This was our first time visiting, and things were a bit confusing at the start—we weren’t sure where or how to pick up our pizza, and the wait time felt pretty long.
That said, the pizza was well-packaged for the ride home. The grease didn’t soak through the box, and the cheese stayed in place, which was a nice surprise.
I really enjoyed the cheese blend—it was flavorful and had a nice texture. The sauce tasted good too, though it got a little lost under all that cheese. Next time, I’ll ask for extra sauce to balance things out.
We ordered a cheese double dough and a pepperoni with a soft crust (pictured). The crust was tender and had a nice bite to it.
Overall, good pizza once we got it, but the ordering/pickup process could use a little more clarity for first-timers.
Lynn Falotico
First of all very small , chaotic. Five of us difficult to hear each other talk at table! Wait staff seamed stressed. Order pizza CSMOG the usual No flop good rich sauce. Good pizza as expected. If you want a good pizza take it home . If you want to lose you voice have a good conversation Dinner in . Good luck
Ken Shannon
Haven't been here in a while did pizza Italian bomber. Pizza as good as any. Beef definitely as good as anything you can find anywhere else and possibly a lot cheaper coleslaw pass the test just the way it's supposed to be. French fries no frills just the way they're supposed to be coming back for more yep.
Panida T
Great pizza, a nice chill place to have some drinks and watch the games. Good prices & a friendly bartender! Thank you!
Angel Garzaro
Hidden gem 💎
John Brown
Best BLT pizza this side of the Mississippi
AmyLynne McBee
Definitely get the BLT on extra thin crust!! You wont be disappointed
Cody Schneider
No matter what you get here you will not be disappointed. I've had just about everything on the menu and its all fantastic. BEST tavern/Chicago style pizza up north. I won't get pizza from anywhere else but here.
Eric Mueller
Great local bar. We order their ribs, reminds me of Carson ribs . Great taste very reasonable.
Erik Mitchell
We ordered a Deep Dish cheese and a Deep Dish sausage. They delivered 2 different crusts with different toppings then proceeded to argue on the phone for 30 min when we asked them to deliver what we ordered. Terrible service. Never again.
Great restaurant and sports bar. We had a great server who was very helpful and attentive. For dinner we ordered the back ribs and the classic lasagna. These were both delicious. Draft beers were a perfect add-on. We drive by here frequently and we’ll be back again!
Brenden Eskenazy
Absolutely delicious. My family and I stopped in and got a few appetizers, a burger, some pasta and 2 pizzas (they were Bogo 1/2 off). I got the extra thin crust, so light and crispy. Staff was polite and prompt with service! We will be returning
Ciclali C
Ordered a couple of pizzas for delivery, and when they came they forgot to bring one. The driver went back to pick it up and the owner gave us the money back for that pizza! The driver was super apologetic and it was a really nice thing for the owner to do. The pizzas were great! We will for sure be ordering from them again!
Connor B
Fanella's Pizza & Pub has awesome vibes, excellent pizza, and great staff. Love this place!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jim Papen
We've been here many times and the food is really good. Love the pizza. The salads are good too. Our server, Samantha, is awesome, too.
This was our first time visiting, and things were a bit confusing at the start—we weren’t sure where or how to pick up our pizza, and the wait time felt pretty long.
That said, the pizza was well-packaged for the ride home. The grease didn’t soak through the box, and the cheese stayed in place, which was a nice surprise.
I really enjoyed the cheese blend—it was flavorful and had a nice texture. The sauce tasted good too, though it got a little lost under all that cheese. Next time, I’ll ask for extra sauce to balance things out.
We ordered a cheese double dough and a pepperoni with a soft crust (pictured). The crust was tender and had a nice bite to it.
Overall, good pizza once we got it, but the ordering/pickup process could use a little more clarity for first-timers.
First of all very small , chaotic. Five of us difficult to hear each other talk at table!
Wait staff seamed stressed.
Order pizza CSMOG the usual
No flop good rich sauce.
Good pizza as expected.
If you want a good pizza take it home . If you want to lose you voice have a good conversation
Dinner in .
Good luck
Haven't been here in a while did pizza Italian bomber. Pizza as good as any. Beef definitely as good as anything you can find anywhere else and possibly a lot cheaper coleslaw pass the test just the way it's supposed to be. French fries no frills just the way they're supposed to be coming back for more yep.
Great pizza, a nice chill place to have some drinks and watch the games. Good prices & a friendly bartender! Thank you!
Hidden gem 💎
Best BLT pizza this side of the Mississippi
Definitely get the BLT on extra thin crust!! You wont be disappointed
No matter what you get here you will not be disappointed. I've had just about everything on the menu and its all fantastic. BEST tavern/Chicago style pizza up north. I won't get pizza from anywhere else but here.
Great local bar. We order their ribs, reminds me of Carson ribs . Great taste very reasonable.
We ordered a Deep Dish cheese and a Deep Dish sausage. They delivered 2 different crusts with different toppings then proceeded to argue on the phone for 30 min when we asked them to deliver what we ordered. Terrible service. Never again.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great restaurant and sports bar. We had a great server who was very helpful and attentive. For dinner we ordered the back ribs and the classic lasagna. These were both delicious. Draft beers were a perfect add-on. We drive by here frequently and we’ll be back again!
Absolutely delicious. My family and I stopped in and got a few appetizers, a burger, some pasta and 2 pizzas (they were Bogo 1/2 off). I got the extra thin crust, so light and crispy. Staff was polite and prompt with service! We will be returning
Ordered a couple of pizzas for delivery, and when they came they forgot to bring one. The driver went back to pick it up and the owner gave us the money back for that pizza! The driver was super apologetic and it was a really nice thing for the owner to do. The pizzas were great! We will for sure be ordering from them again!
Fanella's Pizza & Pub has awesome vibes, excellent pizza, and great staff. Love this place!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We've been here many times and the food is really good. Love the pizza. The salads are good too. Our server, Samantha, is awesome, too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicago Style Pizza
Loading...