Jersey Mike's Subs

1000 W Fayette Ave, Effingham
(217) 790-4116

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Cheesesteak on a Boat Mike's Way

Bacon Ranch Chicken Cheese Steak

Turkey and Provalone Mike's Way

Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak

Roast Beef and Provolone

Chipotle Cheese Steak

The Original Italian

Turkey and Provolone

Chicken Bacon Ranch

Ham and Provolone

Photos

+21 photos

+20 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Jerseymikes

Doordash

Grubhub

Trycaviar

Recent Reviews

I am a regular traveler to Effingham and have made a habit of always stopping here for lunch (and maybe dinner too). The team and food is fantastic - Rachel runs a great crew that is always upbeat and serves consistently good food.

July 2025

Great location! Very clean. Happy environment to be and eat in. Rachel and Jess approached me as soon as I walked in with a positive and upbeat attitude which I personally like. The food was perfect. VERY HOT (YUM). And fresh! I ordered a Number 26 as I always do. I had fresh onion and Pickles to an as it comes sandwich (which is good as it is too) note: they ask what you want or don’t want ….and that tops it off for me for taste! I also add extra meat! It then becomes...

July 2025

I have Celiac disease and other food allergies. They always go above and beyond to make my sub in a tub so as not to cross contaminate with wheat or dairy. One of the only local places that I trust.

June 2025

More Reviews