Placed an order on Tues by phone for pick up. Paid by phone for my husband to pick up. My husband saw a massive sign that said buy one get one pizza Tuesday. My husband questioned the woman and she said point blank "oh I offered but the woman on the phone said she only wanted one pizza." Who says no to free anything? The person on the phone never offered or mentioned the offer. When my husband called me to check on this I noted i had no idea. When confronted with her lie, the woman got nervous and started making excuses. It was so awkward for my husband and maddening for me that he was in the middle of this. A 14in pizza for 30 without delivery is already alot but add insult by lieing about a customer about a offer they advertise is ridiculous. Never again. Lost another customer.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Jeff Duyckinck
Decent spot for a quick slice at a fair price.
Food: 4
Service: 5
Joann Cogley
The pizza was dry and had very little cheese or sauce I do not recommend this restaurant
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
john modrak
Probably a top 3 pizza in Oak Park, personally my favorite but has some unique elements I love that may not be for everyone ( semolina or cornmeal under crust, cross between NY and Chicago style thin)
One very annoying thing though, their website is terrible
A couple times the online site has combined old orders into new ones, and prices are wrong or misquoted, I had to pay more than owed and the answer on all occasions was a shrug. I’d prefer they don’t even offer online ordering vs current experience.
They also don’t honor the 2 for Tuesday deal they offer, if you order online
I paid for a pizza assuming once I arrived the cheaper pizza for 2 for 2 could be refunded and they wouldn’t/ couldn’t do that.
I actually don’t mind if your website stinks as a small biz, don’t even mind if you can’t fix it. I suppose as someone in hospitality biz what I don’t love is the unwillingness to make any attempt other than “sorry we don’t do it online” to rectify the situation
While I was waiting for my pizza I saw other people pickup up bigger orders for half what I paid online
Worst part is they could have if I picked up for cash, but the online system didn’t allow cash pickups over $50 and forced me to put in a card they couldn’t refund
Such is life, but probably some avoidable errors here.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
Anita Guy
I went there today for the first time. And I ordered a slice of pizza and it looked like they gave me some leftovers pizza that was sitting somewhere for awhile. It was all dried out. I'm glad I bought one slice. I will never go there again for anything.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Imani O'Daniels (Spiritual Fro)
Best pizza slice I've ever had, affordable too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice
David Samuels
Hey Guys come on! You need to update your online menu!! The pricing is way off! You guys charged me $27.50 for a large pizza with one topping, your online menu is completely different! Plus you need to post a sign that you are charging a service fee! Is this for your employees health care? If not I have a real problem with this!!
Joe Petrecca
The best pizza in the neighborhood by far
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza
Puppers Policetti
I tried the pan pepperoni pizza at the Armands location over on Western Ave a few weeks back, and it was absolutely fantastic. Just found out there was one in EP, too, so I ordered from them recently. I ordered a large specialty pizza called the Elmwood Park Special, which came with sausage, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers. Showed up at my door about an hour later and dug right into it. It was ok. Nothing to write home about. It's difficult to gauge how good it might have been as I received a lukewarm pie by the time it arrived. I'm gonna try their pan pepperoni next time just to have a solid metric with which to compare quality with their Western Ave location. If I am able, I'll probably end up just driving over to pick it up or dine-in next time just to avoid the delivery fee because it came out to like 45 bucks for a single 14" pizza.
Edit: My usual pizza spot was closed for a holiday recently, so I ended up ordering delivery from this location again. After placing my order, I got my pizza after an hour and a half. Pizza was no longer warm when it arrived and was overly salty for whatever reason. The upside, at least, was that the toppings were ample. It's definitely still a huge disappointment given the prices, especially in today's economy. Waiting more than an hour and a half just to receive cold, salty, mediocre food is a huge bummer and a waste of money. I think I will just be ordering specifically from their Western Ave location from now on whenever I'm in North Center. Their quality is way better and actually consistent, as is their delivery time because their food is still piping hot when it arrives.
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Elmwood Park Special Pizza
Colin Fitt
Minimum 30% increase in menu price makes them significantly less desirable.
I tried the pan pepperoni pizza at the Armands location over on Western Ave a few weeks back, and it was absolutely fantastic. Just found out there was one in the neighborhood, too, so I ordered from them recently. I ordered a large specialty pizza called the Elmwood Park Special, which came with sausage, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers. Showed up at my door about an hour later and dug right into it. It was good! Nice crispy crust and with plenty of toppings spread over generously. I'm gonna try their pan pepperoni next time just to have a solid metric with which to compare quality with their Western Ave location. I'll also probably end up just driving over to pick it up or dine-in next time just to avoid the delivery fee because it came out to like 45 bucks and also to experience the pizza at max freshness.
Food: 4
Service: 3
Shannon Jackson
Delicious
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice
John Donnelly
Great thin crust pizza and antipasto salad.
Food: 5
I Love Chicken Adobo
I tried the pan pepperoni pizza at the Armands location over on Western Ave a few weeks back, and it was absolutely fantastic. Just found out there was one in the neighborhood, too, so I ordered from them recently. I ordered a large specialty pizza called the Elmwood Park Special, which came with sausage, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers. Showed up at my door about an hour later and dug right into it. It was good! Nice crispy crust and with plenty of toppings spread over generously. I'm gonna try their pan pepperoni next time just to have a solid metric with which to compare quality with their Western Ave location. I'll also probably end up just driving over to pick it up or dine-in next time just to avoid the delivery fee because it came out to like 45 bucks and also to experience the pizza at max freshness.
Food: 4
Service: 3
Bella Italiana
Great great service young lady in the front was very kind and the lady who took my order was on point asked for easy cooked pizza came out great! ??My new to go spot . Great great Great. Thank you!
Placed an order on Tues by phone for pick up. Paid by phone for my husband to pick up. My husband saw a massive sign that said buy one get one pizza Tuesday. My husband questioned the woman and she said point blank "oh I offered but the woman on the phone said she only wanted one pizza." Who says no to free anything? The person on the phone never offered or mentioned the offer. When my husband called me to check on this I noted i had no idea. When confronted with her lie, the woman got nervous and started making excuses. It was so awkward for my husband and maddening for me that he was in the middle of this. A 14in pizza for 30 without delivery is already alot but add insult by lieing about a customer about a offer they advertise is ridiculous. Never again. Lost another customer.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Decent spot for a quick slice at a fair price.
Food: 4
Service: 5
The pizza was dry and had very little cheese or sauce I do not recommend this restaurant
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Probably a top 3 pizza in Oak Park, personally my favorite but has some unique elements I love that may not be for everyone ( semolina or cornmeal under crust, cross between NY and Chicago style thin)
One very annoying thing though, their website is terrible
A couple times the online site has combined old orders into new ones, and prices are wrong or misquoted, I had to pay more than owed and the answer on all occasions was a shrug. I’d prefer they don’t even offer online ordering vs current experience.
They also don’t honor the 2 for Tuesday deal they offer, if you order online
I paid for a pizza assuming once I arrived the cheaper pizza for 2 for 2 could be refunded and they wouldn’t/ couldn’t do that.
I actually don’t mind if your website stinks as a small biz, don’t even mind if you can’t fix it. I suppose as someone in hospitality biz what I don’t love is the unwillingness to make any attempt other than “sorry we don’t do it online” to rectify the situation
While I was waiting for my pizza I saw other people pickup up bigger orders for half what I paid online
Worst part is they could have if I picked up for cash, but the online system didn’t allow cash pickups over $50 and forced me to put in a card they couldn’t refund
Such is life, but probably some avoidable errors here.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
I went there today for the first time. And I ordered a slice of pizza and it looked like they gave me some leftovers pizza that was sitting somewhere for awhile. It was all dried out. I'm glad I bought one slice. I will never go there again for anything.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Best pizza slice I've ever had, affordable too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice
Hey Guys come on! You need to update your online menu!! The pricing is way off! You guys charged me $27.50 for a large pizza with one topping, your online menu is completely different! Plus you need to post a sign that you are charging a service fee! Is this for your employees health care? If not I have a real problem with this!!
The best pizza in the neighborhood by far
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza
I tried the pan pepperoni pizza at the Armands location over on Western Ave a few weeks back, and it was absolutely fantastic. Just found out there was one in EP, too, so I ordered from them recently. I ordered a large specialty pizza called the Elmwood Park Special, which came with sausage, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers. Showed up at my door about an hour later and dug right into it. It was ok. Nothing to write home about. It's difficult to gauge how good it might have been as I received a lukewarm pie by the time it arrived. I'm gonna try their pan pepperoni next time just to have a solid metric with which to compare quality with their Western Ave location. If I am able, I'll probably end up just driving over to pick it up or dine-in next time just to avoid the delivery fee because it came out to like 45 bucks for a single 14" pizza.
Edit: My usual pizza spot was closed for a holiday recently, so I ended up ordering delivery from this location again. After placing my order, I got my pizza after an hour and a half. Pizza was no longer warm when it arrived and was overly salty for whatever reason. The upside, at least, was that the toppings were ample. It's definitely still a huge disappointment given the prices, especially in today's economy. Waiting more than an hour and a half just to receive cold, salty, mediocre food is a huge bummer and a waste of money. I think I will just be ordering specifically from their Western Ave location from now on whenever I'm in North Center. Their quality is way better and actually consistent, as is their delivery time because their food is still piping hot when it arrives.
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Elmwood Park Special Pizza
Minimum 30% increase in menu price makes them significantly less desirable.
Restaurantji Recommends
I tried the pan pepperoni pizza at the Armands location over on Western Ave a few weeks back, and it was absolutely fantastic. Just found out there was one in the neighborhood, too, so I ordered from them recently. I ordered a large specialty pizza called the Elmwood Park Special, which came with sausage, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers. Showed up at my door about an hour later and dug right into it. It was good! Nice crispy crust and with plenty of toppings spread over generously. I'm gonna try their pan pepperoni next time just to have a solid metric with which to compare quality with their Western Ave location. I'll also probably end up just driving over to pick it up or dine-in next time just to avoid the delivery fee because it came out to like 45 bucks and also to experience the pizza at max freshness.
Food: 4
Service: 3
Delicious
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice
Great thin crust pizza and antipasto salad.
Food: 5
I tried the pan pepperoni pizza at the Armands location over on Western Ave a few weeks back, and it was absolutely fantastic. Just found out there was one in the neighborhood, too, so I ordered from them recently. I ordered a large specialty pizza called the Elmwood Park Special, which came with sausage, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers. Showed up at my door about an hour later and dug right into it. It was good! Nice crispy crust and with plenty of toppings spread over generously. I'm gonna try their pan pepperoni next time just to have a solid metric with which to compare quality with their Western Ave location. I'll also probably end up just driving over to pick it up or dine-in next time just to avoid the delivery fee because it came out to like 45 bucks and also to experience the pizza at max freshness.
Food: 4
Service: 3
Great great service young lady in the front was very kind and the lady who took my order was on point asked for easy cooked pizza came out great! ??My new to go spot . Great great Great. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...