Casey's

639 E Terra Cotta Ave, Crystal Lake
(815) 459-1518

Customers' Favorites

Photos

+35 photos
+34 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I visited Casey’s both on Tuesday, March 18 and Friday, March 21, 2025. Similar to a lot of places in Crystal Lake, this was one of the places I first experienced downstate and was glad to see get brought back to my city. This location is not new by any means and I’ve been here many times I just have not left a review yet and I like to try and leave a review to most places I go. On Tuesday I got pizza slices and it was HUGE and tasted really good. On Friday we got gas and...
I love this location. The cleanest Casey's I've been in by far. The staff are wonderdul. Nancy and Cindy are just so sweet and you are greeted like an old friend. The food is pretty good for gas station food, and Sky in the kitchen is so sweet and fast. When I ask for extra pickles she actually gives you EXTRA pickles, unlike mcDonalds. Im not sure what his name is, but the young store manager is a hard worker and he's pretty nice. The donuts look gorgeous and yummy...
I stopped by there the first time ,don't live in Illinois, stopped to get some to drink ,and saw had a little sandwich place and got a sub. The gal name I think was andy,and there was another gal also they both were sweet and professional, and she made a awesome sin, plus the manager Robert that i met was also awesome and the gal who checked us out was also awesome and basically everyone there was above and beyond .

More Reviews