Today was our first time at Wendy Puff Pizzeria, using a gift card we received from our kids (who love the place!). Wow! I need to eat vegan, so was delighted to try the Vegan Sarnie that was special this month. The mix of tastes was wonderful and I enjoyed every bite. My husband also loved the Green Hornet pizza and the Italian Street appetizer was great, too. We will definitely be back!Vegetarian options: Lots of menu items are naturally vegetarian and some can be made vegan with a substitution of vegan cheese.Dietary restrictions: Gluten free pizza is available as well as vegan cheese. The staff is very helpful and attentive to restrictions.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Adam Bockler
Friendly staff. Quick service.The pizza was the perfect temperature - hot enough that it felt like it just came out of the oven (which it did), but not so hot it burns your mouth.Make reservations in advance, or at least call. When we arrived, there were empty tables so we sat at one until we were moved to the bar due to reservations they had for later. It wasn’t clear to us when we walked in whether it was open seating because there is no host/hostess or reception area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage Pizza
Jeremy Hyland
Really fun place. Super unique menu, great atmosphere but packed
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anastasia Link
We received a gift card for Wendy Puff over the holidays & were so excited to try this local pizza place!The pizza is a thin crust that has a great puffed crust around the edge to hold on to. The menu is all pizzas (puffs) with a few salads & handful of appetizers, as well a full drink menu.Each pizza feels elevated with the flavors fully thought out– no boring pizzas here! On the ‘Pedro the Elect’ the chicken meatballs were incredibly flavorful & the white bean chili reduction added a lovely depth to the pesto! We also had the ‘The Soppressata’ & ‘The Green Hornet’ pizzas.There were gluten free crust & vegan cheese options available.The staff was super friendly & happy to answer my questions/offer suggestions. One of the owners (2 brothers) checked in on our experience. It was great to meet him & share how delicious meal was!Making a reservation is recommended because the restaurant is smaller & seating is limited, but there were a few seats available at the bar during both our visits.Wendy Puff is worth the short drive from Peoria to Eureka & we will definitely be back!Dietary restrictions: Vegan cheese availableGluten free crust options
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage Pizza, Red Devil Pizza
Robin Friederich
Amazing pizzas, cold beer, personable and knowledgeable servers.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ashley Fischer
Delicious pizza. Friendly, attentive staff. Clean. Busy but able to be seated right away. Cool designs on the walls. Definitely go here!Parking: All free parking. Parking on street, in alley or public parking lot behind restaurantWheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair accessible entrance. All 1 level. 1 of the 2 bathrooms are wheelchair accessible.
Great little pizza place in Eureka, Illinois! Pizza is delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kyle Kamischke
Good Lord this place is great! My wife and I went there on a date, and we both absolutely loved it. We both had the Bourbon Puff Sour to drink, and it was so good we had to each have a second one. We also thoroughly enjoyed both our pizzas. The staff were really attentive and the owner made sure we were enjoying our visit. The atmosphere is also really great and the place was packed because of how amazing it is! You won't regret a visit to here and it's well with the drive!Also, I was enjoying my food and drinks so much that I forgot to take pictures before I got into them. The drinks are served to the brim!Dietary restrictions: There have plenty of options for Gluten and Dairy free.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
David Lin
I just had two incredible pizzas at Wendy Puff in Eureka. They were so, so good—we had the Red Devil and the Winter Menu: Potato Analog (featuring Okinawan purple sweet potato puree, garlic, fennel bulb, sautéed mushroom, parmesan, gruyère, whipped lemon ricotta, need I go on?), but all these pizzas look fabulous; and the olives and burrata were outstanding. You really should come here. I was blown away… and I do not exaggerate. Vegetarian options: Four of the twelve pizzas are vegetarian. Both salads and multiple appetizers are also vegetarian. The entire menu is amazing.Parking: It’s Eureka IL. There’s plenty of parking. :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Red Devil Pizza, Olives
Jason Kobler
Hands down not only the best pizza in the area, but anywhere. This was our first visit and the hype we had heard did not even do it justice. The service was great and the pizza was the best part of the experience. Wehad the Wendy City and Pedro the Elect along with knots for an appetizer. The service was prompt and friendly. We had a fantastic experience. We will be back soon!
Really delicious, unique, and fun pizzas! The garlic knots are also really good! Although it’s a really small space, it does feel crowded and the music type and volume level was perfect (not distracting and pleasant).
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Red Devil Pizza
Katana VanRoekel
My family and I saw this place advertise on the news and wanted to try it ever since. Don’t let the small menu option steer you away because Wendy Puff Pizzeria + Pub did not disappoint. For appetizers we got the Italian Street Food and Cinnamon Sugar Knots. Out of this world! I would definitely get the Cinnamon Sugar Knots again! For the Puffs which is their pizzas, we got the Sausage + and The Wendy City. They look almost the same but the Sausage + has a bit of garlic taste as The Wendy City has a bit of spice to it, but not overly spicy! I definitely have other puffs already in mind to try during our next visit and of course along with the cinnamon sugar knots! ツ For two appetizers, two puffs, and 3 soft drinks our total was $67, just to give you an idea on price.I would suggest making a reservation before dining in with all the advertisements and them being so new in a small space. They do accept walk-ins, but you might have to wait awhile for a reservation to clear. We went on a Thursday night and they were full. But the staff were very friendly and they got us a table for 3 as soon as they could.
Today was our first time at Wendy Puff Pizzeria, using a gift card we received from our kids (who love the place!). Wow! I need to eat vegan, so was delighted to try the Vegan Sarnie that was special this month. The mix of tastes was wonderful and I enjoyed every bite. My husband also loved the Green Hornet pizza and the Italian Street appetizer was great, too. We will definitely be back!Vegetarian options: Lots of menu items are naturally vegetarian and some can be made vegan with a substitution of vegan cheese.Dietary restrictions: Gluten free pizza is available as well as vegan cheese. The staff is very helpful and attentive to restrictions.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Friendly staff. Quick service.The pizza was the perfect temperature - hot enough that it felt like it just came out of the oven (which it did), but not so hot it burns your mouth.Make reservations in advance, or at least call. When we arrived, there were empty tables so we sat at one until we were moved to the bar due to reservations they had for later. It wasn’t clear to us when we walked in whether it was open seating because there is no host/hostess or reception area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage Pizza
Really fun place. Super unique menu, great atmosphere but packed
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We received a gift card for Wendy Puff over the holidays & were so excited to try this local pizza place!The pizza is a thin crust that has a great puffed crust around the edge to hold on to. The menu is all pizzas (puffs) with a few salads & handful of appetizers, as well a full drink menu.Each pizza feels elevated with the flavors fully thought out– no boring pizzas here! On the ‘Pedro the Elect’ the chicken meatballs were incredibly flavorful & the white bean chili reduction added a lovely depth to the pesto! We also had the ‘The Soppressata’ & ‘The Green Hornet’ pizzas.There were gluten free crust & vegan cheese options available.The staff was super friendly & happy to answer my questions/offer suggestions. One of the owners (2 brothers) checked in on our experience. It was great to meet him & share how delicious meal was!Making a reservation is recommended because the restaurant is smaller & seating is limited, but there were a few seats available at the bar during both our visits.Wendy Puff is worth the short drive from Peoria to Eureka & we will definitely be back!Dietary restrictions: Vegan cheese availableGluten free crust options
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage Pizza, Red Devil Pizza
Amazing pizzas, cold beer, personable and knowledgeable servers.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious pizza. Friendly, attentive staff. Clean. Busy but able to be seated right away. Cool designs on the walls. Definitely go here!Parking: All free parking. Parking on street, in alley or public parking lot behind restaurantWheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair accessible entrance. All 1 level. 1 of the 2 bathrooms are wheelchair accessible.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage Pizza, Olives, Mushroom Onion
Great little pizza place in Eureka, Illinois! Pizza is delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good Lord this place is great! My wife and I went there on a date, and we both absolutely loved it. We both had the Bourbon Puff Sour to drink, and it was so good we had to each have a second one. We also thoroughly enjoyed both our pizzas. The staff were really attentive and the owner made sure we were enjoying our visit. The atmosphere is also really great and the place was packed because of how amazing it is! You won't regret a visit to here and it's well with the drive!Also, I was enjoying my food and drinks so much that I forgot to take pictures before I got into them. The drinks are served to the brim!Dietary restrictions: There have plenty of options for Gluten and Dairy free.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I just had two incredible pizzas at Wendy Puff in Eureka. They were so, so good—we had the Red Devil and the Winter Menu: Potato Analog (featuring Okinawan purple sweet potato puree, garlic, fennel bulb, sautéed mushroom, parmesan, gruyère, whipped lemon ricotta, need I go on?), but all these pizzas look fabulous; and the olives and burrata were outstanding. You really should come here. I was blown away… and I do not exaggerate. Vegetarian options: Four of the twelve pizzas are vegetarian. Both salads and multiple appetizers are also vegetarian. The entire menu is amazing.Parking: It’s Eureka IL. There’s plenty of parking. :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Red Devil Pizza, Olives
Hands down not only the best pizza in the area, but anywhere. This was our first visit and the hype we had heard did not even do it justice. The service was great and the pizza was the best part of the experience. Wehad the Wendy City and Pedro the Elect along with knots for an appetizer. The service was prompt and friendly. We had a fantastic experience. We will be back soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Really delicious, unique, and fun pizzas! The garlic knots are also really good! Although it’s a really small space, it does feel crowded and the music type and volume level was perfect (not distracting and pleasant).
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Red Devil Pizza
My family and I saw this place advertise on the news and wanted to try it ever since. Don’t let the small menu option steer you away because Wendy Puff Pizzeria + Pub did not disappoint. For appetizers we got the Italian Street Food and Cinnamon Sugar Knots. Out of this world! I would definitely get the Cinnamon Sugar Knots again! For the Puffs which is their pizzas, we got the Sausage + and The Wendy City. They look almost the same but the Sausage + has a bit of garlic taste as The Wendy City has a bit of spice to it, but not overly spicy! I definitely have other puffs already in mind to try during our next visit and of course along with the cinnamon sugar knots! ツ For two appetizers, two puffs, and 3 soft drinks our total was $67, just to give you an idea on price.I would suggest making a reservation before dining in with all the advertisements and them being so new in a small space. They do accept walk-ins, but you might have to wait awhile for a reservation to clear. We went on a Thursday night and they were full. But the staff were very friendly and they got us a table for 3 as soon as they could.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage Pizza, Red Devil Pizza, Olives, Mushroom Onion, Seasonal Pizza
Pedro the Elect - my new fav pizza! Thanks Wendy Puff! Love the friendly staff too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food and service were great. The music and enclosed space made it hard to have a conversation though.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5