Tavern Steakhouse Libertyville

519 N Milwaukee Ave, Libertyville
(847) 367-5755

Recent Reviews

Shauna

We've been dining at Tavern since we were kids. Back when the tables were mahogany wood and jackets were required. We love to celebrate special occasions here or dine with friends casually. The service, food and atmosphere is at a quality all in its own category. Amanda does a phenomenal job managing and the staff is second to none. If you needed an excuse to try this place out...here's your sign.

Jason H.

OUTSTANDING! We arrived and were immediately impressed. Every aspect of our meal was amazing. There isn't mention of a dress code, but you would feel comfortable from business casual, up. Prices match the caliber of the meal, service and atmosphere. We will return, definitely!

Mike Kruse

Excellent food and staff! The staff was very friendly and informational. The food is worth the price. You would be leaving saying you could made it better for cheaper at home. Great experience and highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Lava Cake, Dry-Aged Bone-In Ribeye

Nicole N.

Absolutely amazing experience! Phenomenal food (we tried the ribeye, filet, and pork chop and they were all incredible). Warm basket of different kinds of bread were offered along with our meal, drinks were delish, and the staff were extremely warm and welcoming. It had a very unique style, fancy and elegant yet we felt comfortable and welcomed in jeans. I cannot recommend this place more!

JasonH

OUTSTANDING! We arrived and were immediately impressed. Every aspect of our meal was amazing. There isn't mention of a dress code, but you would feel comfortable from business casual, up. Prices match the caliber of the meal, service and atmosphere. We will return, definitely!

DeniseG

We have eaten at The Tavern on several occasions. Unfortunately our experience this time was not so great. Dinner there has always been expensive, but we have also left dinner with a very positive dining experience. Our dinner this time was not positive. The steaks were very good, however the the pork chop was poor and the lobster tail overcooked and tough. We will give The Tavern another try given our great experiences in the past.

Wise G.

Not bad, the aged ribeye was pretty good, so was the pork chop. I got the Shrimp app and the shrimp was very rubbery. A little disappointed that this place was so expensive and would serve rubbery shrimp. Spent $300 for two people. The drinks were very mediocre. Service and ambiance were good but would not go back solely on the price to quality comparison. I feel you could get better elsewhere for the cost. Have no issues spending good money on excellent good but this place fell a little short.

Excellent food all around. The first few drinks we ordered were out of stock. We did settle on an excellent bottle of Overture. My only complaint was that we finished an entire bottle of wine before we received a water refill. Food here never disappoints

We were warmly greeted. The service was excellent, Patrick did a great job. The food was excellent. The drinks were excellent. The atmosphere was excellent and the noise level was very satisfactory. You could actually talk to people at your table. Highly recommended by us.

Robert H.

Family from Florida and Colorado to celebrate Seaman Merrick's completion of boot camp. Steaks from Allen Brothers perfectly prepared. Outstanding service provided by "Fen" and his team! No rush, great setting. Could not ask for more or better!!

Julie

Absolutely fantastic meal, service and atmosphere. Best meal we have had in a long time. Patrick, our server, was super attentive. The support staff was awesome with filling our waters, removing dishes. Highly recommend!

Kitty

I love the relaxed feel of this place – like a comfortable dining room in a friends home. We were seated along the wall and it was really quiet. Perfect table for a birthday dinner. I definitely would return to try more dishes. The smoke salmon appetizer was amazing. The tavern salad was refreshing.The broiled gulf shrimp and the sauces were outstanding (only downside, it wasn't peeled). My husband had the pork chop which was very tender and one of the best he's ever had. Service was well-timed and friendly, wines were affordable." Our server (Juan) was wonderful! The flourless chocolate cake was a nice surprise. Will definitely go back!

JodiA

From the moment we walked in, I loved it! The ambiance was perfect. Cozy, eclectic, and beautiful! Every dish, from the appetizers to the homemade bread they bring around to our main entrees, was amazing! We were celebrating a very special moment in our son's life and they went beyond to make him feel so special. So much thanks! We will definitely come back during our next visit!

Eddie Moore

I could have made what we had at home. Just blah. However, ambience was superb and the cocktails were stellar

Anne B.

The festive ambience was amazing! We were greeted warmly and had great service! The food was delicious. I had the paparadelle with shrimp and scallops. Overflowing with seafood! It is pricey but will come back again for special occasions.

Load More