Arrenello's Pizza

Best pizza joint around. It's a bit on the pricer side but it definitely won't disappoint.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Out of All the pizza joints in the area; NW IN and Chicagoland, They are THEE BEST! thin crust, deep dish, or the dinners, it's all so very good! Yes, it's the sweet sauce which is my favorite! So,if you aren't sure about a sweeter sauce start way thin crust. But our go to orders are either a Deep Dish with extra cheese and pepperoni or thin crust with pepperoni and green peppers. No need to order extra cheese on a thin because they cheese it up real good! Glenwood location is better than highland in my opinion but if you're closer to highland IN location, they're good too,but worth the drive to Glenwood. And the liquor store right next door is convenient to pop in on your way to get your pizza if it's a weekend and you need a nice cold adult beverage to go with your pizza!

Great pizza. I really wish that they opened earlier so I could order pizza more often. I'd love to have a pizza while watching the bears game.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I just hate sweet sauce lol

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

I was very apprehensive about ordering from this place because of our experience over 5 years ago; the first time the pizza sauce was loaded with sugar and most went to waste. Personally, I had no interest in EVER ordering from this restaurant again.

Well, it’s Friday, long week, I’m tired and had no desire to cook. So, I asked my husband what would he like and he said just order a pizza from the restaurant by the house. Immediately, I was thinking “NO WAY.” But, I thought apparently my husband didn’t think the pizza was terrible so I decided, why not, I would give it another try.

After placing the order, I kept thinking about the possibility of the pizza being too sweet and a waste of money. I thought about canceling the order but I didn’t because apparently my husband wanted the pizza or maybe he just didn’t want to have to drive anywhere else.

Finally, he’s back and all I could do was be hopeful that the pizza would NOT be a waste. I didn’t even bother to get up to get some, I just sat in front of the tv, so my husband brought me a few pieces of pizza, and WOW,. When I say that the pizza was delicious, it was INCREDIBLY DELICIOUS. The crust was so THIN and CRISPY, the sauce was FLAVORFUL with maybe a pinch of sugar, loaded with plenty of SAVORY sausage and topped with FRESH mozzarella cheese. MOZZARELLA!!!!

Yes!!!! We’re full and very satisfied and we DEFINITELY will be ordering again. Thank you!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fresh Sausage Pizza

food was fresh hot an good

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We LOVE Arrenellos pizza! It's our go to place for 40 years.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I went here for the second time and I order buffalo wings i was charged 15 dollars it came with no fries then I asked do it come with ranch they said no I still paid for the wings when it was time for me to get my food the gave me a white paper bag I asked can I get a carrying bag because I’m walking and have other things I have to carry they told me they do not have carrying bags so no carrying bags no ranch with my meal or fries just didn’t understand that I get home the I have theses very tiny party wings I was like 15$ for this now the first time I came I paid an Uber to bring me way from the roseland area because I really enjoyed they pizza I arrived at 8:15 and tried to order me a medium pizza I was told they are close on the internet it said 9:00 pm here I am paid and 22$ Uber to get to the restaurant and the short Hispanic lady told me she was close I told her how far I came and this is what I wanted to get for my birthday she said sorry we are close keep in mind it 8:15 they close at 9:00pm the price they have is outrageous 30 dollars for a medium pizza with only one topping yes they have ok pizza but the price is not fair on anything they need to get carrying bags and people should not get charged for ranch with they buffalo wings I do not recommend this high price place to anyone they are totally unfair

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 1

A few days ago I went to order pizzas for my employees but I changed my mind when I saw a younger employee with long nails, she was touching the food right after pulling out her wedgy and didn't want to wash her hands, she continued to touch the food without gloves.

Best deep dish pizza ?

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

If you like a sweet pizza sauce this is the place it’s amazing ingredients are always fresh and huge portions it’s just deliciousness

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I picked up a pizza from here and while I was waiting I noticed that other coworkers were laughing at one coworker and treating her badly, the worker being made fun of looked like she was in her 50's. I felt bad for her for the rest of my stay in town and couldn't stop thinking about her, can't believe this is allowed to happen to someone in a work setting and only to one person in the whole establishment.

I picked up a pizza from here and while I was waiting I noticed that other coworkers were laughing at one coworker and treating her badly, the worker being made fun of looked like she was in her 50's. I felt bad for her for the rest of my stay in town and couldn't stop thinking about her, can't believe this is allowed to happen to someone in a work setting and only to one person in the whole establishment.

I loveee their pizza???

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sausage, Fresh Sausage Pizza

This pizza ? is the best! It was a childhood staple in my family. We ordered multiple times a week. I love that I can still stop by and pick it up now that I’ve moved. It has the sweetest sauce! Best stuffed pizza around! The owners are super too!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5