Love this place. This is the best pizza around, grew up in Huntley was always my go to place. We live in Florida now, but anytime we are here, we have to get this pizza. Always hot and delicious and the perfect pie
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marie Worman
To start with the person taking the order wasn't very friendly. I ordered a stuffed pizza with extra pepperoni. Most of the pizza had no pepperoni at all but lots of cheese. Then parts of the pizza had lots of pepperoni but very little cheese. I also ordered jalapeno poppers and those tasted like the grease they cooked them in was old. I was very disappointed in all of it, especially for the price. This was my first time ordering and it will be my last.
Food: 1
Service: 3
Eddie Mouton
My family has been using Papa Savario's for years. They truly do a fantastic job catering, and they have good bundle packs. I recommend it to make your family get-together dinners that much easier on you.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jim Bellavia
Delicious pizza and friendly customer service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
joe maluch
I thought this place was okay but I was wrong, they fooled me with one pizza that was made nice and neat and tasted good, but since then all the pizza are made very sloppy , there sauce is to sweet on the thin crust , there chicago style is some thick acid sauce that taste terrible and it's why to doughy. They cannot get the orders correct always forgetting things and can't make the pizza correct, I gave them a chance, but who ever runs this place or is making the pizza is not good and they need to sell this and let someone who cares take over! A family vote was taken and it was decided never again papa in huntley !
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Bob Panek
Ordered a late takeout dinner. Ordered a sausage and mushroom canzone. While waiting for it we sat at their bar and had a beer and seltzer. They havr quite a collection of hard liquor that includes Blanton's, Talamore Dew, and other favorites. Whrn we arrived hone, the calzone was hot and tasty.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
brent w
Sauce was good.messed up ordered thin crust.should of ordered regular crust.but garlic was on point.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Mike Freeman
sometimes very chewy
Joe Szuberla
The worst Pizza I've ever had! I paid $29.00 for a small thin Pizza Crust that comes with nothing on it. Nothing like the crystal lake location. It must be different owners. Honestly I've had frozen Pizza better than this. Don't waste your money and time here. Extremely disappointed . Shame on you. 👎
Food: 1
Service: 1
Joel Neely
It’s 9:15. They close at 10:00. No one answered the phone and they shut off online ordering. Guess they don’t want my business. Lost me as a customer.
It's 20 dollar pizza masquerading as 35 dollar pizza. Nothing special, especially at that price. Closer and cheaper and better options exist.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Nonya Business
Ordered a pound of boneless wings tossed in buffalo sauce. About half of the wings were overcooked and more than half weren't even coated with the buffalo sauce. Thankfully I could scrape up some sauce from the bottom of the to go carton and drown them in the blue cheese dressing. I called the location and was told they’ll let the manager and cook know. There was no sorry, no offer to make up another batch and bring back the remainder, no discount for my next purchase, no complementary wings with my next purchase, and they didn’t offer to take my number for a manager to follow up with me at a later date. I paid cash, that leaves me very little leverage in this situation. I will follow up with a manager come Monday morning in hopes of a resolution. Purchased Saturday 7-5-2025 8:35pm
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
jimi lehner
If you want a great little place to have a few drinks with friends and eat some fantastic food, this is it!! Gaming available also...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jerry Schaefer
I’ve ordered for pick up here before but tonight attended a work gathering in their new dining/bar/slot machine area. Everything was wonderful from bartenders, attentive staff to the customers, pizza buffet and the area cleanliness. I really enjoyed the new restaurant addition and may even stop back in for a slice.
Sandra Rangel
The food was wonderful, and the service was excellent! It was a pleasure dining with my party of eight for the first time.
Love this place. This is the best pizza around, grew up in Huntley was always my go to place. We live in Florida now, but anytime we are here, we have to get this pizza. Always hot and delicious and the perfect pie
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
To start with the person taking the order wasn't very friendly. I ordered a stuffed pizza with extra pepperoni. Most of the pizza had no pepperoni at all but lots of cheese. Then parts of the pizza had lots of pepperoni but very little cheese.
I also ordered jalapeno poppers and those tasted like the grease they cooked them in was old. I was very disappointed in all of it, especially for the price. This was my first time ordering and it will be my last.
Food: 1
Service: 3
My family has been using Papa Savario's for years. They truly do a fantastic job catering, and they have good bundle packs. I recommend it to make your family get-together dinners that much easier on you.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious pizza and friendly customer service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I thought this place was okay but I was wrong, they fooled me with one pizza that was made nice and neat and tasted good, but since then all the pizza are made very sloppy , there sauce is to sweet on the thin crust , there chicago style is some thick acid sauce that taste terrible and it's why to doughy. They cannot get the orders correct always forgetting things and can't make the pizza correct, I gave them a chance, but who ever runs this place or is making the pizza is not good and they need to sell this and let someone who cares take over! A family vote was taken and it was decided never again papa in huntley !
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ordered a late takeout dinner. Ordered a sausage and mushroom canzone. While waiting for it we sat at their bar and had a beer and seltzer. They havr quite a collection of hard liquor that includes Blanton's, Talamore Dew, and other favorites. Whrn we arrived hone, the calzone was hot and tasty.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sauce was good.messed up ordered thin crust.should of ordered regular crust.but garlic was on point.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
sometimes very chewy
The worst Pizza I've ever had! I paid $29.00 for a small thin Pizza Crust that comes with nothing on it. Nothing like the crystal lake location. It must be different owners. Honestly I've had frozen Pizza better than this. Don't waste your money and time here. Extremely disappointed . Shame on you. 👎
Food: 1
Service: 1
It’s 9:15. They close at 10:00. No one answered the phone and they shut off online ordering. Guess they don’t want my business. Lost me as a customer.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
It's 20 dollar pizza masquerading as 35 dollar pizza. Nothing special, especially at that price. Closer and cheaper and better options exist.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Ordered a pound of boneless wings tossed in buffalo sauce. About half of the wings were overcooked and more than half weren't even coated with the buffalo sauce. Thankfully I could scrape up some sauce from the bottom of the to go carton and drown them in the blue cheese dressing. I called the location and was told they’ll let the manager and cook know. There was no sorry, no offer to make up another batch and bring back the remainder, no discount for my next purchase, no complementary wings with my next purchase, and they didn’t offer to take my number for a manager to follow up with me at a later date. I paid cash, that leaves me very little leverage in this situation. I will follow up with a manager come Monday morning in hopes of a resolution. Purchased Saturday 7-5-2025 8:35pm
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
If you want a great little place to have a few drinks with friends and eat some fantastic food, this is it!! Gaming available also...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I’ve ordered for pick up here before but tonight attended a work gathering in their new dining/bar/slot machine area. Everything was wonderful from bartenders, attentive staff to the customers, pizza buffet and the area cleanliness. I really enjoyed the new restaurant addition and may even stop back in for a slice.
The food was wonderful, and the service was excellent! It was a pleasure dining with my party of eight for the first time.
Loading...