We started off with a cocktail. The flavor was great, but just a tad strong on the alcohol. We had mac'n'cheese as an appetizer and then enjoyed the pizza Fire on the Mountain. It was all excellent. Don't let the name of the pizza scare you off; the heat is mild. Atmosphere is amazing with the history of the building. Service was fast and friendly. It was our first visit. Definitely will be back.
Paul Ellis
Very pleasant fast casual spot in Jerseyville...great service and good food!
JD Lee
Wanted to go back to Terrapin Place as it has been awhile since we first went there. Ordered the same pizza thinking the crust would be amazing like our prior visit. Today the pizza had a rim of crisp crust , but the rest was like limp cardboard. It was difficult to cut it and there was no way to pick the slice up. We asked our server to have the pizza crisped up and were told since we had already touched it they could not do that. She told us that is how the pizza is. Today's pizza was definately not like the pizza we had previously that had an amazing crispy crust with a unique flavor. Boxed up the pizza to bring home to crisp it up. If I had wanted to cook at home today, I wouldn't have bothered going out. The atmosphere is great, but today the pizza disappointed. Feel the server could have made an effort to make our experience better.
tony lane
Had great service and the atmosphere was well put together to feel relaxed.
Andrew Toigo
Really cool building and decor. Great attention to detail and pride in his menu. Incredible pizza. You can tell it's all made from scratch. The owner and servers were all really nice! They have great ranch dressing too. Love that they don't have TVs... nice change of pace and had us talking as a family and to others in the restaurant. Really fun! Worth driving to Jerseyville just for this place.
karen cairns
Great food and an amazing atmosphere!
Les S
Tried for the first time this evening and it was fantastic! We will definitely be back. Great service, pizza was great and the gouda mac and cheese is DANGEROUS in a good way!!
Frank Long
We seem to always have a good time when we stopped in
Brad Roach
Great workers that appreciate there job.we will be back to try out the rest of the menu. Thanks 😊
Thomas Stamberger
Good wood-fired pizza here. If you go I highly recommend trying the mac n cheese appetizer it was delicious.
Service and all happy employees. The own was very just as happy sat with us and told us all about the place. Also a waitress told us all about her turtle! I have never seen my grandson so happy to eat somewhere. He is already ready to go back before we even left there lol. He got a button for getting us all to go. Thank you all for such a great night! We will be back soon! Food excellent!
James Schroeder
They have fantastic food and service in a newly renovated building with excellent music!
Mike Flowers
Absolutely the best pizza ever.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
robin arview
Excellent!!! I highly recommend this place, the food, service, drinks, cleanliness, the atmosphere is the perfect vibe. ?
We started off with a cocktail. The flavor was great, but just a tad strong on the alcohol. We had mac'n'cheese as an appetizer and then enjoyed the pizza Fire on the Mountain. It was all excellent. Don't let the name of the pizza scare you off; the heat is mild. Atmosphere is amazing with the history of the building. Service was fast and friendly. It was our first visit. Definitely will be back.
Very pleasant fast casual spot in Jerseyville...great service and good food!
Wanted to go back to Terrapin Place as it has been awhile since we first went there. Ordered the same pizza thinking the crust would be amazing like our prior visit. Today the pizza had a rim of crisp crust , but the rest was like limp cardboard. It was difficult to cut it and there was no way to pick the slice up. We asked our server to have the pizza crisped up and were told since we had already touched it they could not do that. She told us that is how the pizza is. Today's pizza was definately not like the pizza we had previously that had an amazing crispy crust with a unique flavor. Boxed up the pizza to bring home to crisp it up. If I had wanted to cook at home today, I wouldn't have bothered going out. The atmosphere is great, but today the pizza disappointed. Feel the server could have made an effort to make our experience better.
Had great service and the atmosphere was well put together to feel relaxed.
Really cool building and decor. Great attention to detail and pride in his menu. Incredible pizza. You can tell it's all made from scratch. The owner and servers were all really nice! They have great ranch dressing too. Love that they don't have TVs... nice change of pace and had us talking as a family and to others in the restaurant. Really fun! Worth driving to Jerseyville just for this place.
Great food and an amazing atmosphere!
Tried for the first time this evening and it was fantastic! We will definitely be back. Great service, pizza was great and the gouda mac and cheese is DANGEROUS in a good way!!
We seem to always have a good time when we stopped in
Great workers that appreciate there job.we will be back to try out the rest of the menu. Thanks 😊
Good wood-fired pizza here. If you go I highly recommend trying the mac n cheese appetizer it was delicious.
Restaurantji Recommends
Service and all happy employees. The own was very just as happy sat with us and told us all about the place. Also a waitress told us all about her turtle! I have never seen my grandson so happy to eat somewhere. He is already ready to go back before we even left there lol. He got a button for getting us all to go. Thank you all for such a great night! We will be back soon! Food excellent!
They have fantastic food and service in a newly renovated building with excellent music!
Absolutely the best pizza ever.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent!!! I highly recommend this place, the food, service, drinks, cleanliness, the atmosphere is the perfect vibe. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Awesome atmosphere, amazing food. Great service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Loading...