Cimino's Pizza

107 E Mason St, Polo
(815) 946-9123

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Brad Nielsen

This is a very small town they are in.Everything is horrible. I tried one more time and had baked Mostaccioli giving them one more chance after years of avoiding them because I forgot how bad it was and had a taste for pasta.I have tried Pizza 1 year ago and regretted it(horrible) Lasagna 2 noodles in the whole thing. The garlic bread was horrible and not even toasted,I toasted it and it was still disgusting.The little bread rolls they give you with pasta are terrible. There is no meat in the sauce and you have to buy Meatballs which are terrible too. I don't know how they stay in business. I just wasted the last $24 dollars there yesterday.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

Kaitlyn Stevens

Food is always cold when we order. We have ordered stuffed crust before and it was stuffed with cheese but not the most recent time we ordered it. So no point to have that as a menu option if you don't do it. Or explain that it's just folded over thick crust instead

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Rip off

Git same order week ago now charged $20 more smh going Dixon from now on was good customer too oh well there loss $50 for an pizza 12 bosko sticks poorboy an fries smh

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Sara Meiners

The owners are wonderful people.By far, my favorite pizza in the area!!!Their menu offers so many options.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Zach Arbogast

On a cold and snowy night, they still delivered some of the most perfect pizzas we've ever seen.

Megan Nichole

Never disappoints! The cheesy garlic bread is a must!

Mark Maginnis

Pizza, pasta, even gluten free pizza

bill c

Have y’all ever eaten pizza? What we got delivered was 3 inches of bad dough with undercooked cheese and canned mushrooms. It was not pizza, to call it such would be a crime. Y’all are 1.5 hours from Chicago go on a field trip and learn what pizza is.

Olivia Drew

great pizza

Aric Bender

They usually get my order wrong

Cynthia Schryver

Always good pizza!

bill costantino

Have y’all ever eaten pizza? What we got delivered was 3 inches of bad dough with undercooked cheese and canned mushrooms. It was not pizza, to call it such would be a crime. Y’all are 1.5 hours from Chicago go on a field trip and learn what pizza is.

James Johnstone

Good food great service

Olivia Winters

great pizza

Dwayne Schier

I grew up on their pizza and lasagna its the best I miss it because I've moved to Missouri and there aint nothing like it down here

Loading...