies 1/4lb.Double-Cheese Burgers
Enjoy a pair of our signature, double cheeseburgers. No fries included.
Ribeye Steak Sandwich
Flame broiled ribeye steak.Served with lettuce,tomatoes,onions and mayonnaise on toasted garlic bread.No fries included.
Big Nicky 1/3lb. TRIPLE-Cheese burger
Three fresh, pure beef patties served on a toasted, sesame seed bun with american cheese, ketchup, mustard, pickles and topped with our special grilled onions. No fries included.
Corned Beef Sandwich
Fresh shaved corned beef on toasted rye bread. No fries included.

Seafood
Shrimp (Half pound) Basket with Fries
Half pound of breaded fried shrimp served with cocktail sauce
Fish Sandwich (beer batter Cod) with Fries
With tartar sauce. served on a sesame seed bun with leuttce, raw onions tomatos
Shrimp (Half pound) Dinner Half pound of breaded fried shrimp served with cocktail sauce,coleslaw, fries and garlic bread,
Half pound of breaded fried shrimp served with cocktail sauce,coleslaw, fries and garlic bread,

Value Meals SPECIALS (a sandwich, Fries,& drink.)
Big Baby meal
Double cheeseburger.Served with american cheese,mustard ketchup,grilled onions and pickels.Served with fries and 20 oz drink.
Gyro meal
Two hot dog meal
Italian Beef Sandwich Meal Served always dipped/juicy on a French bread (cheese and peppers EXTRA ) (dry upon request)
Served always dipped/juicy on a French bread (cheese and peppers EXTRA ) (dry upon request) and 20 oz drink included.
Ribeye Steak Sandwich meal
Pizza puff meal
Maxwell style Polish meal
Served with mustard,grilled onion and pickels.Fries and 20 oz drink included.
Make My fries-> CHEESE-FRIES (For meal deals and menu items with fries) you must order fries to use this And you must select this for each meal
this ONLY applies to a meal deal order!!! you must order fries to use this And you must select this for each meal
Chicken Fingers meal
Fish Sandwich meal
Grilled Chicken sand. meal
flame broiled chicken breast served on a sesame seed bun with mayo ,lettuce,tomato and raw onions.
Cheese sauce (5oz? cup)
Corned Beef Sandwich meal
Italian Combination Meal Served always dipped/juicy on a French bread (cheese and peppers EXTRA ) (dry upon request)
Served always dipped/juicy on a French bread (cheese and peppers EXTRA ) (dry upon request)
Big Nicky meal
Triple cheeseburger.Served with american cheese,mustard ketchup,grilled onions and pickels.Served with fries and 20 oz drink.
BBQ Rib Sandwich meal
Chicago Style Polish meal
served with mustard ,relish,chopped onions,pickles,tomatos hot peppers and celery salt
Italian Sausage Meal Served always dipped/juicy on a French bread (cheese and peppers EXTRA ) (dry upon request)
Served dipped.Fries and 20 oz drink included.

Salads
Greek Chicken Salad
A Breast of chicken (charbroil) Lettuce,onions,tomatos ,cucumbefs,green-peppers,pepperchiny-peppers feta cheese,greek olives,pita-bread and dressing.
Chicken Caesar Salad
Charbroiled chicken breast. Served over lettuce, tomatoes, onions and croutons tossed in caesar dressing.
Gyros Salad
Zesty gyro meat served over our greek salad with toasted pita bread.
Greek Salad
Lettuce,onions,tomatos ,cucumbefs,green-peppers,pepperchiny-peppers feta cheese,greek olives and dressing.
Garden Salad
Lettuce ,tomatoes onions and dressing.

Hot Dogs AND Polish sausages
Three (3) Hot Dogs with Fries SPECIAL
Three, chicago-style hot dogs served with all the classic trimmings - yellow mustard, sweet relish, diced raw white onions, dill pickle spear, sliced tomatoes and sport peppers - along with one generous serving of fries.
Hot Dog with Fries
One, chicago-style hot dogs served with all the classic trimmings - yellow mustard, sweet relish, diced raw white onions, dill pickle spear, sliced tomatoes and sport peppers - along with one generous serving of fries.
Maxwell style Polish WITH FRIES Served with mustard,grilled onion HOT PEPERS and pickels
Served with mustard,grilled onion HOT PEPERS and pickels
Cheese sauce (5oz? cup)
Hot Dog (NO FRIES)
One, chicago-style hot dogs served with all the classic trimmings - yellow mustard, sweet relish, diced raw white onions, dill pickle spear, sliced tomatoes and sport peppers.
Maxwell style Polish NO FRIES Served with mustard, grilled onion HOT PEPERS and pickle
Served with mustard, grilled onion HOT PEPERS and pickle
Polish Sausage WITH FRIES. (Chicago style polish)
Chicago style polish susage,served with all the classic trimmings.-yellow mustard, sweet relish, diced raw white onions, dill pickle spear, sliced tomatoes and sport peppers.Along with one generous serving of fries.
Polish Sausage (NO FRIES) Chicago style polish
Chicago style polish susage,served with all the classic trimmings.-yellow mustard, sweet relish, diced raw white onions, dill pickle spear, sliced tomatoes and sport peppers.
Chilli Dog with Fries
Make My fries-> CHEESE-FRIES (For meal deals and menu items with fries) you must order fries to use this And you must select this for each meal
this ONLY applies to a meal deal order!!! you must order fries to use this And you must select this for each meal
Cheese Dog with Fries

Soups
Chili Soup
12 oz bowl.

Sides and Extras
French Fries
one size
Cucumber Sauce
Our traditional, creamy cucumber sauce with garlic and lemon juice that really brings out the flavor of our gyros sandwich.
Cheese Sticks
Cheese sauce (5oz? cup)
Cheese Fries
Garlic Bread
Cole Slaw
BBQ Sauce
Onion Rings
Peppers
Choose from a side of hot, sweet or giardiniera peppers
Chili Fries
Pita Bread
Authentic greek pita bread with fluffy texture, exceptional taste and hand-crafted quality.
Mushrooms
Cocktail Sauce
Dill Pickels

Beverages
RC Cola
Fruit Punch Soda
Raspberry Iced Tea
Lemonade
Lemon Lime Soda
Diet RC Cola

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: facebook
+25 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+24 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

ordered a hot dog with everything thinking they would give me a Chicago dog instead I got relish onion pickle and mustard. needless to say it was awful. the beef was a little better but the bread stale.
February 2025
Was visiting from out of town when I found this awesome spot. Was in and out in under 10 minutes, the staff was very helpfull. Ordered a Gyro with fries (added feta and lettuce for a small extra charge). Best part is they have RC cola on tap! Been decades since I have seen that....they also had other menu items that looked enticing, will definitely be back next time I am in Chicago!
September 2024
The place has been around a very long time but great food and still has the same employee working there as well which makes the place great. ?

Parking: There's about 6 parking spaces
September 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

First Chop Suey - 2325 S Cicero Ave
Chinese, Juice Bar & Smoothies
Taco Bell - 2225 S Cicero Ave
Fast Food, Mexican
El Aconaz - 2311 S 49th Ave
Mexican

Nicky's The Real McCoy

2400 S Cicero Ave, Cicero, IL 60804
(708) 222-8500