Half and Half Pizza Co.
77 E Scranton Ave, Lake Bluff
(224) 706-6651
Customers' Favorites
Mushroom Bruschetta
Make Your Own Pizza
Make Your Own Pie
I Live in a Tent
Baked Goat Cheese
Whipped Ricotta
Build Your Own
White as Snow
Greek Salad
Meat Pizza
APPS/SNACKS
BAKED GOAT CHEESE
tomato sauce, goat cheese, evoo, oregano, garlic bread
CHEESY PIZZA BREAD
2 cheeses, tomato sauce, oregano, garlic herbs, side of ranch
MUSHROOM BRUSCHETTA
mushrooms, basil, roasted shallots, creamy reggiano sauce
TOMATO BRUSCHETTA
fresh tomatoes, basil vinaigrette, parmesan, garlic bread
RICOTTA & PISTACHIO DIP
GARLIC BREADSTICKS
(3 or 6 pcs) garlic, herbs, evoo, side of marinara sauce
ROASTED ARTICHOKES
italian artichokes, roasted tomatoes, whipped ricotta, pistachios
WINGS
garlic, chilies, with ranch or garlic parmesan or spicy cayenne - sauce on side
MEATBALLS
HAM & MANCHEGO APP
SALAD/SANDWICH
1923 CAESAR
romaine hearts, reggiano parmigiano, garlic croutons, caesar dressing.
CAMPANIA'S SUNSET
romaine hearts, fresh mozzarella, roasted pecans, garlic croutons, salami
gf GET HIM TO THE GREEK
tomatoes, cucumbers, pepperoncini, feta cheese, kalamata olives. (No lettuce)
gf ROASTED BEETS
whipped ricotta, pesto, hazelnuts
gf IT'S FROM CAPRI
tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil, cracked pepper, lemon
MEATBALL SANDWICH
slow cooked pork and beef with herbs & spices, tomato sauce, white wine, fresh basil, on asiago cheese bread
SPICY CHICKEN SANDWICH
reggiano parmesan sauce,asiago & parmesan cheese, calabrian spicy chilies, arugula
ITALIAN BEEF
house marinated and roasted beef,natural juice, herbs & spices, with house giardiniera
PIZZA
NO SLEEP... TILL... BROOKLYN!
fresh buffalo mozzarella, basil, chunky tomatoes, crispy prosciutto, evoo
AUTUMN IN PIEDMONT
black truffle, sliced tomatoes, fontina DOP cheese, topped with fresh arugula
CARNIVORE
italian sausage, smoked bacon, pepperoni, grilled chicken, mozzarella, house made tomato sauce
CHEESE
rich mozzarella, house made tomato sauce
DAD'S FAVORITE
house italian sausage, sweet onions, mozzarella, house made tomato sauce
I LIVE IN A TENT
mushrooms, onion, olives, peppers, broccolini, fresh basil, mozzarella, house made tomato sauce
JAMON DUE
serrano and proscuitto, thai basil, asiago & manchego cheese, chunky tomatoes, evoo
JOHN'S
house italian sausage, pepperoni, black olives, mozzarella, house made tomato sauce
MARGARITA OUR WAY
fresh tomato, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil
NO FAITH...
burnt pepperoni, fresh oregano, spicy chilies, manchego, asiago, mozzarella
SUPPERONI
under and over cheese pepperoni, house made tomato sauce, mozzarella
WHITE AS SNOW
mozzarella, ricotta, asiago, extra virgin, creamy parmesan sauce, oregano
WINNER
italian sausages, maitake mushroom, thai basil, asiago cheese, fresh tomatoes
A-SPICY A-MEAT-A-BALL
house beef & pork meatballs, calabrian chiles, oregano, onions
CACIO E PEPPE
smoked bacon, sweet onion, creamy reggiano sauce, parmesan, black pepper
LIKE IN PARMA
volcanic soil grown tomatoes, prosciutto, parmesan, mozzarella, asiago, basil
LOCAL MUSHROOMS
pistachios, parmesan sauce, ricotta, manchego cheese, arugula, shallots
BACKWARDS
BOLOGNESE
TAKE & BAKE
TAKE & BAKE AUTUMN IN PIEDMONT
black truffle, sliced tomatoes, fontina DOP cheese, topped with fresh arugula
TAKE & BAKE CARNIVORE
italian sausage, smoked bacon, pepperoni, grilled chicken, mozzarella, house made tomato sauce
TAKE & BAKE CHEESE
rich mozzarella, house made tomato sauce
TAKE & BAKE DAD'S FAVORITE
house italian sausage, sweet onions, mozzarella, house made tomato sauce
TAKE & BAKE I LIVE IN A TENT
mushrooms, onion, olives, peppers, broccolini, fresh basil, mozzarella, house made tomato sauce
TAKE & BAKE JAMON DUE
serrano and proscuitto, thai basil, asiago & manchego cheese, chunky tomatoes, evoo
TAKE & BAKE JOHN'S
house italian sausage, pepperoni, black olives, mozzarella, house made tomato sauce
TAKE & BAKE MARGARITA OUR WAY
fresh tomato, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil
TAKE & BAKE NO FAITH...
burnt pepperoni, fresh oregano, spicy chilies, manchego, asiago, mozzarella
TAKE & BAKE NO SLEEP... TILL... BROOKLYN!
fresh buffalo mozzarella, basil, chunky tomatoes, crispy prosciutto, evoo
TAKE & BAKE SUPPERONI
under and over cheese pepperoni, house made tomato sauce, mozzarella
TAKE & BAKE WHITE AS SNOW
mozzarella, ricotta, asiago, extra virgin, creamy parmesan sauce, oregano
TAKE & BAKE WINNER
italian sausages, maitake mushroom, thai basil, asiago cheese, fresh tomatoes
TAKE & BAKE A-SPICY A-MEAT-A-BALL
house beef & pork meatballs, calabrian chiles, oregano, onions
TAKE & BAKE BACKWARDS
TAKE & BAKE BOLOGNESE
TAKKE & BAKE CACIO E PEPPE
smoked bacon, sweet onion, creamy reggiano sauce, parmesan, black pepper
TAKE & BAKE LIKE IN PARMA
volcanic soil grown tomatoes, prosciutto, parmesan, mozzarella, asiago, basil
TAKE & BAKE LOCAL MUSHROOMS
pistachios, parmesan sauce, ricotta, manchego cheese, arugula, shallots
TAKE & BAKE MAKE YOUR OWN
includes sauce & cheese(EACH ADDITIONAL 2.50) - limit 6 toppings
MAKE YOUR OWN
MAKE YOUR OWN PIZZA
includes sauce & cheese(EACH ADDITIONAL 2.50) - limit 6 toppings
MAKE YOUR OWN PERSONAL 8"
PERSONAL PIZZA
KIDS CHEESE
KIDS PEPPERONI
KIDS SAUSAGE
MAKE YOUR OWN PERSONAL 8"
DESSERT
VANILLA
CHOCOLATE
CARAMEL
TROPICAL SORBET
RASPBERRY
STRAWBERRY
MACAROONS
CREAM PUFF
RICE CRIPSY
SAUCES & SIDES
SIDE BASIL AIOLI
SIDE MARINARA SAUCE
SIDE SPICY CAYENNE SAUCE
SIDE GARLIC BREAD
SIDE REGGIANO SAUCE
SIDE CAESAR DRESSING
SIDE BASIL VINAIGRETTE
SIDE BALSAMIC VINAIGRETTE
DRINKS
Cadence Cold Brew Coffee South American Ethiopian Blend
Cadence Cold Brew South American Coffee
Coca Cola
Diet Coke
Sprite
Squirt
Rootbeer
Coco5 Lime
Coco5 Passionfruit
Coco5 Cherry
Coco5 Orange
Coco5 Pineapple
Spindrift Orange Mango
Spindrift Blood Orange Tangerine
Spindrift Raspberry Lime
San Pellegrino Limonata
San Pellegrino Aranciata
San Pellegrino Sparkling Water
APPS/SNACKS
CHEESY PIZZA BREAD
2 cheeses, tomato sauce, oregano, garlic herbs, side of ranch
MUSHROOM BRUSCHETTA
mushrooms, basil, roasted shallots, creamy reggiano sauce
TOMATO BRUSCHETTA
fresh tomatoes, basil vinaigrette, parmesan, garlic bread
CRISPY CHEESE BALLS
2 cheeses, oregano, garlic and basil aioli
BAKED GOAT CHEESE
tomato sauce, goat cheese, evoo, oregano, garlic bread
RICOTTA & PISTACHIO DIP
GARLIC BREADSTICKS
(3 or 6 pcs) garlic, herbs, evoo, side of marinara sauce
ROASTED ARTICHOKES
italian artichokes, roasted tomatoes, whipped ricotta, pistachios
WINGS
garlic, chilies, with ranch or garlic parmesan or spicy cayenne - sauce on side
MEATBALLS
HAM & MANCHEGO APP
Photos
+22 photos
+21 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
First time at Half and Half Pizza Co. tonight and I will return. The pizza is incredible! and on top of that the atmosphere is great and the staff were equally incredible. A very impressive selection of wine so I can’t imagine you wouldn’t find something you’d like. Great experience.
November 2025
My third visit has cemented my opinion of Half & Half Pizza. The staff at every visit have been helpful, friendly and professional. The pizza is outstanding, I have tried three different pizzas with their classic crust. Very consistent with flavor, cook and quality of ingredients. The wings should not be overlooked as well. Excited for my next visit.
July 2024
The pizza was wonderful! Absolutely recommend White As Snow! I came with 3 kids and they were willing to do substitutions. Great experience and will definitely be back. I want to try take and bake next.
February 2024
You May Also Like
Lake Bluff Brewing Company - 16 E Scranton Ave
![]()
Brewery, Pubs, American, Bar, New American
Maevery Public House - 20 E Scranton Ave
![]()
American, Cocktail Bar, Gastropubs, New American, Pet Friendly
Hansa Coffee and Wine Sellers - 24 E Scranton Ave
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee, Gluten-Free