The pizza was really good. The couple who owns the place were super nice. I love supporting family-owned businesses.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shannon Martinez
My family loves fat olives pizza. Consistently good food and great service. Happy to have this little pizza shop in our small town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andrew L (Nightrain)
Crust is a very nice thickness, not overly thin. The veggies taste as fresh as you can get. The cheese is perfect.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers Pizza
Tracy Pabel
This place is amazing. Our server Oliva was awesome. If you are visiting Homer like we are, high recommend this place
SBow3111
I came home from Colorado, and all I wanted was a delicious pizza with HOT/giardiniera. To my surprise, they have both mild & hot! I, of course, had to do an Italian beef pizza, so I could get my beef fix before heading to Portillos the next day.Colorado is a pizza desert... I couldn't choose just 1 pizza. We also ordered plain cheese, veggie, and sausage/pepperoni. They were all amazing!I used to work at the Waterman Pizza Villa location for those that remember, and I can't wait to get Fat Olives when I'm home. This will now be a regular stop.Also, shout out to Chumley's in Shabonna as you are not competitors. They are a great location. I can eat pizza everyday!Make route 30 a pizza destination!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shawn Wolff
first time customer. I ordered the Oliver. Taste's GREAT!
Seek Up Strategies
Pizza is excellent and mushrooms next door are great!
Stacy Gunderson
Ordered for the first time yesterday. Great flavor and plenty of toppings. Next time will ask for extra sauce though... just reheated leftovers in the air fryer and the crust crisped up nice!
Tom Cadorette
Quality pizza, good prices and consistent. I honestly go every week and ive never been dissapointed. I love this place!
We’re camping nearby and another camper recommended. The pizza was delicious and they were very friendly. Seems like a family run shop. They were nice enough to do a curbside pick up for my husband who is immune compromised. We really appreciate this!
Tyler Goodson
Always a great place to order pizza from
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Thomas Christy
I ordered the Double Dough Meat Lovers Pizza, and I totally loved it. It was delicious. I will order it again.
Jenna Cook
What a wonderful pizza shop! The pizza was delicious and cooked perfectly. We also got the garlic bread and dessert breadsticks which were also very good.
The pizza was really good. The couple who owns the place were super nice. I love supporting family-owned businesses.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My family loves fat olives pizza. Consistently good food and great service. Happy to have this little pizza shop in our small town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Crust is a very nice thickness, not overly thin. The veggies taste as fresh as you can get. The cheese is perfect.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers Pizza
This place is amazing. Our server Oliva was awesome. If you are visiting Homer like we are, high recommend this place
I came home from Colorado, and all I wanted was a delicious pizza with HOT/giardiniera. To my surprise, they have both mild & hot! I, of course, had to do an Italian beef pizza, so I could get my beef fix before heading to Portillos the next day.Colorado is a pizza desert... I couldn't choose just 1 pizza. We also ordered plain cheese, veggie, and sausage/pepperoni. They were all amazing!I used to work at the Waterman Pizza Villa location for those that remember, and I can't wait to get Fat Olives when I'm home. This will now be a regular stop.Also, shout out to Chumley's in Shabonna as you are not competitors. They are a great location. I can eat pizza everyday!Make route 30 a pizza destination!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
first time customer. I ordered the Oliver. Taste's GREAT!
Pizza is excellent and mushrooms next door are great!
Ordered for the first time yesterday. Great flavor and plenty of toppings. Next time will ask for extra sauce though... just reheated leftovers in the air fryer and the crust crisped up nice!
Quality pizza, good prices and consistent. I honestly go every week and ive never been dissapointed. I love this place!
The pizza is awesome! Will be going back again!
Restaurantji Recommends
absolutely terrible
We’re camping nearby and another camper recommended. The pizza was delicious and they were very friendly. Seems like a family run shop. They were nice enough to do a curbside pick up for my husband who is immune compromised. We really appreciate this!
Always a great place to order pizza from
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered the Double Dough Meat Lovers Pizza, and I totally loved it. It was delicious. I will order it again.
What a wonderful pizza shop! The pizza was delicious and cooked perfectly. We also got the garlic bread and dessert breadsticks which were also very good.