Coney Island

$ • American, Hot Dogs

Hours:
77 S Cherry St, Galesburg
(309) 343-4990

About Coney Island

Coney Island on Cherry Street in Galesburg, IL is a popular spot for hot dog lovers and is a historic restaurant. The cozy restaurant offers a menu focused on different variations of hot dogs, from classic Coney dogs to more adventurous toppings. The hot dogs are juicy, flavorful, and excellent, served on steamed buns. The chili and Coney sauce are amazing and phenomenal. The decor is a fun mix of Coke memorabilia and a collection of antique soda fountain stuff, giving the place a crazy mixed feel. It can be a bit cluttered and not the cleanest looking, but the service is fantastic, friendly, and efficient. The flat top cooking method adds to the delicious flavor of the hot dogs. Prices are reasonable, making it a great spot for a quick and satisfying meal in a casual, family-friendly environment. This 100-year-old restaurant has a welcoming atmosphere and is definitely worth a revisit for a tasty and upbeat meal.

Customers' Favorites

Coney Island Reviews

4.7
194 ratings
Restaurantji Rating
5
75%
4
19%
3
4%
2
1%
1
1%
Food
4.6
Atmosphere
4.8
Service
4.7

Share your opinion about Coney Island

Restaurantji Rating

always look forward to going to Coney Island when in area! never had a bad experience.

First time customer today. The Coney dog and the Chicago dog were awesome! Loved all the craft sodas, vintage decor, and great prices - we’ll be back for sure!!!

OLDEST RESTAURANT IN GALESBURG ILLINOIS!🚆

Read All Reviews(194)

Ratings

Menu

Add a Menu
Coney Island Menu
Coney Island Menu

Photos

Add a Photo
Coney Island
Coney Island
View All Photos

Hours

Monday 11AM - 7PM
Tuesday 11AM - 7PM
Wednesday 11AM - 7PM
Thursday 11AM - 7PM
Friday 11AM - 7PM
Saturday 11AM - 5PM
Sunday 11AM - 3PM
Updated on: