Matt's Cookie Company

482 N Milwaukee Ave, Wheeling
(847) 537-3888

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Joshua Davis

I bought a package at fareway in Newton, IA where I'm from and was excited to see them cause I haven't had them since I was a kid and I'm 47 now so I think about 12yrs old is when I had them last and I remember them being soft and very moist and flavorful with tons of chocolate chunks but I got a pack of them the other day and they definitely aren't the same and like other people has said the taste is off and way too crumbly and they just aren't like they used to be as I remember as a kid so it was very disappointing.

David Ward

Disappointed in the smaller size of the cookie. Oatmeal raisin so hard I had to soften them up in the microwave. You've lost a customer.

Patti Beitzel

I have had to start eating clean because of my health. Most fig bars will make me very ill because of all the processed ingredients. Matt's Fig Bars are delicious and I can eat them any time i want and not be sick. I am hoping to keep buying them on a regular basis.

Daria Chastang

I got the Peanut and Chocolate Chip cookies from Whole Foods and I am a fan! Especially after you heat them up a little to get the chocolate to melt.

I didn't really read the label, just wanted a soft baked peanut butter cookie. And these are really good! I just saw that they are dairy free and I'm even more impressed by the taste and texture. Can't wait to try the other flavors. 🍪 😋

Elise Smith

I just tried the soft baked chocolate peanut butter cookies for the first time yesterday....and I. Am. In. Love!!!

The little peanut pieces. The shape of the cookies that look like they were scooped and baked by hand. The texture. The flavor.

These are the store bought cookies that taste home made I have been looking for. Can't wait to try the other flavors.

STEVE 0

Don't taste the same. Smaller package.

Marty Johnson

Your shrinkflation is total B.S.
Won’t pay the same price for half the cookies.

Paloma Porras

These cookies are by far the best we've ever had. It's a pure treat and delight for me and my husband. Matt's cookies are deliciously soft and moist and better than homemade cookies. We've tried others and we always come back to Matt's cookies. We especially love their Double Chocolate Peppermint cookies. They are becoming a staple in our home along with their other flavorful cookies.

Michael Heunermund

As a fat guy I have always been a fan of cookies and Matt's does not disappoint! They make my favorite peanut butter cookies and I can't get enough of them!!

Tarina Harris

Omg I just tried Matt's apple oat crisp wow they are so good moist flavorful like home made cookies from home. I hope you sell the apple ones year round. Oh could you try orange cranberry cookies and lemon cookies

Richard Ahern

I saw the overall average and it was so low I had to help rectify that. These cookies were delicious and soft (oatmeal raisin) and non-dairy. Perfect for me. Never heard of them and I grew up in the Chicago area. Menards has them in Minnesota.

Cindy Rose

These are moist and delicious! I’m lactose intolerant and can’t eat the majority of cookies and treats as they have dairy as an ingredient. These dairy free cookies are so great tasting and I appreciate that I can finally have a sweet treat!

Susan Lovett

Just bought the cookies, for the first time! Amazing. Thank you for making dairy free.

Chanel Palmer

I just wanted to reach out and comment on your product. I recently purchased Matt's peanut butter cookies, and I have never tasted a cookie like this. It was super moist and flavorful. They tasted like a homemade cookie. These cookies made me go back to my local ShopRite and purchase all the remaining boxes.

I would have never thought a cookie made from so far away would be about to retain its texture and flavor. I am excited to try the other flavors.
A new fan from New Jersey!!!!

Cindy C

Amazing cookies. They taste like they were made with real ingredients in someone's home kitchen. Looking at the short list of ingredients, I understood. I tried the fig bars on impulse and was honestly blown away by the taste. Enough that I am very much looking forward to trying the other varieties. For now though, I'm sticking with the fig bars that are my new favorite.

Loading...