The Italian Wedding soup was too salty, but the kale chip accompaniment was a nice touch. Crab cake was good, the apple match sticks and watercress greens complimented it well. Walleye Pike with Etouffe had too much rice soaked with the sauce. The fish was cooked perfectly, but the etouffe sauce over powered it. I think it would have been better if the fish was served on a plain- or saffron infused-rice with a lemon-butter sauce. NY Strip Steak with Gorgonzola sauce was perfectly cooked. The shareable mashed potatoes and mushroom sides were also very good. The bread pudding dessert was dry, but the ice cream topping overcame it. Service by Casey and the supporting staff was excellent.
Zoom Y.
We were a group of six adults and a child and had a wonderful dining experience on a day after Christmas of 2023. The place wasn't busy - we had a reservation, though, and we were seated right away. Our server, Casey (sp?), was very friendly and accommodating. Everything we ordered, from the starters to entrees with a couple of sides for sharing, were all delicious. I had Scallop Risotto and it was the best risotto I've ever had! They let me substitute the peas with asparagus, which I appreciated and they tasted so much better. Everyone was fully satisfied with their meal and we all enjoyed the evening. Harry Carey is a great restaurant - although it's a bit pricey, I highly recommend it, especially for a special occasion!
Andreas Rosboch
Bartenders are nice but food was very disappointing.Pasta was overcooked. Sauce was scalding and lacking in distinct flavours. Meat pieces in the sauces were chewy and full of tendons. A soggy mess.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Albert T
Went here for a late Valentines Day date because we knew during the week would be busier. Server was great until it started getting busier and we didn’t see him much after. He asked if I wanted another drink, I replied yes, then never saw him until I got the check (never got my second drink). Food was “okay”. We’ve been to many steakhouses before and this was bottom tier. After our dinner, we would rate it an average of 6.5/10 for a $200 check.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
LaWonna B.
The reason why I decided to give e this restaurant 3 stars is SOLELY due to our server, Johnathan, aka Johnny, aka "DA MAN!" We had food that was , at best, SUBPAR! Our party sent food back to the kitchen MULTIPLE times, and it was VERY uncomfortable for us, especially since we were there celebrating a birthday. If it hadn't been for Johnny, we probably would have left. I'd like to thank Johnny for being super kind and professional. He allowed us to have fun and tried to make sure we had EVERYTHING we needed. Would I recommend this restaurant to my friends and family, uh, NO! This was my very FIRST time there, but I shall NOT return. I do not write these reviews to bother or anger anyone. I'm simply giving my opinion, which, in this case, is extremely poor as it relates to this restaurant. I'm done good people, please have a wonderful weekend! Eat, drink, and be kind to one another! Smooches
JimC
Our server was fantastic. Everyone attentive and friendly. We have eaten here several times is past and had better food experience. The filet mignon my wife had ,though cooked to order was chewier than she expected and what she has had before. The prime rib special I had was also tough. Not what we are used to from Harry's
Mark Kukla
We needed a last minute dinner reservation and this place was able to accommodate us on a Friday night which was nice. The restaurant looks cool. Our server was super nice, food was good. They did not have espresso or cappuccino which should be taking off the menu, our server said the machine has been broken for 7 months.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Spliffy B
Not impressed. Used to love Harry Careys but the food was subpar, at best. We had some salads that weren't bad or great. Corn Brule didn't even look appetizing, much less taste. Calamari was good. The breaking ball dessert was a joke. Looked great but very underwhelming once it was cracked open. The piniata dessert, same idea as this, at uncle julios puts this to shame for the same price. And when the bill came I was very disappointed that when my daughters ordered lemonade the server asked if they wanted Raspberry lemonade, without Informing ME, that instead of 3.50 the drink would be $8. I ended up paying $30 for 4 lemonade for my 8/12 yr old. Completely ridiculous and ubsurd. Don't try upselling to an 8 yr old when it's going to double the cost of a child's drink. Theres NO REASON 4 KID LEMONADES SHOULD BE $30. WONT BE RETURNING HERE. Much rather have a great meal, that exceeds expectations in TASTE and service at Gibsons, Jalexanders. EDIT: And now that I looked online, i see they have a children's menu. That's fantastic. Next time, they should offer it to my 8/12 yr old. $350 lunch today for 3 salads, a chicken sand, chicken vesuvio, my 2 kids who could've ordered off the kids menu(turkey sand, sliders), calamari, a side of corn/broccoli, 4 kid lemonade, and waters. Literally came out to $50/per person w/tip for crappy lunch. Nothing was worth going back to have again. They need new management cause this place used to be awesome.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
Ron Nunnery
Great place and great service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak
William MARTIN
I really enjoyed the food.Whether in the morning with a hearty savory breakfast or a meal, there is always something good to eat.I ate burgers and lasagna there, all the dishes were good.The service is also excellent.
Ordered chicken picatta to go. Definitely one of the better decisions I've made this month so far.
Food: 5
NancyH
We had drinks and lunch on a Saturday afternoon. Drinks started with Bloody Mary cocktails, and some wine. our lunches consisted of salads, hamburgers, and the ravioli. Everything was excellent. The service was excellent, the bar is nice and large and the lunch tables are well situated so we could watch several sporting events at the same time. Of the salad selections we had the Kale and the Chicken Chopped salads. Both were large and well made with fresh vegetables. The Toasted Ravioli is actually baked so it is not greasy but was filled with cheese and sausage. The Hamburger was very large and served with sweet potato fries. Everything was cooked to our liking. The staff is also very good.
Michael J.
Bad food, ok service, bar ambiance. Ordered tenderloin linguine it was bland, the meat was fatty and chewy. Thought I'd avoid the cold and eat at the hotel. Rather freeze.
Philly Red
Our visit was the end of June 2023 during a business trip at dinner. We were also celebrating a birthday and the birthday boy chose this location. It was a party of 7. The location was safe and plenty of parking. The décor was excellent and so was the staff. Food was good but I have had better for what I had and price paid. Not much for the price you pay for some of the regular dishes. I had to have my special cooked because of allergies and the staff was accommodating. Overall, it was a nice mealtime with co-workers, celebrating a birthday boy. Nice for a fancy date-night. Desert was good as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Theresa Yvonne
my husband and i came here for our 2nd wedding (11 year anniversary) for dinner. Their gluten free pasta was delicious! and the service was GREAT! Dietary restrictions: they have gluten free options (pasta was one of them and it was DELICIOUS, might I add.
The Italian Wedding soup was too salty, but the kale chip accompaniment was a nice touch. Crab cake was good, the apple match sticks and watercress greens complimented it well. Walleye Pike with Etouffe had too much rice soaked with the sauce. The fish was cooked perfectly, but the etouffe sauce over powered it. I think it would have been better if the fish was served on a plain- or saffron infused-rice with a lemon-butter sauce. NY Strip Steak with Gorgonzola sauce was perfectly cooked. The shareable mashed potatoes and mushroom sides were also very good. The bread pudding dessert was dry, but the ice cream topping overcame it. Service by Casey and the supporting staff was excellent.
We were a group of six adults and a child and had a wonderful dining experience on a day after Christmas of 2023. The place wasn't busy - we had a reservation, though, and we were seated right away. Our server, Casey (sp?), was very friendly and accommodating. Everything we ordered, from the starters to entrees with a couple of sides for sharing, were all delicious. I had Scallop Risotto and it was the best risotto I've ever had! They let me substitute the peas with asparagus, which I appreciated and they tasted so much better. Everyone was fully satisfied with their meal and we all enjoyed the evening. Harry Carey is a great restaurant - although it's a bit pricey, I highly recommend it, especially for a special occasion!
Bartenders are nice but food was very disappointing.Pasta was overcooked. Sauce was scalding and lacking in distinct flavours. Meat pieces in the sauces were chewy and full of tendons. A soggy mess.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Went here for a late Valentines Day date because we knew during the week would be busier. Server was great until it started getting busier and we didn’t see him much after. He asked if I wanted another drink, I replied yes, then never saw him until I got the check (never got my second drink). Food was “okay”. We’ve been to many steakhouses before and this was bottom tier. After our dinner, we would rate it an average of 6.5/10 for a $200 check.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
The reason why I decided to give e this restaurant 3 stars is SOLELY due to our server, Johnathan, aka Johnny, aka "DA MAN!" We had food that was , at best, SUBPAR! Our party sent food back to the kitchen MULTIPLE times, and it was VERY uncomfortable for us, especially since we were there celebrating a birthday. If it hadn't been for Johnny, we probably would have left. I'd like to thank Johnny for being super kind and professional. He allowed us to have fun and tried to make sure we had EVERYTHING we needed. Would I recommend this restaurant to my friends and family, uh, NO! This was my very FIRST time there, but I shall NOT return. I do not write these reviews to bother or anger anyone. I'm simply giving my opinion, which, in this case, is extremely poor as it relates to this restaurant. I'm done good people, please have a wonderful weekend! Eat, drink, and be kind to one another! Smooches
Our server was fantastic. Everyone attentive and friendly. We have eaten here several times is past and had better food experience. The filet mignon my wife had ,though cooked to order was chewier than she expected and what she has had before. The prime rib special I had was also tough. Not what we are used to from Harry's
We needed a last minute dinner reservation and this place was able to accommodate us on a Friday night which was nice. The restaurant looks cool. Our server was super nice, food was good. They did not have espresso or cappuccino which should be taking off the menu, our server said the machine has been broken for 7 months.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Not impressed. Used to love Harry Careys but the food was subpar, at best. We had some salads that weren't bad or great. Corn Brule didn't even look appetizing, much less taste. Calamari was good. The breaking ball dessert was a joke. Looked great but very underwhelming once it was cracked open. The piniata dessert, same idea as this, at uncle julios puts this to shame for the same price. And when the bill came I was very disappointed that when my daughters ordered lemonade the server asked if they wanted Raspberry lemonade, without Informing ME, that instead of 3.50 the drink would be $8. I ended up paying $30 for 4 lemonade for my 8/12 yr old. Completely ridiculous and ubsurd. Don't try upselling to an 8 yr old when it's going to double the cost of a child's drink. Theres NO REASON 4 KID LEMONADES SHOULD BE $30. WONT BE RETURNING HERE. Much rather have a great meal, that exceeds expectations in TASTE and service at Gibsons, Jalexanders. EDIT: And now that I looked online, i see they have a children's menu. That's fantastic. Next time, they should offer it to my 8/12 yr old. $350 lunch today for 3 salads, a chicken sand, chicken vesuvio, my 2 kids who could've ordered off the kids menu(turkey sand, sliders), calamari, a side of corn/broccoli, 4 kid lemonade, and waters. Literally came out to $50/per person w/tip for crappy lunch. Nothing was worth going back to have again. They need new management cause this place used to be awesome.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
Great place and great service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak
I really enjoyed the food.Whether in the morning with a hearty savory breakfast or a meal, there is always something good to eat.I ate burgers and lasagna there, all the dishes were good.The service is also excellent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Ordered chicken picatta to go. Definitely one of the better decisions I've made this month so far.
Food: 5
We had drinks and lunch on a Saturday afternoon. Drinks started with Bloody Mary cocktails, and some wine. our lunches consisted of salads, hamburgers, and the ravioli. Everything was excellent. The service was excellent, the bar is nice and large and the lunch tables are well situated so we could watch several sporting events at the same time. Of the salad selections we had the Kale and the Chicken Chopped salads. Both were large and well made with fresh vegetables. The Toasted Ravioli is actually baked so it is not greasy but was filled with cheese and sausage. The Hamburger was very large and served with sweet potato fries. Everything was cooked to our liking. The staff is also very good.
Bad food, ok service, bar ambiance. Ordered tenderloin linguine it was bland, the meat was fatty and chewy. Thought I'd avoid the cold and eat at the hotel. Rather freeze.
Our visit was the end of June 2023 during a business trip at dinner. We were also celebrating a birthday and the birthday boy chose this location. It was a party of 7. The location was safe and plenty of parking. The décor was excellent and so was the staff. Food was good but I have had better for what I had and price paid. Not much for the price you pay for some of the regular dishes. I had to have my special cooked because of allergies and the staff was accommodating. Overall, it was a nice mealtime with co-workers, celebrating a birthday boy. Nice for a fancy date-night. Desert was good as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
my husband and i came here for our 2nd wedding (11 year anniversary) for dinner. Their gluten free pasta was delicious! and the service was GREAT! Dietary restrictions: they have gluten free options (pasta was one of them and it was DELICIOUS, might I add.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5