The woman who answered the phone is rude and misleading. She deliberately lied to ensure a sale.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jason Casford
Mainly carry out! So, rated low because no wait staff and no atmosphere. One of our top picks for pizza.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Garlic Nuggets, Garlic Bread
Doug lauck
Good food long wait when
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Donna Hammerich
I get their awesome house special pizza. Sometimes I'll pick up, or get delivery, pizza is always hot and delicious. The sauce! Just love it. (i imagine it's a secret Alfano family recipe) Authentic Italian pizza.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sauce
Bob B.
The pizzas and ingredients were excellent. They were quickly prepared and on time. We received good value for the price!
Taylor Schott
Its sad cause the food is good here usually but damn tell me 45 mins for my take out order and get there nothing is ready and waited an hour and 15 mins it was ridiculous for how small my order was a whopping 13 bucks. 6 ppl running around back there and no structure.
For The people
Best pizza in the area grew up here all my life I don't care what none of these comments say the pizza is always fresh!! Everything is fresh made here including the pizza dough!! I love the chicken strips the ranch is house made!! The BEST!! and the deserts are amazing the cake and cinnamon puffs! Look no further! U want quality pizza this is the place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grilled Ham and Cheese, dbl Bacon Burger, Sauce, Chicken Breast Deluxe, Homemade Hamburger, Lasagna, Chef Salad, Garlic Nuggets, Fettuccine Alfredo, Garlic Bread, Meat or Cheese Tortellini, Onions Rings, Cannoli, Grilled Cheese, Pizza Bread, French Fries
Justin Seibert
It says they are open no answer. Literally called 20 times. It says they are open but no answer. This is not the 1st time this has happened......
Johnny Lake
Ordered food from Alfanos in Spring valley and again it was a mistake doing so! My fiance ordered a mushroom and Swiss burger with grilled onion added, they did not grill The Onion the burger was burnt on the outside and actually red and raw in middle. Little Sicily has really gone downhill from the quality that they used to have. A waste of money for the low quality food and service you will receive.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Damian Marcum
Extremely lucky to get 1 star. The shrimp that I received was NOT COOKED. It was grey and sad. Most likely the worse dining experience I have had in YEARS. Would definitely not recommend anything but the pizza and garlic knots. Would not dine again. No excuse for raw shrimp.
It rarely deserves any stars. The woman at the front desk is pretty stern, and never in my life. Have I ever been involved in an argument from a lady taking orders from a pizza place? It was a horror experience my Fries were not cold. They were steaming, and she blamed that the fries were soggy because I was six minutes Then she argued with me that it was more than that. I normally don’t do stuff like this but it’s crazy how she handled that situation from now on I’m going to Angelo’s better customer service. And they don’t get your order wrong I don’t want to come off rude or antagonizing this woman, but the way she handled this situation and started arguing with me leaves a bad taste in my mouth and not just the soggy oily hot fries that she blamed me for being six minutes late And not to mention, there is a hole in my cup of nacho cheese I also offered to pay if she could make them crispy and she talked over me the whole conversation before I could explain myself nothing against this pizza place at all. They have great delicious food, but the service could use a little work. And one of my cheese cups has a black residue and a little indent on it as you seen the picture below And even though I said, I will pay them to reheat them and crisp them up for me And she said no, which is perfectly in her right but then she told me that something they don’t do But they have done it before when I ordered a pizza from them so there’s just a lot of new ones so just be wise what you order and make sure you check your food before you leave the store It doesn’t matter if you’re a loyal customer. The lady at the desk just seems unhappy all the time.
Mike Nowakowski
I waited 2 hours for a sub and I live right down the street and it costed me 26$ and I was going to tip the driver 10 but it took for ever (ordered @9. Didn’t get till 11 so idk what the deal is pay y’all’s drivers better or get more maybe ppl won’t complain so
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Stephanie Hall
Sorry to say, but they went downhill, used to love alfanos now I won't go there again... pizza sucks now!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Christopher Pelc
$63.30 for pizza and wings. Wings were good. Pizza on the other hand not so good. The pepperoni had a funky smell and taste. The cheese under the pepperoni tasted like plastic and was nasty. Called in and said something about. Got told that it's the same cheese and pepperoni they have been using all day. Not sure what happened or if it was spoiled product or what but even my dog wouldn't eat it.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jose Ramirez
Order a pizza canceled the order I called them and they said they haven’t made it yet it it’s been over two hours never order from there again
The woman who answered the phone is rude and misleading. She deliberately lied to ensure a sale.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Mainly carry out! So, rated low because no wait staff and no atmosphere. One of our top picks for pizza.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Garlic Nuggets, Garlic Bread
Good food long wait when
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
I get their awesome house special pizza. Sometimes I'll pick up, or get delivery, pizza is always hot and delicious. The sauce! Just love it. (i imagine it's a secret Alfano family recipe) Authentic Italian pizza.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sauce
The pizzas and ingredients were excellent. They were quickly prepared and on time. We received good value for the price!
Its sad cause the food is good here usually but damn tell me 45 mins for my take out order and get there nothing is ready and waited an hour and 15 mins it was ridiculous for how small my order was a whopping 13 bucks. 6 ppl running around back there and no structure.
Best pizza in the area grew up here all my life I don't care what none of these comments say the pizza is always fresh!! Everything is fresh made here including the pizza dough!! I love the chicken strips the ranch is house made!! The BEST!! and the deserts are amazing the cake and cinnamon puffs! Look no further! U want quality pizza this is the place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grilled Ham and Cheese, dbl Bacon Burger, Sauce, Chicken Breast Deluxe, Homemade Hamburger, Lasagna, Chef Salad, Garlic Nuggets, Fettuccine Alfredo, Garlic Bread, Meat or Cheese Tortellini, Onions Rings, Cannoli, Grilled Cheese, Pizza Bread, French Fries
It says they are open no answer. Literally called 20 times. It says they are open but no answer. This is not the 1st time this has happened......
Ordered food from Alfanos in Spring valley and again it was a mistake doing so! My fiance ordered a mushroom and Swiss burger with grilled onion added, they did not grill The Onion the burger was burnt on the outside and actually red and raw in middle. Little Sicily has really gone downhill from the quality that they used to have. A waste of money for the low quality food and service you will receive.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Extremely lucky to get 1 star. The shrimp that I received was NOT COOKED. It was grey and sad. Most likely the worse dining experience I have had in YEARS. Would definitely not recommend anything but the pizza and garlic knots. Would not dine again. No excuse for raw shrimp.
Atmosphere: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Garlic Nuggets
Restaurantji Recommends
It rarely deserves any stars. The woman at the front desk is pretty stern, and never in my life. Have I ever been involved in an argument from a lady taking orders from a pizza place? It was a horror experience my Fries were not cold. They were steaming, and she blamed that the fries were soggy because I was six minutes Then she argued with me that it was more than that. I normally don’t do stuff like this but it’s crazy how she handled that situation from now on I’m going to Angelo’s better customer service. And they don’t get your order wrong I don’t want to come off rude or antagonizing this woman, but the way she handled this situation and started arguing with me leaves a bad taste in my mouth and not just the soggy oily hot fries that she blamed me for being six minutes late And not to mention, there is a hole in my cup of nacho cheese I also offered to pay if she could make them crispy and she talked over me the whole conversation before I could explain myself nothing against this pizza place at all. They have great delicious food, but the service could use a little work. And one of my cheese cups has a black residue and a little indent on it as you seen the picture below And even though I said, I will pay them to reheat them and crisp them up for me And she said no, which is perfectly in her right but then she told me that something they don’t do But they have done it before when I ordered a pizza from them so there’s just a lot of new ones so just be wise what you order and make sure you check your food before you leave the store It doesn’t matter if you’re a loyal customer. The lady at the desk just seems unhappy all the time.
I waited 2 hours for a sub and I live right down the street and it costed me 26$ and I was going to tip the driver 10 but it took for ever (ordered @9. Didn’t get till 11 so idk what the deal is pay y’all’s drivers better or get more maybe ppl won’t complain so
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Sorry to say, but they went downhill, used to love alfanos now I won't go there again... pizza sucks now!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
$63.30 for pizza and wings. Wings were good. Pizza on the other hand not so good. The pepperoni had a funky smell and taste. The cheese under the pepperoni tasted like plastic and was nasty. Called in and said something about. Got told that it's the same cheese and pepperoni they have been using all day. Not sure what happened or if it was spoiled product or what but even my dog wouldn't eat it.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Order a pizza canceled the order I called them and they said they haven’t made it yet it it’s been over two hours never order from there again