I was kinda shocked by some of these reviews. I really liked the pizza and appreciate the specials. It is perfectly thin, not drowning in cheese (in a good way), and slightly sweet. Maybe it isn't everyone's perfect style, but I have a hard time finding pizza that has a nice balance like this. I would recommend it. I'm not sure when the new owners came, but I enjoyed the pizza more this time than the last time I was there.
Food: 5
Jack Hurliman
Good pizza I’m a huge ranch person and I paid the extra $2 for ranch which is already insane and I got the cheesy bread, food came and the bread was dry BUT, there was no ranch. Pissed me off on my friday night
Jen Kairuz
We’re obsessed with Pisa Pizza! Always delicious with flavorful sauce, perfect cheese to sauce ratio and crispy crust. Love this place for easy family dinners or parties. Takeout’s super easy, the crew is great, and the leftovers hit just as hard the next day. Total local gem! 🍕🔥
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Malone
Straight up awesome pizza.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Thin Crust Pizza
l b
Pisa Pizza was a childhood staple of mine- a local, affordable spot with always delicious pizza. The previous owners sold the business, and the food definitely reflects that, it’s a thin “tavern” style crust now and definitely not as good. It’s okay but nothing special. The old pisa pizza had such a unique flavor and texture, very disappointed to see that it’s gone now. Not sure why you’d buy a neighborhood favorite pizzeria just to totally change the recipe instead of starting your own place.
Food: 3
John Beshilas
The young girl that answered the phone didn't talk until I said hello, then she didn't seem at all interested in taking my order. We ordered TWO pizzas and when we got there to pickup only one was cooked, some crap excuse about the order tape running out. The samw girl that took our order was at the front counter on her cell phone and had the personality of a rock!! No apologies, no discount, NO NOTHING, and the pizzas were just meh!! NEVER AGAIN!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Anthony Sadolfo
This place is takeout or delivery only, and let me tell you, it’s absolutely worth it!
As someone who loves trying pizza everywhere I go (and is admittedly a bit of a pizza critic lol), I was blown away. The crust is perfectly thin and flat with a satisfyingly crunchy bottom; no sogginess here. You can taste the quality of the ingredients in every bite. Fresh, flavorful, and delicious.
The prices are fair, the place was spotless when I stopped in, and the staff was super friendly and knowledgeable, even when I threw a bunch of random questions at them (thanks for being patient with me, guys!)
If you’re even thinking about trying this place, do it. It’s seriously worth it :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brooke Ashley
My family and I love their pizza! So good for large groups and always nice and fresh. Must try if you live near!
Brooke Raush
Best pizza in Lagrange!! Their recipe is too die for. Great for families! Can’t recommend their service and food enough.
Amazing thin crust! Came in on a Friday night for pickup. Super friendly staff and my order was ready right on time. Definitely going back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Omar Eloiza
Rare to find a place that uses FRESH mushrooms as opposed to canned. Truly a no-frills pizza shop. Friendly customer service and delicious pizza. Can’t ask for more.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kurt Johns
The pizza is awesome, the price is right, and the service is exceptional. They do a great job if you are serving a large group
Food: 5
Service: 5
ashley lavin
We moved from the city 5.5 years ago, love pizza and had access to a variety of great options while we lived downtown. We had found most suburban pizza to be mediocre and all the same. Pisa is such a welcome change. Traditional tavern style but with really delicious sauce, great crust and flavorful pepperoni. Friendly staff and owners. It’s our go-to.
Atmosphere rating just reflects that it’s a carryout spot. No problem with that!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Leslie Hartoonian
Arrived Cold, not the same and overpriced. The pizza is not the same, way too thin and skimpy on ingredients. Not sure what happened but won’t be ordering here ever again. Sorry but not good or worth the money.
I was kinda shocked by some of these reviews. I really liked the pizza and appreciate the specials. It is perfectly thin, not drowning in cheese (in a good way), and slightly sweet. Maybe it isn't everyone's perfect style, but I have a hard time finding pizza that has a nice balance like this. I would recommend it. I'm not sure when the new owners came, but I enjoyed the pizza more this time than the last time I was there.
Food: 5
Good pizza I’m a huge ranch person and I paid the extra $2 for ranch which is already insane and I got the cheesy bread, food came and the bread was dry BUT, there was no ranch. Pissed me off on my friday night
We’re obsessed with Pisa Pizza! Always delicious with flavorful sauce, perfect cheese to sauce ratio and crispy crust. Love this place for easy family dinners or parties. Takeout’s super easy, the crew is great, and the leftovers hit just as hard the next day. Total local gem! 🍕🔥
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Straight up awesome pizza.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Thin Crust Pizza
Pisa Pizza was a childhood staple of mine- a local, affordable spot with always delicious pizza.
The previous owners sold the business, and the food definitely reflects that, it’s a thin “tavern” style crust now and definitely not as good. It’s okay but nothing special. The old pisa pizza had such a unique flavor and texture, very disappointed to see that it’s gone now. Not sure why you’d buy a neighborhood favorite pizzeria just to totally change the recipe instead of starting your own place.
Food: 3
The young girl that answered the phone didn't talk until I said hello, then she didn't seem at all interested in taking my order. We ordered TWO pizzas and when we got there to pickup only one was cooked, some crap excuse about the order tape running out. The samw girl that took our order was at the front counter on her cell phone and had the personality of a rock!! No apologies, no discount, NO NOTHING, and the pizzas were just meh!! NEVER AGAIN!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
This place is takeout or delivery only, and let me tell you, it’s absolutely worth it!
As someone who loves trying pizza everywhere I go (and is admittedly a bit of a pizza critic lol), I was blown away. The crust is perfectly thin and flat with a satisfyingly crunchy bottom; no sogginess here. You can taste the quality of the ingredients in every bite. Fresh, flavorful, and delicious.
The prices are fair, the place was spotless when I stopped in, and the staff was super friendly and knowledgeable, even when I threw a bunch of random questions at them (thanks for being patient with me, guys!)
If you’re even thinking about trying this place, do it. It’s seriously worth it :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My family and I love their pizza! So good for large groups and always nice and fresh. Must try if you live near!
Best pizza in Lagrange!! Their recipe is too die for. Great for families! Can’t recommend their service and food enough.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
needs better signage for the FRONT of building!
Restaurantji Recommends
Amazing thin crust! Came in on a Friday night for pickup. Super friendly staff and my order was ready right on time. Definitely going back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rare to find a place that uses FRESH mushrooms as opposed to canned. Truly a no-frills pizza shop. Friendly customer service and delicious pizza. Can’t ask for more.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza is awesome, the price is right, and the service is exceptional. They do a great job if you are serving a large group
Food: 5
Service: 5
We moved from the city 5.5 years ago, love pizza and had access to a variety of great options while we lived downtown. We had found most suburban pizza to be mediocre and all the same. Pisa is such a welcome change. Traditional tavern style but with really delicious sauce, great crust and flavorful pepperoni. Friendly staff and owners. It’s our go-to.
Atmosphere rating just reflects that it’s a carryout spot. No problem with that!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Arrived Cold, not the same and overpriced.
The pizza is not the same, way too thin and skimpy on ingredients. Not sure what happened but won’t be ordering here ever again. Sorry but not good or worth the money.
Food: 1
Service: 2
Loading...